The Pope’s meaning was obvious. And this way of interpreting speech makes it fundamentally unintelligible.
Conservative Catholics: Ah yes, the pope said “those who wage war” but of course meant “those who wage unjust war.”
Lib Catholics: See, the Pope condemns war.
Catholics must, of course, understand the Pope’s meaning in the full context of the deposit of faith. We recall, for instance, that the Church celebrates an annual feast to commemorate God’s hearing the prayers of a pope and saint as he waged war on Muslim invaders at Lepanto.
In a free market system corporations only supply goods which meet the demands of the masses. That is the consumers are in charge of what goods get made because corporations are ultimately responding to demand.
If corporations are selling people slop, it’s either because the people want slop or because government intervention in the market is preventing corporations from meeting demand.
@nolibertarians You have to account for the additional productivity the data center creates. Companies that use the data center’s services increase productivity among their employees increasing capital for the company and wages for their workers.
@KlasNio@redeemed_zoomer If you’re not dating with the intention of marriage then you shouldn’t be dating.
If you are dating with the intention of marriage you shouldn’t be dating someone you shouldn’t marry.
We’re not misrepresenting your stance, your stance is just wrong.
An ACLU-backed coalition of plaintiffs is hell-bent on stopping the city of Quincy, MA from installing statues of two Catholic saints on its new public safety building.
So far they're winning---but @becketfund isn't backing down and vows to continue defending Quincy’s right to honor its heroes.
Yeah, it is very obviously better to work with people on the other side of the LGBTQ issue to do things like pass resolutions that ban polygamy or require preachers to believe in God, than it would be to refuse to work with them and never accomplish anything because you can’t get the votes.
People don’t understand that in a parliamentary system you have to build momentum towards big changes - you can’t go from extremely liberal to extremely conservative. You have to win over the moderates to push out the extremist on the other side. With the extremist gone who is moderate shifts to the right and you repeat until you get actual conservative policies. That process requires for settling for less than ideal policies in the interim and not fighting every battle at once.
I’d be happy to, but first I noticed the world christian encyclopedia from which you obtained your 10,000s figure includes several hundred catholic denominations which disagree with each other and include many theological inventions no Christians believed before 1800. Would you care to share which of the hundreds you bet your salvation on?
His post is based on a single survey from 2023 which is an obvious outlier.
The corporate election study for the years 2022-2024 found
2022 20% Protestant 15% Catholic
2023 19% Protestant 21% Catholic
2024 22% Protestant 16% Catholic
The margin if error is roughly ±2% for each meaning in 2022 and 2024 the study showed more protestants than catholics by a margin of 5% and 6% respectively- both beyond the margin of error. While he is relying on the 2023 study showing Catholics ahead by 2% - well within the margin of error.
@dog_domain@MartinP49146517@OrdinariateUSA His post relies on a single outlier survey from 2023 - the corporate election study. The corporate election in 2024 found gen z to be approximately 22% Protestant and 16% Catholic. He’s is obviously cherry picking.
This relies on data from the 2023 corporate election study. The 2024 corporate election study found gen z to be approximately 22% Protestant and 16% Catholic. The fact that you are relying on a single outlier survey 2023 when there are more recent surveys available demonstrates your claim is not rooted in data.
A stronger line of argumentation would be to argue RZ is correct that Rutherford would consider schism but that he doesn’t go far enough as Rutherford rejected the notion of two true churches having jurisdiction in the same area.
When RZ argues that the nature of the United States amends the view allowing multiple “mainline jurisdictions,” you should then propose the 1788 Revision of the WCF to function as the “traditional presbyterian view on how the church should function in a nation with freedom of religion” rather than speculate about how Rutherford would adapt his view. Then argue what constitutes schism from that document and its drafters.
The weakness in RZ’s argument is he to maintain a version of Rutherford’s conception of jurisdiction while rejecting Rutherford’s conception of church and state. You should argue the two are necessarily linked and incorrect. This will be convincing because most people already disagree with Rutherford’s conception of church and state.
This strategy puts him on the defensive by forcing him to reconcile inconsistencies in his own viewpoint while you advance the traditional presbyterian standard in the US via the 1788 revision.
When Romanists need “Protestant” to refer to the smallest number possible — it’s the narrowest grouping possible that makes the cut.
When Romanists need “Protestant” to refer to the largest possible number to try and say it’s a mass of metastasizing confusion — four gazillion denominations — all of a sudden it’s the largest possible sampling needed to argue.
How convenient.
That you’re correct regarding the historic Presbyterian church view is virtually incontestable by anyone who’s read Westminster divines and their contemporaries. However I’d encourage you to engage more with the traditional congregationalist rebuttal against the concepts of a national jurisdictions and organized visible churches beyond the congregation; particularly those expressed by John Owen in his “The True Nature of a Gospel Church and It’s Government.”