According to Holger Zellentin, who has studied Rabbinic Judaism and Christianity, the Quran, "goes above and beyond what was done in the Bible and also in Jewish law by being more Equitable Visa women" and adopted Byzantine law reforms which reworked ancient Christian traditions to make them more equitable to Women.
Full blog post below titled "Why I Studied the Aisha Hadith for my PhD: Some Reflections on Religious Interpretation, Sunni Orthodoxy, and Islamophobia" October 28, 2022 by Joshua Little
https://t.co/ao6VGX35aN
Joshua Little chose to study the age of Aisha for his PHD dissertation as a result of leaving behind his Islamophobia
"Much more can be said on the ʿĀʾišah hadith, its history, and its implications, but for now, this will suffice. To recapitulate my own history and experience therewith: I first encountered the ʿĀʾišah hadith in a polemical New Atheist and Islamophobic context, in which the hadith is blamed for the occurrence of child marriage. Following the collapse of my Islamophobia and New Atheism, I continued my studies in early Islamic history and especially Hadith, culminating in an MPhil and a DPhil at the University of Oxford. When it came time to choose a topic for my thesis, I decided to return to the ʿĀʾišah hadith, this time looking at it from an academic perspective. The skeptical results of my research will be welcomed by some and not by others—and although I do cast doubt on a canonical Sunnī hadith, there are still ways for my findings to be reconciled with an orthodox Sunnī perspective, such that conflict is not necessary."
@InspiringPhilos@DelmanReads@sebconverted Presumably you wouldn’t have told a Muslim convert to ”move back to a Muslim country”, and so the reason you said it is clearly not just because he is a Muslim. But also because of his background.
@InspiringPhilos@DelmanReads And Nazi propaganda routinely framed Germany's aggressive policies and war efforts as acts of "self-defense" against an alleged global Jewish conspiracy
Just wildly racist stuff from @InspiringPhilos here. I haven’t heard this one since middle school. I can’t believe this is who y’all let represent a faith as compassionate as Christianity.
🚨 Every Muslim has a different journey with their faith. Different questions, different struggles, different ways of learning and growing.
Meet @MureedApp.
A new approach to personalized learning, built around and by you.
Your personality. Your journey.
More soon!
😭 some guy said in goudarzi’s replies he’s going to hell for publishing under Oxford. On a more serious note I’m personally looking forward to it. I found find his dissertation convincing but I didn’t fully buy into it and think there are some verses which challenge his hypothesis (3:3, 3:78-79, 5:47) I hope he addressed these verses in his book because I think the injil is very clearly called a kitab in 3:78 (although it is not specified).
Michel Cuypers argues internal abrogation in the Quran, in its immediate context, makes no sense as 2:40-123 is a long polemic against the people of the book and the use of the prior scriptures, so it makes more sense that 2:106 is referring to biblical verses being replaced.
He argues the central theme is the chosenness of the Jewish people and to an extent also the Christians. The Quran, being against religious exclusivity, claims to abrogate verses in the Torah which seem to suggest the that only Jews are favored by god and replace it better or similar verses.
In other words the Jews Claim to be gods Chosen people so no prophet could be sent amongst the Gentiles/Arabs, they"do not wish that any good should be sent down upon you from your Lord but God chooses out of his mercy whoever he wills". The Quran refutes this claim and abrogates the chosenness of the Jews and rectifies biblical verses.
Okay I’ve read this interpretation before that 5:47 is asking the followers of the gospel to judge by what god has revealed in the Torah/mosisac kitab. Why do you think this interpretation is more accurate than referring the the injil . It seems in light of 5:68 the “fihi” is towards the Gospel?
Holger Zellentin on the Quranic accusation of scriptural fasciation:
"it accuses the Israelites both Jews and Christians of having partially corrupted the law that was entrusted to them by textual alteration, addition, or misinterpretation, in the mould of the Clementine Homilies and other traditions that put their focus on the danger of satanic verses. The Quran thus presents itself as restoring the primary divine message, in which there is no doubt (Q. 2:2)"
🧵(1/25) Al-Shafi'i didn't single-handedly invent the usul al-fiqh. He was an important catalyst in the Islamic world shift toward hadith-centric legal theory, eventually leading to the creation of actual usul al-fiqh textbooks by Ibn Surayj & others a century later.