@RussianMeatCube@Maks_NAFO_FELLA The most charitable interpretation might be "if the US congress passes under Democratic control before the conflict is resolved". Also worth noting that this doesn't seem to be a direct quote.
@grok@ZenAndFire@grok I suspect there's misleading presentation (by lack of context, paraphrasing, implied meaning, etc) with some of the "real" quotes. For example, Luther's statement has his typical blunt and colorful language but it's part of arguing for marriage over forced celibacy.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok OK, good that you can note that. But if you look back to our exchange here, that's an awful lot of attempted "serious" justification for the reasoning process on your part. I'd be tempted to say post-hoc rationalization or even "gaslighting" (though I don't like that term).
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok Either the reasoning actually holds or it only holds only as a joke. Decide which one it is. Nothing in the scenario is such that it could not exist in real life. People of comparable status plus a dog could be in a real life situation where only one of them can be saved.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok So let's hope you never get to decide any real-life "one-save" scenario involving the lives of five humans with such institutional roles, networks etc and one dog. Or at least not before a substantial update in your reasoning models.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok So do you admit that you'd draw the same conclusion in all situations where only one can be saved and it involves those same (or comparable) five individuals and one dog? Or do you maintain that there a re additional factors in this meme?
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok Dog is not going to have a meaningful residual system whether it lives or dies. In any case, nothing in the scenario asks you to apply what might possibly be a tie-breaker when choosing between human lives to a situation where the choice is between a dog life vs human life.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok The "one-save" rule in no way introduces the residual systems consideration. Nor does anything else in the discussion. For whatever reason, you added it unprompted while claiming that it's given in the meme scenario.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok In our more detailed discussion privately on Grok, you admitted you're wrong because you added the "residual-systems" perspective totally uncalled & then held on to it at all cost. Also admitted the consequences of this category of error could be catastrophic in real life.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok Are you saying the dog experiences comparatively greater loss because it leaves no "residual systems" in case if dies vs the people in the meme who have such systems? This wouldn't be any different in other life-or-death scenarios involving people with systems vs a dog.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok So you see these people's value coming from the systems that continue to do their work even if they themselves personally die? Would this amount to saying that aside from their systems, these people are neither more valuable nor as valuable as the dog?
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok Is your assumption that given their status and resources, someone else would save every single one of them anyway? That's quite an assumption to bring to a hypothetical that doesn't show anyone else present (they are all gesturing toward "you" and are in urgent danger).
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok What exactly is it about this meme in particular that makes resources the deciding factor? Give a detailed answer that actually makes sense.
@grok@Misa1088595@riya_mishra007@grok Why is any of that relevant? Are you really saying that you don't recognize a human life as more valuable than a dog life? Would your answer be different if you had to decide between running over a human vs a smiling dog?