Lefty but not a tankie. Studied Russian and Near Eastern history. Lived in Russia for 7 years. I will have a civilised conversation even if we disagree. πΊπ¦π΅πΈ
The West was painfully slow getting weapons into Ukraine in the first year; they were convinced it would fold when Russia invaded. I don't see how Russia invading makes it a Nato war; they eventually began supplying the Ukrainians with artillery shells and anti-air defence, at the request of Ukraine's elected government.
I can agree that Nato countries are complicit with what the Israelis have done, I don't think anybody can disagree.
Gaza and Ukraine are apples and oranges though. Ukraine can defend itself, the Palestinians can't. You might understand my position if you had lived in Russia and seen what it's like under Putin.
Two things can be true: I can support tge EU's policy towards Russia and not its policy towards Israel. That isn't symping.
Sanctions target states and individuals in executive roles serving those states. Chay could have gone solo, published his opinions and not taken Russian money and he would have been fine.
He was sanctioned because of working for a Russian state-owned body (RT). It has nothing to do with freedom of speech nor is this new. Back in 2022, EU citizens in executive roles at Russian state-owned companies faced sanctioning if they didn't reprise their roles. https://t.co/LZcYEEo8Bc
Ewan, it has nothing to do with free speech. Chay has been sanctioned because he works for a state owned company (RT); the same sanction was used against EU citizens working in executive roles at Russian state-owned oil companies and the likes. They were forced to resign or suffer the consequences.
As for media in the EU. Journalists regularly criticise their own governments without consequence.
The sanction in question has nothing to do with freedom of speech. It was used in 2022 against EU citizens working in executive roles in russian state-owned companies to force them to resign or face consequences. Chay has been sanctioned because be has continued working for a Russia. state-owned company, though why they didn't sanction him sooner is anyone's guess.
For the last time, Chay Bowes was not sanctioned for his political opinions; it's because he works for RT which is state-owned. The sanction in question dates back to 2022 and applied to EU citizens who worked in executive roles for Russian state-owned companies. They resigned or faced sanctions like Chay.
@cox2_edel@hussedogru Sanctions have nothing to do with court. Dogru is on the sanctions list because of Red Media's financing originating from RT which is owned by the Russian state.
Rinse and repeat
It has nothing to do with freedom of speech, it has everything to do with limiting the Russian government's ability to achieve its goals abroad. Bowes works for RT, which is state-owned. The same sanctions apply to him as they did to individuals working for other Russian state-owned companies.
https://t.co/LZcYEEo8Bc
He's being sanctioned because he is sponsored by the Russian state via RT. The sanctions, like the rest, are simply aimed at limiting Putin's government from achieving its goals in the current context.
Sanctioning EU citizens isn't new, by the way. In 2022 EU citizens, including Irish, working for Russian state-owned companies were threatened with sanctions unless they reprised their roles.
Here's one example: https://t.co/2eEjN8rzoSβ¦
@eoinmauricedaly@JohnOBrennan2 Further to my last comment, here's an example of an Irish citizen being threatened with sanctions for similar reasons: https://t.co/4nJ3Tm5a1P
@eoinmauricedaly@JohnOBrennan2 It's not the first time this has happened either. European citizens, Irish included, working for Russian state-owned companies were threatened with sanctions unless they left their roles. This was in 2022.
@EwanMacKenna He's state sponsored, that's why. It's nothing new. European citizens, Irish included, working for Russian state-owned companies were threatened with sanctions unless they left their roles. This was in 2022.
I never thought I'd see the day where members of the far left defend someone who is clearly on the far right of the political spectrum.
As for me, I would favour sanctioning state sponsored propagandists from Israel as well. Also, Bowes hasn't been convicted as a criminal. That's not what sanctions are. I think we have to assume that they know enough about him to justify freezing his bank accounts.