Pierre

1897/2000w

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@ACHwithaH @thedose__ Keays hate is a casual take.

0 score involvements from Laird as a negative, yet forgets 5 from Keays 8 touches

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@_raymondwill Trail shoes make great golf shoes if you don't need to dress up

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@BenjiNaesen "Yeah he's won a Grand Tour but what has he done lately"

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@DogsBreakfastFC

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@DogsBreakfastFC Lifts the arms/ball into the tackle which is considered prior, means it's must be a disposal and not an attempt

It's quick but there, one of the very few areas with decent consistency this season

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@TheBackPocketAU @bazz_27 Came off a Sydney boot towards goals no? Well within his rights to tap it through, let alone fumble a wet ball. Extremely harsh

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@onepercentas Hell of a tweet in a game containing C Curnow

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@_raymondwill @brysondech @ACameronWRX

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@themongrelpunt @FootyfanRoberto It's not though, Jackson starts the tackle as the Geelong player is still in the process of gathering that ball. If any attempt that isn't a legal disposal in this sort of scenario is called players will very quickly not aim to take possession first

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@jakksynn @hasumpstuffedup @themongrelpunt He's basically being tackled before he even takes possession, HTB here would be unworkable for any contested ball winner.

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@Bigkev87 @hasumpstuffedup @themongrelpunt It's not considered prior but without the ball being pinned you need to make a genuine attempt to dispose of it, which happened here.

No prior and no attempt (ball not pinned/arm free) would have been HTB in this scenario

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@ZingCochrane @JoshJenkins24 How'd he end up in the goal square all alone so often?

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@Sivixio28 @JADelaideX Push in the back and pushing into a contest aren't the same rules mate, might need to brush up on a few things yourself

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@Sivixio28 @JADelaideX Hands in the back of a player cutting across you vs shoving someone about to jump at a contest (then not getting the ball)

Are we banning the action only based on results? Naughton in the clear because Murray didn't have enough of a collision with Weightman?

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@Sivixio28 @JADelaideX I mean you could post the slightly longer cut that shows him track the ball all the way to the contest
https://t.co/mL6Vk4KJeY

[7AFL @7AFL]

Taylor Walker gave away a free kick in this incident 👇

#AFLCrowsCats

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@Sivixio28 @JADelaideX When you say involved you must mean pushes then doesn't compete for.

And when you say Tex wasn't looking at the ball you must mean tracked it the entire way to the contest right?

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@Bmwils11 @hasumpstuffedup @MattWalshMedia Technically how?

You'd be going through 5m of protected area to get to the mark, which isn't allowed anywhere else on the ground

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@hasumpstuffedup @MattWalshMedia Is there some secondary aspect to this rule for set marks/shots?

There will be plenty of uncontested marks i50 with players outside the protected area, but they're then allowed to stand the mark when set by the controlling umpire.

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@VardyMagic That Dempsey shrugged tackle was excellent, had both arms pinned and just shimmied out of it.

An inside mid, built like a key forward, with the tank of a winger, absolute 🦄

[Pierre @PeterScaife3]

@oz_addy @mccaffriedion @1116sen And according to the AFL as of last week, if it was incorrectly called a point and play had begun it would not have been brought back just to keep the game going.

Can't imagine why people would be miffed though...