Roboam Dinzey Messina

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog Hi, under current rules, is it still true that cards like Grindstone or Palantír of Orthanc can determine information from the milled card if it's revealed but doesn't leave the library due to a replacement effect like Darksteel Colossus's?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog if I control The Darkness Crystal, and an opponent controls The Lord of Pain, and he would die, would I gain 2 life?

I'm concerned about where exactly is The Lord of Pain when the replacement effect is applied.

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog hi, I activate Vitality Hunter's ability, in response I cast Cytoshape so it becomes a copy of Hydra Broodmaster. When the ability resolves, will I create X tokens?

What if I activate Colossus of Akros's ability and do the same? Will I create 10 tokens?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog if I cast Demon of Catastrophes for its blitz cost and sacrifice Henzie in the process, will the Demon still have Blitz when it enters?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog Hi @Dunkatog, just in case you're not too busy, any update on this?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog If an opponent controls Blind Obedience and I cast an Overlord for its impending cost, would it enter tapped?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog @Dunkatog I see, so does that mean this ruling on Arixmethes is wrong?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

Hey @Dunkatog, there's a heated debate about this question: if Dress Down is in play, and you cast an Overlord for its impending cost, does it enter with time counters?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@WotC_Matt @Jenn_the_Judge @Dunkatog @JudgingFtW and here's Matt's answer about the Tidebinder and reflexive triggers.

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog @minor_deviation @JudgingFtW here's Jess's answer about the Tidebinder and delayed triggers. The original post was deleted but it was asking if Arena's behavior was correct when a delayed trigger was countered and the source lost all its abilities.

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog @Burning_Inquiry @VeggieWagonYee @Dunkatog Do we have an official ruling for [Aminatou, Veil Piercer] and enchantments with X in their mana cost?

Like, if I cast [The Meathook Massacre] for its miracle cost, can I choose the value of X to be 4, and cast it for just 💀💀?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog Do we have an official ruling for [Aminatou, Veil Piercer] and enchantments with X in their mana cost? Like, if I cast [The Meathook Massacre] for its miracle cost, can I choose the value of X to be 4, and cast it for just 💀💀?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Hanmac10 @magnusmagicus @Dunkatog @WotC_Matt @maro @maro254 @Hanmac10 @magnusmagicus Madness already triggered, and the trigger gives you permission to cast the card, so you can cast either face.

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@magnusmagicus @Hanmac10 @Dunkatog @WotC_Matt @maro @maro254 It's not about which face has madness. The card has madness. Period. When the trigger resolves, you may cast either face for its madness cost based on that face's mana cost. The front face's characteristics don't exist when you cast the back face, so there's no way to pay {B}

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Hanmac10 @Dunkatog @WotC_Matt @maro @Hanmac10 Following Dream Devourer's ruling, the madness cost is based on the mana cost of the face you cast. So you can cast the back face when the Madness trigger resolves, but paying that face's mana cost.

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@magnusmagicus @Hanmac10 @Dunkatog @WotC_Matt @maro @maro254 @magnusmagicus That reddit must be wrong. The madness cost is based on the mana cost of the face you cast. Just like the foretell cost given by Dream Devourer. Here's the ruling:

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@WotC_Matt @6YZsIDx @WotC_Matt What about 601.2c? Which happens way before the spell becomes cast.

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Jenn_the_Judge @Dunkatog @WotC_Matt Can we get a confirmation on this interaction?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@Dunkatog @Hanmac10 @WotC_Matt @Dunkatog but what cost would you pay? Does the Adventure even has a miracle cost? If it does, is it reduced too?

[Roboam Dinzey Messina @R0b0am]

@WotC_Matt @InfiniTokens Matt, what about this ruling in the release notes?