@jdlichtman Nice result!
Would you mind if I tried this problem with my AI agents to see what they come up with, or would you prefer that I wait until you’ve posted the paper?
Here is a pdf file containing this counterexample
https://t.co/y0JuUCEAj3
The old chat address got "unshared" accidentally, so I am sharing chat again with new address
https://t.co/xCVvRZ5gGt
Grok built a short counterexample to Problem 7.4 in Figalli–Guerra–Kim–Shahgholian https://t.co/uQMnsVZy1K
I want to explain it a little, because the example is cute and it was a bit surprising.
A harmonic function on a domain that vanishes on an open subset must vanish everywhere. Geometrically: if it maps an open set to a single point, then it maps the entire domain to that point.
A variational way to think about it is by minimizing the Dirichlet energy: the minimizer of the integral of the square of its gradient, with fixed boundary values, is a harmonic function. For vector-valued harmonic maps, the Dirichlet energy is the integral of the sum of the squares of the gradients of each component.
For these vector-valued harmonic maps, there is a stronger geometric statement: if an open set is mapped into a smooth curve, then the entire image lies in a straight line. In particular, rank at most one (of the matrix of first derivatives) on an open set implies rank at most one everywhere.
Now introduce an "obstacle": require the map to stay outside a given body, allowing contact with its boundary, and minimize the energy subject to this constraint.
Problem 7.4 asks whether rank at most one still propagates when the body is convex. The authors had already constructed a counterexample for a non-convex body.
Grok shows that the answer is negative even when the body is a ball https://t.co/gA8PprHMyV
@haider1 Any predictions about solving an open problem are pure speculations.
There is no “genius” who is exempt from this rule. Anyone confidently making such predictions simply has a huge ego -- which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, especially if you’re a problem solver by heart.
@lazy_grad@ElliotGlazer He correctly estimated what these models could do and had the courage to push on this problem while almost everyone else was still betting the Riemann Hypothesis wouldn’t fall until 2027+ (especially some fields medalist!)
1) 2030 Fields Medal committee should award Levent, or they should disband.
2) Levent's prompting as presented in his timeline was reflective of serious centaur math, him making high-level judgments with immense details left to Claude.
3) The following gen prolly oneshots it.
If you make a discovery, don’t hesitate to share it on X just because it might seem less important than the Riemann hypothesis.
There is no ranking of open problems in mathematics--no one can truly judge which ones matter most and which ones are harder (about open problems!).
Whether you’ve been grinding for years or thinking for an hour, your problem could be harder than RH -- even if nobody else has heard of it.
I hope momentum keeps going and that AI solving RH won’t discourage us from sharing our own discoveries. I’m always curious to hear about them.
@santygegen How would they even know which problems would actually excite me or my colleagues? Some people publish their favorite open-problem lists. I never did. Most of us never did. So no free target lists. :D
Being excited about a solution to the Riemann Hypothesis while watching the market crashing is just mathematicians’ version of “don’t stop, it hurts so good.”
Btw Alessandro Masullo proposed a proof of GRH several months ago that has been under review by Brian Conrad "... and it is so far looking good." https://t.co/mHup5jGfd5
Some are claiming that AI has solved the Riemann Hypothesis.
2026 may mark the beginning of a new era, one in which machines outperform humans at intellectual tasks.
Okay, here is a problem for testing AI. You do not need to know any abstract mathematics to understand the statement, only how to add and multiply 1’s and -1’s.
I am offering a monetary prize for a correct solution, paid via X Money on X. I will also check the proof myself and retweet it. If the solution truly impresses me, I am happy to increase the prize.
The question arose almost accidentally while I was working on something else. I remember spending around five hours thinking about it without finding a solution. It is also one of my least-upvoted questions on:
https://t.co/HNy06Awdbk
It appeared before AI became good at mathematics, so this is a fair challenge: can AI beat roughly five hours of human work?
The rule is simple: the solution (share the full AI transcript) must be purely AI-generated, with no substantial mathematical hints from a human.