That looks so heartbreakingly sad! Why is the baby elephant alone?
So, if the baby elephant is born right there why not let the baby elephant breastfeed from the mother elephant. The baby can be supplemented with feedings but why not let the baby breastfed by the mother elephant? It’s tough for elephants to live in zoos why not let them have at least a little bit of solace?
#TheBuckStopsHere with @PadmajaJoshi | "The book is full of half-truths": author and columnist Shobhaa De (@DeShobhaa) on Sonia Gandhi's memoir, adding that it is being "hyped up"
Why do they kick, scream, and throw a tantrum every time we tell them no civilization altering invasion or migration ever happened. We know small numbers of people from outside came sometime but we’re thoroughly assimilated. Indian civilization developed independently and indigenously and influenced the premodern world in multiple ways. #NoAryans
Haha. Rajdeep was mocking journalists for attending "Diwali Milan" of PM Modi.
Here he is greeting and passing smiles at Sonia Gandhi's book launch. Hypocrisy at its peak?!
#NoAryans#NoYamnaya replacement in India
Euro-centric scholarship projects European history onto India. Don’t fall for their half baked theories.
For example, the recent hypothesis about Yamnaya spread and replacement is more consequential to Europe than India.
1. Yamnaya and their Caucusus to European links and replacement of European population
Yamnaya male genome is dominated heavily by specific haplogroups, notably R1b
Studies published in Nature and Science revealed that Yamnaya-derived male lineages swept through Bronze Age Europe, replacing up to 90% of native Y-chromosome lines in places like Britain and nearly 100% in Iberia within a few centuries, even as local maternal (mtDNA) lines survived to a greater degree
2. Yamnaya related genetic heritage R1b is rare or absent in India
aplogroup R1b is generally very rare or largely absent across most of the Indian population, with average frequencies estimated to be around 1% to 5% in broad South Asian genetic surveys, and often near 0% in many specific regional or ethnic groups.
#NoAryans
1. Languages is not race. The linguistic theory is insufficient to explain Aryan race or their invasions or migrations. Nowhere was the term “Aryan” used as a race in the Vedas. It was just Arya that was found in the Vedas which signifies knowledge, refinement, or respect.
2. Lactose intolerance or tolerance is not linked to race or language. Indo-European language is not linked to lactose tolerance or intolerance. The European nations with Indo-European languages like Greece and Italy also have high lactose intolerance when compared to northern India.
3. And genetic history completely disproves the false Aryan invasion or migration theory.
#NoAryans
#NoAryans
What’s the date of the Vedas?
They decided it takes 200 years for something to go from oral record to literary record. This is based on their Bible experience. But they overrule the fact that the gap for oral to literary record might be different in the ancient world.
Do you think the evidence of Mittani inscription is enough to fix the Vedas at 1500 BCE based on the assumption that it takes 200 for oral record to transition into literary record? But the Vedas still remain oral so how does one reconcile with that? How can one fix that date of origin of something that refuses the rules of oral to literary transmission?
What is female deity? Why can’t you say the Goddess? Do you know how misogynistic you sound?
There are more goddess temples in India and more goddess worship going on in India every day. The only one who comes close to this huge number of Goddess temples is Hanuman ji.
So, their old techniques to smear the goddess didn’t work so now they are trying to say “‘female deity’ is represented less”. Do they hear themselves. It’s so lame. Hinduism is the only major world religion with significant theological, ritual, and spiritual significance attributed to Goddess.
Is this guy from east coast of India where the goddess is supreme? From Kamakhya to Vijayawada Kanakadurga to Madhura Meenakshi to Kanyakumari the east coast is full of Goddess temples.
Is this guy from Odisha? Did he ever visit the Jagannath temple at Puri and others? Goddess Subhadra is in the center. Isn’t it important?
Are these guys going senile? What’s wrong with these people?
Don’t use the terms AANI and AASI
We don’t have two different ancestors, we only have one ancestor, our Founders 73KYA. I don’t know how they can make these false theories.
For history chronology is important. The fact the U2 clades are spread across India should put these AASI and AANI to rest. The ancestors are not divided on the modern lines.
They coined the new artificial terms AANI (Ancient Ancestral North Indians) and AASI (Ancient Ancestral South Indians) to replace previously used artificial terms Aryans and Dravidians. What does that even mean? The northern Indians have different ancient ancestors? The southern Indians have different ancient ancestors than the northern Indians? How is that even possible for ancient ancestors? No evidence for it in ancient genetic history. The female genome mtDNA M occurs in northern India while the male genome YDNA C occurs in southern India and the descendants and descending genetic history is equally spread across India. (By the way- it’s not north India but northern India and not south India but southern India- change the usage!)
They used the new artificial term AASI to replace the Aryans and the AANI to replace the Dravidians. They think this is a great trick to keep the Aryan vs. Dravidian divide on life support for another century.
But what they don’t realize is the ancient world didn’t follow their artificially created divides. The ancient world of India was built on indigenous peoples spread across the land. The ancient genetics are well spread across India. The Rakhigarhi maternal clade is found across India and in different social groups spread across northern and southern India, so, No AANI And AASI divide there! Luckily our ancestors travelled across the land and didn’t care much for the divide that these people designed in the 20th and 21st century world.
We don’t have separate northern ancestors and another separate southern ancestors. That theory is false. We all come from the same founders mtDNA M and YDNA C dating to 73KYA (Thousand Years Ago). India is #FoundersZone we all come from the same Founders. There might be mutations that evolved over the millennia across India but not because of different ancient ancestors. The differences might be the result of mutations but not necessarily different ancestors.
@GeetaSikand It’s the name of the town with Sindhu-Saraswati civilization where the skeletons were excavated. Historians are not very creative with names- we just name things or events after the place or the date.
Here is the statement from their Harvard guru after our Rakhigarhi genetic evidence proved it beyond doubt that Indians are indigenous and Indian civilization developed indigenously India.
For history chronologically development is important not percentages.
Modern genetic evidence (that is based on what we carry) established that our genetic heritage is derived from our Founding ancestors 73 KYA (Thousand Years Ago). There is a linear evolution from the Founders Male C and Female M to our generation through genetic history.
The next step was to find Ancient genetic evidence and see if it supports this linear continuity within our genetic history or was it broken by some invasions or migrations. So they got the skeleton that roughly corresponds to that period (1900-1600 BCE).
They really hoped to find some evidence to support their invasions or migrations theory. But, alas! Our Rakhigarhi grandmother from 16000 years ago showed an indigenously evolved genetic clade U2B2. This genetic clade evolved in India is entrenched and found among a variety of populations including many castes and tribes (see my paper on genetic history to understand the linear evolution and spread of this clade among Indians).
So, all their hopes of finding some invasion or occupation were dashed to the ground. They retreated their theories of invasions and migrations occupying, destroying our original culture to impose their culture that they claimed to have brought with them. Rakhigarhi grandmother showed them the facts to the contrary. All our culture evolved indigenously from the individuals living in India.
They began saying “some people like Greeks and Persians came later”. Sure, they might have come. But that’s not an issue because the came with love and admiration for India. They assimilated so much into Indian culture that they learned Sanskrit, became Hindus of Buddhists, and lived happily in India. They are as Indian as indigenous Indians were. Some Hindu temples of 400 BCE and Buddhist stupas contain the dedicatory inscriptions of these Indianized Greeks and Persians.
So, no! No one from outside conquered or occupied India to impose their culture on India. If anyone came, they came and assimilated.
The central question here is did any alien group invade or migrate to India between 1900-1600 BCE to alter and impose their culture on India? The resounding answer is in negative.
Indian civilization is developed indigenously in all its aspects through the centuries meticulous process by the indigenous people living in India. It is a marvelous feat to preserve the Vedas over millennia!
All their falsehoods are exposed!
Question #ColonizedMinds #ReclaimHistory
The Many Ugly Forms of Aryan myth: Aryan is the Demon Raktabija of Indian history. It raises its ugly head in a new form every time it is slayed.
I. Original Aryan invasion theory: Invasion-Conquest-Occupation (1900-1600 BCE)
They said: “Some pure Aryan men from the Steppes invaded with iron weapons riding horse drawn chariots conquering India: killed all men and married their women, gave Vedas, Sanskrit, and founded the Indian civilization teaching the indigenous people agriculture and culture.”
Their conclusion: “India owes everything it considers as its civilization to these barbarian conquerors. Indians created nothing- they were just uncivilized gullible folks who adored and learned everything from their conquerors”.
This was disproved through vigorous research:
1. No pure race called Aryans and no large advanced civilization in the Steppes to advanced marching band of young men riding horses into India.
2. Agricultural evolution and domestication of animals, plants etc indigenously developed
3. Iron is found in India datable to 2400-1800 BCE, long before Iron was used anywhere in the world.
4. Horses in India are domesticated in India and a different Asian horse so they were brought from outside was proven false.
5. Sanskrit and Vedas originated in India, no evidence they were brought from outside.
As soon as invasion theory was disproven they started migration theory.
II. They said: “Bands of Aryans migrated into India over time- then composed Vedas and taught language and civilization to indigenous peoples. Migrations-imposed their culture”.
Disproven again because it lacks coherent evidence. If they came as migrants of small bands of men, they should leave some archaeological evidence. But no cultural or archeological evidence.
III. They are saying: “They just came later- we don’t know what they did.”
After the genetic history arrived all these theories of invasions or migrations were disproven. So at this stage they just want to hang on to their belief that “some outsiders came later”. No archeological, genetic or cultural evidence is available so they just use their old linguistics and now lactose intolerance.
If they just came later after Indian civilization is comfortably established in India developed all its major features what is their argument?
Why do they need this “western people came to India” theory? What is their point? They just don’t want Indians to be decolonized. They want to control your mind forever.
* The skeleton is Indus Valley skeleton so about 4KYA to 3.5KYA but it carried the genetic heritage that evolved in India 16000 years ago. Thus, disproving anything abrupt invasions or migrations arriving into India replacing it as it established long historical evolution in situ.
That’s because it goes through mutations with every few generations- we all carry some form of it’s mutation- that’s all non-Africans. Indians have the oldest clade and also historically evolved genetic heritage from the first Founders. Do you think it stays same after 73KYA? Take a basic biology class and a history class.
Unscientific survey! Maybe! But I agree it’s close to the truth- not knowing our heritage or not knowing our true history is the biggest existential threat faced by Hindus. Our heritage and identity were hijacked by the colonialists. Our future depends on reclaiming our history/heritage.
My unscientific poll and the answers I received: what is the biggest existential threat faced by Hindus?
My own answer is apathy and indifference and finding an answer to that would help some of the other areas.