@MarveledImran@shia_notes How can you say it's not based in the Fiqh when some of the biggest scholars of the School like Ibn Junayd Al Iskafi amongst the early ones or Ayatollah Mutradha Kashmiri amongst the Mutakhireen have the same opinion. That such a marriage is impermissible.
Narrated that Imam Sadiq (as) said,
"Whoever knows that We say nothing but the truth, then he should be content/satisfied with what he knows from Us.
And if he hears from Us something that contradicts what he knows, then he should know that it is Our way of protecting him."
From Tafsir al Ayyashi,
Regarding the statement of Allah most High:
Indeed Allah enjoins justice (عدل) and kindness (إحسان), and generosity towards relatives (إِيتاءِ ذِي الْقُرْبى), and He forbids indecency(فحشآء), wrongdoing(منكر), and aggression (بغي). (16:90):
@SayyidAliAbbas@BoyismStudent@TahaNaqvi114 You know this would go alot smoother if you'd articulate how you define these esotericists which you're so critical of. As I asked of you to do previously brother.
@abuseyfain@TahaNaqvi114 That's a silly thing to say. It insinuates you know every Narration ever, and this isn't one of them. You could just ask you know
@3bdal7ujjah@abuseyfain@TahaNaqvi114 They will be punished, their punishment is deferred for wise reasons. But they will be punished. I can't send the narration here, too long. I'll DM some parts
@abuseyfain@TahaNaqvi114 There's other narrations saying the same for the Ghulat. That some of the Ghulat will be accepted and the Muqassirah will not be accepted. Both of These are for a specific mughali or Muqassir. We have general reports which allude to both being accepted too.
If They are Upon Ali jjh, they are upon Haqq. If they are away from Ali jjh, They are away from Haqq. The truth is but the Master a.s, and falsehood is everything other than the Master jjh.
The Pure Prophet (saww) established Mawlana Ali (jjh) to be the scale of Truth. And Indeed haqq is with Mawlana Amir (a.s), it follows the Master (a.s). Therefore whoever has Mawlana Amir (a.s) as their Master, be it the Shia of today, the Hindu of Old, the Persian, the Greek...
@muslim_modest@TahaNaqvi114 And some genuinely brainwashed indoctrinated morons would genuinely try to justify such an inhumane criminal animalistic behaviour. Or try to lessen it's severity. Heartbreaking
@SayyidAliAbbas@TahaNaqvi114 All of this is extremely subjective. There's nothing objective about this. And this reads extremely unbecoming of someone claiming a scholarly background
@SayyidAliAbbas@TahaNaqvi114 That's not how the religion works. Noone but the Thaqalayn are scales by which one measures right or wrong. No matter how closer in time or tabaqa to the Imams a.s. And you recognise their problems aswell, who's to say they weren't wrong in these matters.