Rakesh Prasad

Tax consultant

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

By accepting ₹23,649 crore relief to #VodafoneIdea, #DoT has now effectively admitted that #AGR calculation errors did exist. If calculation errors existed for one operator, principles of justice, equality and fair play demand that the same opportunity be extended to #BhartiAirtel, #TTML and every #telecom company adversely impacted by the flawed AGR regime.
The consequences of the order delivered by Justice Misra devastated the telecom sector by burdening companies not only with disputed dues, but also crushing interest, penalty and even interest on penalty. When a litigant had succeeded till the High Court, imposing such extraordinary liabilities after reversal by the Supreme Court was excessive and resulted in grave financial destruction. If the originating calculations by #DoT itself were defective, then the very basis of penal consequences stands seriously undermined.
From this also flows an equally important question — why should Government continue to hold equity in #Idea when circumstances leading to such distress were materially created by failures within the system itself? Instead of forced equity conversion, #Vodafone should now rightfully demand, and @narendramodi Government should accept, that #VodafoneIdea be allowed to pay spectrum dues and other liabilities in the ordinary course of business.
Not only should Government equity in #Idea be cancelled, reduced or readjusted to the extent of AGR correction and its consequential impact, but the company must also be given a fair opportunity to revive naturally. @AdityaBirlaGrp should examine all remedial measures in the upcoming #Idea board meeting.
Investors should note: the story of #Idea may be far from over.
They may remain invested or buy more for good gains . @JM_Scindia all your life you have stood for fairness now is the time to act .

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Yatin, the issue is that you and your channel @CNBC_Awaaz don’t miss an opportunity to undermine Vodafone Idea. A half-full glass can always be portrayed as half empty. Despite the various tactics employed by the Reliance group—whether provable or not—the impact is clearly felt. After all, if crookedness were easy to prove, it wouldn’t remain crookedness. From a relative standpoint, @AdityaBirlaGrp continues to command stronger public trust, whereas concerns around the credibility of your group persist in public perception. One of the brothers is already a cheater in the eyes of Public .
Interpret this announcement correctly, Birla’s stance signals renewed confidence in #VodafoneIdea’s revival. In markets, confidence itself is a powerful catalyst. A project of this scale demands upwards of ₹4 lakh crore in investment and a 3–5 year execution window. With his renewed commitment, potential subscriber gains, and parallel developments, a re-rating of Idea’s market cap to ₹4 lakh crore or beyond cannot be ruled out. You also buy #Vodafone #Idea it will give you better returns then #reliance . Investors may buy / hold #idea with an ultimate tgt of 3 digits in next 2 years @yatinmota @aseemmanchanda

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Boycott #lenskart , why should we let such companies grow with our money . The CEO agrees that these policies were there and were amended in Feb , now if at one time the policies were there then why should we let this company or mentality grow with our money . Teach them a lesson , avoid buying its product and exit its shares . Invest in any company of your choice buy #adaniPower with a tgt of Rs 250 , buy #REC for a tgt of 425 & sell #lENSKART , punish corporates who are against our culture , religion & are biased . They will live in our country , grow on our blood and then …….

Nations are built not only by governments, but by the choices of their citizens. Boycott #LENSKART

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

With an eccentric President ruling America, India must stay sharply focused inward. We have a massive domestic consuming class and immense scope for our industries. Every market shake-down is an opportunity to buy—fear creates value.

@narendramodi @nsitharamanoffc please concentrate on stopping the flight of capital. One critical step: do not allow early investors in Indian companies to exit at 5x, 10x, or even 100x returns at the cost of Indian public investors — #Paytm being a classic example.

Disinvestment at the IPO stage is not true market-led price discovery; it often becomes a playground for manipulators, speculators, corrupt fund managers, and complicit regulators.

Disallow such disinvestment in the proposed @reliancejio IPO as well & any other IPO, Otherwise, hard-earned Indian savings—directly or via banks, mutual funds, and DIIs—will be siphoned off, just as seen in the #RPOWER IPO.

This is the wake-up call. Time to rein in anti-India capital extraction and protect domestic investors.
@PMOIndia
@FinMinIndia @DIPAMIndia
@DeptofExpenditure @NITIAayog
@SEBI_India @RBI
@BSEIndia
@NSEIndia
@SansadTV
@loksabhaspeaker
@RajyaSabha
@StandingComFin
@Suchitapani
@ashishchauhan
@nileshshah68
@SamirArora
@PorinjuVeliyath
@EconomicTimes
@businessline
@FinancialXpress
@CNBCTV18Live
@moneycontrolcom
@IndianInvestor_
@InvestorsForum
@jagograhakjago
Time to introspect @aseemmanchanda

#ProtectIndianInvestors #CapitalFlight #FairIPOs #MarketReforms #SEBI #IndiaFirst

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

VODAFONE IDEA: Supreme Court clarifies that Vi’s plea covered both — relief on additional AGR dues and reassessment of all dues.
The Court has allowed the government to reconcile all Vodafone Idea dues, marking a major relief for the company.

Mr. @aseemmanchanda @_anujsinghal @CNBCTV18Live
A word of advice to the CNBC team: please avoid misleading or manipulative interpretations. Such reporting not only misguides investors but also undermines the credibility of your journalism and the institution you represent.

[Rakesh Prasad @RK9107]

Train no.12906 schedule to depart from shalimar West Bengal station at 8.20PM on 27.09.25 and now it is 8.45AM of 28.09.25 but train is yet to depart from origin station, This is not the type of service we expect from Indian Railway😥 @RailMinIndia @AshwiniVaishnaw @PMOIndia

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

The government can easily give #Idea a lifeline, as precedents exist. @_anujsinghal @CNBCTV18News & @aseemmanchanda, you call it “shooting the messenger,” but isn’t it time to address the real issue?

The Reliance Group has consistently leveraged government policies to its advantage.

Between 2003 and 2007, Reliance Infocomm acquired CDMA spectrum at nominal fees. Later, by manipulating policy, it converted these into dual-technology licenses, allowing it to offer GSM services for just ₹50 crore—far less than what other operators paid—resulting in undue gains of ₹40,000-50,000 crore.

By 2019, RCOM owed ₹46,000 crore to banks, which was effectively written off. Despite this, it managed to trade its spectrum with Reliance Jio. The same @DoT_India that now demands bank guarantees for spectrum dues had then overlooked such requirements. @JM_Scindia Even RCOM’s AGR dues remain uncollected despite a Supreme Court ruling. Eventually, RCOM went bankrupt, and its assets—including towers and fiber networks—were sold to @reliancejio for ₹5,000 crore, significantly lower than the ₹11,000 crore offer from Brookfield Infrastructure.

Reliance’s strategy extended beyond telecom. Jio’s free unlimited voice calls from September 2016 to March 2017—despite resistance from @airtelnews, #Idea, and #Vodafone—crippled competitors. Yet, market forces have their way of correcting imbalances. Eventually, Reliance had to sell a 33% stake in Jio Platforms for ₹1.52 lakh crore. While officially claimed to reduce debt, many believe these funds covered oil losses during COVID-19.

This pattern isn’t new. @reliancepower, despite having little real business, was once valued at ₹1.15 lakh crore and allowed to raise ₹10,000 crore at an inflated premium. The bubble burst, and by 2020, its market cap had plunged to ₹950 crore. SEBI talks about regulating financial influencers, yet top bankers and regulators endorsed this overvaluation without scrutiny. To this day, no one has been held accountable.

@AseemManchanda, @AnujSinghal, @CNBCTV18News—don’t you have a duty to expose such systemic manipulation? Shouldn’t the wrongdoings of bureaucrats, compromised judges, and dishonest promoters be addressed?

This is our country—we owe it to our motherland to uphold fairness. Even market analysts like @PrakashGaba, a regular on your channel, advised buying Idea at ₹16-17 with targets of ₹28 and ₹42, only to later recommend selling at ₹7-8. Is this responsible journalism?

While the Ambanis have exploited systemic loopholes, the media should not mislead the public. The rest, I believe, will be judged by a higher power. And no, this is not just about “shooting the messenger”—it’s about exposing a well-orchestrated game.@AdityaBirlaGrp present your case properly and manage Media , I am sure #Idea will win and so will 60lac + small investors whose hopes are alive . @narendramodi we expect a lot more from you .

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

The Telecommunications Ministry @JM_Scindia must step in to address and clarify misleading news reports that are demoralizing general investors in #Idea. Under the guise of journalism, unverified rumors are being spread—seemingly as part of a deliberate effort by vested interests to undervalue a 5G telecom company.

It is concerning that while the government has invested ₹3.25 lakh crore in BSNL for minimal returns, Vodafone Idea, with far superior capabilities, is being valued at just ₹50,000 crore, despite the government’s ₹16,000 crore equity exposure. Such a stark contrast raises serious concerns about fair market treatment.

The government must act swiftly to protect taxpayers’ money and correct the unfair treatment of #IDEA. Delayed decision-making is eroding investor confidence and does not reflect well on the administration. @AdityaBirlaGrp

Furthermore, biased reporting by media houses like @CNBCTV18News and journalists like @_anujsinghal @aseemmanchanda is damaging investor sentiment. Such tactics only diminish the credibility of your group in the eyes of retail investors. Responsible journalism is crucial, and we urge you to refrain from spreading misinformation.

@narendramodi, we request your immediate intervention to set things right.

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

I am amused when your channel flashes quoting mystery analists that company will left with only 1.5 month cash and if no funding then ..? . Bank guarantee which requires only 10% margin and can be had even without margin is being sold as actual 6090 cash shortfall . @_anujsinghal , both of you no doubt are employees of @Reliance group but you are also a reporter , pls don’t misguide or do clever reporting .

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

We are all loyal investors in the Birla Empire, especially placing our trust in KMB, as the group's direction relies on his leadership. Having invested our hard-earned money in #Idea FPO at Rs 11, our investments have now halved in value. If you truly believe in your own company, wouldn’t it be fair to undertake creeping acquisitions to align your stake with Vodafone UK? This move would provide much-needed reassurance to the many investors who have placed their faith in the legacy of late Shri G.D. Birla, Shri B.K. Birla, and Shri Aditya Birla—the pillars of Indian industry.

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Who has approved valuation of #Hyundai IPO. it’s again an OFS like PAYTM / NYKAA , nothing is going to the company but going into the pockets of promoters sitting in Korea .
Already they have taken out lot of money out of cash reserves just before IPO , increased royalty , additionally shares being offered to public had been allotted to promoters at 10 Rs only . Any promoter if bullish why would he sell his own shares , for growth of business one takes money in company . All in all wait and watch , if it’s that good then buy post listing . @nsitharaman are we turning into a banana republic, why our institutions are failing in protecting our mkts and investors . Are they hand in gloves with these strippers . Are we going to repeat #PAYTM , why we do not learn from
Our mistakes ? @RBI @BSEIndia @NSEIndia @CNBC_Awaaz @ZeeBusiness

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

One thing which I am unable to understand is , AGR’s Curative petition of #idea #Bhartiartl #ttml was heard at 1.30 PM and a decision was taken “ dismissed “ . This one word to upload took 20 days and meanwhile somebody in mkt not only sold but gave a sell tgt of Rs 2.5 . Now I believe that office of Supreme Court must have been compromised and somebody has pre-information and he used that to unload in mkt , create panic and earn out of it . Though there is always a possibility that everybody is innocent unless proved guilty but can someone answer why this one word order took 20 days to upload . In case of #IDEA where over 50 lacs shareholders are there step motherly treatment is being given to promote a single telecommunication company . Will our country despite getting freedom , still remain slave of someone . @arjunrammeghwal @reliancejio @AdityaBirlaGrp @airtelnews @LiveLawIndia @CNBC_Awaaz @ZeeBusiness @aseemmanchanda @YatinMota @VodafoneGroup @TataCompanies @BSNLCorporate control My Lords

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

They are making this mkt a gamblers den and helpless #SEBI under over competent #MADHABI #BUCH is watching , manipulative brokerages giving absurd targets and creating panic among investors . #GoldmanSachs #Gs bought 81lac + shares in #IDEA for 11 Rs in FPO and now giving tgts of 2.5 Rs , similarly in other companies absurd targets are being given . What is #SEBI doing @narendramodi @nsitharaman @RBI @DasShaktikanta , when the company is sitting on the verge of #AGR case order these dramas are being played to force poor investors into selling and unnecessary speculation. @CNBC_Awaaz @ZeeBusiness will you remain mute spectators to these manipulations .

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Idea has been removed from the approved list of securities eligible to be taken as margin /MTF funding for buying more shares or in F&O . Normally this practice is adopted for illiquid shares or virtually defunct shares so that at the time of losses Brokers/ exchange can recover its money by selling such pledged shares .
Then why suddenly Idea has been removed , it has been removed so that all those who were bullish in Idea and has taken leveraged position be forced to sell so that interested quarters can accumulate shares . Investors who have leveraged position as per rules of SEBI / NSE / BSE are being asked suddenly either to pay or sell . Be it @NSEIndia @BSEIndia #SEBI , all are hand in gloves with manipulators and they frame the rules as per the wishes of manipulators , it is for this precise reason , they didn’t took any action even when short positions were increasing disproportionately in Adani scripts in OCT 22 -JAN 23 #HINDENBURG episode @narendramodi @RBI @nsitharaman will you please stop these kinds of sudden changing rules of game and benefiting a class of individuals . Can @NSEIndia @BSEIndia explain what is the reason to take #Idea out of approved list . @CNBC_Awaaz @ZeeBusiness @ETNOWlive @AdityaBirlaGrp @VodaIdea_NEWS

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Share mkt is a place where you take calculated risk with limited capital & returns are in proportion to your risk till they are not suicidal .
For maximising returns in #telecom sector one can sell #Bhartiartl & buy #idea . You will get 100 shares of idea by selling one share of #airtel , after few months this ratio will reverse and you will get 2 shares of #Bhartiartl by selling 100 shares of #idea for if all the price hikes & AGR issues are resolved #idea have much more to gain then anybody , working wise also #idea will now gain subscribers more then any other telecom operator as the worst is over for it .
My take is one can buy/hold #idea for good returns irrespective of whether one sells #BHARTIARTL or not . Returns in idea will be proportionately more then any other telecom operator. Hope #SUPREMECOURT shows the same resilience as it has shown in giving bail to #kejriwal. @AdityaBirlaGrp pls engage @KapilSibal for quick redressal of our problem .

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

The whole #idea of price discovery is to measure the collective buying selling , public demand and supply and balance speculation . Yesterday NSE has discovered price of #idea at 9.07 am at Rs 11.80 but I and many more like me who had bid at higher prices , I bid at Rs 12.30 - Rs 12.50 well within stipulated time and have appraised @NSEIndia with my trade logs , despite over 122 cr shares traded but I was not allocated shares . Legally and systematically I should have got shares at Rs 11.80 but I was not allotted shares while few others shares who had put for sale at 11.80 were sold , this is also wrong as their shares should have been sold at a higher price as investors like me remained unallocated . There has been a big goofup either intentionally or technical failure . The exchange needs to compensate the traders as its responsibility of @NSE to trade fair . Both @CNBC_Awaaz and @ZeeBusiness @AnilSinghvi_ had raised the issue without any response from @NSEIndia . @pankajladha_ have raised in his U tube channel . @MadhusudanKela @ipo_mantra @_anujsinghal . I have raised complaint with @nse but they are yet to respond and compensate me and many like me . Have filled two complaints with all my valid trade logs and NSE exchange order nos but got receipt of one only . @nsitharaman @RBI request to act immediately as either it’s a systematic failure or calibrated fraud . @NSEIndia tried to side line this fraud in the name of technical fault and cancelling orders at 10.18 am whereas this manipulation has taken place at 9.07 am .

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Today I had put #IDEA shares for buying from 12.35 to 12.50 at 9.03 am . Although NSE settled it at 11.80 but I have not received a single share . @NSEIndia @nsitharaman @CNBC_Awaaz what’s happening @_anujsinghal pls see . @AnilSinghvi_ there has been a technical glitch , we have put shares and not recd , those who had put for sale have been sold . This needs to be checked . Small investors getting screwed .@RBI @ipo_mantra

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Idea promoters have allotted them selves shares at Rs 14.87 per share for 2075 crs,this can be a small amount as per @_anujsinghal and his thinking is #IDEA will come out with an OFS and it would be very difficult to sale its shares worth 18k crs even around Rs 11,I can understand their pain and concern as if #Idea rises from ashes then #RIL is hurt , but pls don’t fool public and go against your Dharma of giving news,you are giving biased opinions.I ask a question why will @AdityaBirlaGrp not be to raise funds through FCCB which can be converted after 3Yrs at a discount of 15% to mkt price,as this discount can be attributed to interest.If you buy 100 cr shares from mkt , price will sky rocket so who will give 900 cr shares at 11 Rs ( in anuj case 1700 cr shares ),all this despite @AshwiniVaishnaw claim
that lot of funds are willing to invest in indian telecommunication companies while discussing Idea. Pls don’t mislead public,already @CNBC_Awaaz you have many great achievements, which I keep on highlighting from time to time.Investors shouldn’t get carried away by these HOHO Channels as they may have good logic to defend but their intentions are malafide instead Buy/Hold #IDEA for good gains as it is moving to regain its old glory . One can also buy #INDUSTOWER for good again . https://t.co/1oS78nsEjE & https://t.co/xeF8Ad2nv6

[Ramesh Dugar @ramesh_dugar]

Can SEBI chief explain what were they doing when a ₹50Cr SME/midcap went Upto ₹5000Cr and when this froth was being created - what was the necessity to issue statement and crash the market - taking unsuspecting investors to ride because of spiralling effect? Why is that a paper company #RPOWER is allowed valuation of ₹1 lac Cr?
Why #PAYTM is allowed valuation of over ₹1.25 lac Cr when it has assets of only ₹9k crs? The share is now at ₹350 as against issue price of ₹2100! Same happened with #NYKAA which was allowed to raise ₹5k crs,it was valued at over ₹1 lac crs when its sales were less than ₹5000 crs & PE of 2000+ , Who approved all these issues? All these issues had sold for less than 15% of their issues price. Anil Ambani promoted #RPOWER whose shares were allotted at ₹405-450 sold for Re 1 - what a shame on so called financial experts, and SEBI watch dog! They are supposedly managing mkts and risks. Rather they are hand in gloves with market manipulators. They are the real threat! Will @RBI @nsitharaman @narendramodi see what is happening? Who will bell the cat? SEBI & @BSEIndia @NSEIndia manipulates the mkt by reducing/increasing margins, classifying them in ASM and removing them at their whims and fancies . All these actions are done to squeeze the buyers and not the manipulators. Once a share is distributed all these actions are acted upon. No doubt where money is involved all this will happen but then what is the role of a regulator - creating panic or saving? My request: take action against incompetent SEBI chief, stabilise rules, and no human intervention to apply at will. This will make India ₹5 trillion economy faster; not when these manipulators are allowed to manipulate.@CNBC_Awaaz @ZeeBusiness @ETNOWlive

[Rakesh Prasad @RK9107]

My mom and dad Travelling from Gaya to howrah in train no.13024 PNR 6531474522 coach no.B2 seat no.33 & 36. Some group of Students are forcefully occupied their seat and also misbehaving with them please look into the matter @RailMinIndia @AshwiniVaishnaw