@DhruvPathak672@darkandcrude 6. Even granting beginningless consciousness, what establishes that the present person is morally responsible for an inaccessible previous existence's actions, and why is that arrangement just?
If cycle is indefinite, how did i got karma which is positive or negative.
END
@DhruvPathak672@darkandcrude 5. For Dvaita, however, the problem becomes sharper. If God eternally creates/maintains the conditions in which distinct souls experience different circumstances, then I can still ask: what grounds my responsibility for a karmic history I don't remember choosing?
@darkandcrude@DhruvPathak672 5) You don't remember’ doesn't prove the choice didn't happen. But ‘you don't remember’ also doesn't prove that the choice did happen. That's the burden of the person making the claim.”
@darkandcrude@DhruvPathak672 (4)My inability to remember drinking milk doesn't invalidate that.
But if you say, Your soul consciously chose this life before birth, where is the evidence that this choice occurred? And how do you establish that the pre-birth chooser is the same conscious subject who exists now
@darkandcrude@DhruvPathak672 (3) If you say I wanted milk at 6 months, there is independent evidence that the infant and I are the same continuous biological person: the same body developed continuously, there are photographs, records, other people's memories, causal continuity, etc.
@darkandcrude@DhruvPathak672 (2)But that's not the issue. The issue is how you establish that I made a particular choice before birth and that the chooser was sufficiently the same person as me now.
@darkandcrude@DhruvPathak672 Answering in series -
(1) “Not remembering something doesn't prove it didn't happen. I obviously existed as an infant even though I don't remember being one, and I may not remember what I did on 22 June 2017 either.
@DhruvPathak672@darkandcrude Explain pls. Because I think there would be a starting point of whole consciousness. In that time, you would have literally 0 karma. So was it your own choice or god choice to put in this system. If my own then I should remember it because it was my choice else god is responsible