You may have seen claims that Hitler stated,
"The only religion I respect is Islam. The only prophet I admire is the Prophet Muhammad.โ
A brief thread on the dubious origins of this quote and why it shouldn't be taken for granted.
@curnes_john@CivilPivot@GRNasake Why is child marriage allowed in the USA. Go to the muslim orthodox or muhammad hijab or ali dawah and type in on their channel aisha marriage at 9 and see how they will school you.Or sheikh uthman channel go see when people ask them about this infront of people or on live.
@ojaygoldro@CivilPivot@GRNasake Why is child marriage allowed in the USA. Go to the muslim orthodox or muhammad hijab or ali dawah and type in on their channel aisha marriage at 9 and see how they will school you.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake Read them all i can't call you to speak it out. As much dirt has been washed into your brain and sould you need as much bleach to clean it out.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake The Prophet acted within moral framework of his society Muslims believe he did not wrong Aisha. Whether that action should be replicated today is a separate legal and social question cuz Islamic law also takes into account readiness, welfare and the circumstances of local society
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake Muslim tradition also sees wisdom in the marriage beyond the social context. Aisha became one of the greatest scholars of Islam, narrating over two thousand hadiths and teaching many of the Prophet's companions after his death.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake In 7th century Arabia they didn't have numerical rules for age regarding marriage they looked at maturity. Everyone thought it was ok. Even the opponents of the prophet criticised him on things but not on this one.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake Don't judge local laws with your 2026 brain. It is unfair. Or else when in the bible it talks about killing women and children then you should condemn your bible? They was ancient tribes who looked at mental and physical maturity and it was enough.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake If you think he was objectively immoral, show what moral principle he violated at the time, rather than judging the 7th century solely by 21st-century standards.
Plus what if you was like them at that time. Everyone would think it is fair.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake I'm not saying it was right because everyone else did it. I'm saying there is no objective evidence that Aisha was harmed or that the marriage was considered exploitative in its historical context.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake The comparison with 19th-century laws misses the point. My argument isn't that something is moral because it was common. My argument is that Islam's criterion is readiness for marriage, not a fixed numerical age.
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake If you believe it was immoral, then explain what objective moral principle was violated at the time. Simply pointing to modern standards doesn't prove people 1,400 years ago were immoral
@Lando849003@CivilPivot@GRNasake Lets get infallible and fallible out of this for a sec. In 2026 and 1400 years ago marriage is determined by mental and physical maturity now it is not 18. But you don't know that child marriages are still allowed in nearly all american states still.