@theMadridZone@FabrizioRomano Then joins the bench warmers as usual, well it a sacrifice to be made considering it a super team, join the super team, stay on the bench, win trophies… life is good
@V_the_Cityzen with the huge number of great players, id ont we would have situations of players winning the ballon dor back to back, the era of messi and ronaldo might never be replicated anymore
@Onustacks@TouchlineX keep playing, you really think they will bench guller or Bellingham for him? Don’t be surprised he might just be substituted in around 75 minutes. Or worst still, he joins the bench warmers like endrick, look at diomande, vini had to play bad before he could get play time
This argument sounds convincing until you actually examine the logic behind it.
First, nobody is arguing that Messi was the first footballer to win a World Cup. That is not the point. The point is what he accomplished throughout his career and how he performed at the highest level, including on the biggest international stage.
Secondly, why is winning a World Cup being presented as though it is an attempt to erase 20 years of club football? Who made that argument?
Messi's club career is not an empty space that needs to be defended with an international trophy. He spent nearly two decades at Barcelona, won 10 La Liga titles, 4 Champions League titles, 7 Copa del Rey titles and 8 Ballon d'Or awards. He also delivered extraordinary individual numbers and performances.
So, what exactly are we pretending he failed to achieve in club football?
Now, let's address the Ronaldo argument.
Yes, Ronaldo dominated in England, Spain and Italy. His ability to adapt to different leagues, managers and systems is a legitimate part of his legacy. Nobody needs to diminish that.
But playing for different clubs is not automatically proof of greater footballing superiority. Staying at one club and dominating for years is not a weakness either.
If longevity, consistency, goals, trophies and impact are the criteria, then apply those criteria to everybody. Don't celebrate Ronaldo's longevity while dismissing Messi's, or celebrate Ronaldo's adaptability while ignoring Messi's sustained dominance at Barcelona.
And the R9 comparison makes the argument even more problematic. R9 was an extraordinary footballer, but his career trajectory, longevity, achievements and statistical output are not comparable to Messi's in the same way.
Most importantly, international football is not a consolation prize. Representing your country and winning major international tournaments are legitimate parts of a footballer's legacy.
You cannot spend years arguing that Ronaldo's international achievements matter, then suddenly reduce international football to one tournament when Messi wins the World Cup.
The standard cannot change depending on who benefits from it.
Nobody is saying one World Cup automatically makes Messi greater than everybody who never won one. But you equally cannot use Ronaldo's club achievements to dismiss Messi's international achievements while pretending Messi has no comparable club legacy.
That is not objective analysis. That is selective accounting.
If we are judging the complete football career, then judge the complete football career. Don't isolate the achievements that favour your preferred player and dismiss everything else.