@podpodAFL Of this 10 I personally split them into 3 groups.
Won't touch to start: Miller, Greene, MacDonald, De Goey, Ginnivan
Might consider: Bailey, Petracca
Will strongly consider: Hall, Wilson, Richards
@TheBackPocketAU Your honor, stabbing was only a financial crime for 60 years and my client did it thrice. Now he's lived 75 years and it's only just been made so that you go to jail for it and, what do you know, he's stabbed someone again. But I promise you, he's a good guy!
Reasons:
In regard to whether 'exceptional and compelling circumstances' provision can apply to Neale's benefit.
We find that the Tribunal did err in having regard to whether the conduct was intentional.
We accept the position of Neale in his written submissions that the intentional aspect was an element of the charge which had already been established.
The relevant inquiry was whether, despite the charge having been established, there was exceptional and compelling circumstances.
In this case, that was Neale's record.
We find that Neale's record is exemplary, and that he should be afforded the benefit of the provision.
In conclusion, we allow the appeal.
We order that Neale instead be fined $10,000.
@FOXFOOTY Anderson (Lions) notes the Tribunal didn't explicitly mention in its reasons Neale would be missing a Grand Final. He argues that implies the Tribunal didn't consider it relevant to the decision.
@MatterOfStats@fuzzybluerain A rating difference of 0.096 coming into this grand final. Where does this rank for differences between the grand final teams since 2000?