Anyone defending @habibi_uk (Ben Tait) is defending a person (Ben Tait) who says that a Jewish man (Holocaust survivor actually) is a 'creepy jewish figleaf' and a 'stain'. What do these terms signify? Here's one view on that:
@finner684@Dannythefink@Attatroll79 Daniel subsequently explained that a conspiracy to defend Israel is "obviously" a Jewish conspiracy. Perhaps you should tell him he's misunderstood his own argument too.
Thank you for contacting Daniel Finkelstein. Your question is important to us but will not be answered. Your enquiry has now been marked as resolved. Thank you for your understanding. Have a great weekend.
@Redistributeth1@Attatroll79 I’m sorry you don’t agree. Thanks for sharing your view. I’m sorry it isn’t possible to reach agreement on this occasion. Have a great weekend.
@StankBets@LSXYZ9@machineloling There is some logic to this; red - fight to show value, green - value depends on "honest" stats/items/levels, white - defenders/disengagers, value depends on what is added to teammates, blue - controllers/cc champs, black - assassins/roamers who profit from mistakes/unclean play
@Dannythefink@Attatroll79 So the political objectives of non-Jews make their activities Jewish? And you think it's everyone else who has a problem with antisemitic tropes?
@Dannythefink@Attatroll79 You just said it's "absurd" to suggest a conspiracy to promote Israel could be anything other than a "Jewish conspiracy". Why does the political objective make the conspiracy Jewish, Daniel?
@Dannythefink@Attatroll79 Daniel, you're the only person in this conversation who keeps insisting that support for Israel must be Jewish. Do you genuinely not see the problem with that?
@nestapendragon Star Trek is great, but the characters who go through a lot of development like Nog only have one card.
Picard and Locutus would have made sense. Any character with their mirror universe version makes sense. There are 9 Spocks.
Elbit Systems, Israel's biggest weapons producer, provided weapons to Myanmar to arm the genocide against the Rohingya people.
The same firm is also arming Israel's genocide of the Palestinian people. Elbit also operates in Britain with legal cover by the government.
Ben Tait (Habibi) is not Jewish. Neither is John Woodcock. There are lots and lots of people in the network of actors connected to Tait who are not Jewish, but who have been very comfortable accusing Jews of antisemitism.
Nobody is trying to say Jews control the media, and it's disingenuous and insulting to suggest that is what Byline is trying to do. It demeans you, @Dannythefink to suggest it, not least because so many of Tait's targets ARE Jewish.
This story is not finished. There is lots more to report. I suggest people reserve judgment until it's done.
But what HAS been revealed so far is there's a weird anonymous inflammatory Islamophobic troll account that is ACTUALLY AND IN FACT connected to prominent political figures who have tried to use their influence to crack down on protests, civil liberties and free speech around Gaza; he also happens to be influential in amplifying stories "cancelling" well-loved celebrities who have spoken about Palestine; he has been cited as a source in 45 media articles, almost exclusively in the right-wing and pro-Israel press; and individuals like Ian Austin and Jon Woodcock who claim to be fighting hate and extremism and have condemned other politicians on this basis, have long been working with and/or amplifying a troll spewing vicious bile under cover of anonymity.
This is a man who called a Jewish Holocaust survivor a "stain" and "creepy Jewish fig leaf" and repeatedly defamed Muslim figures as "Islamists" and "extremists." He said Ghada Karmi is "one of the worst racists" in the land. He's called good, kind gentle Muslim community activists and journalists "racists thugs" and "extremists" and "notorious antisemites". Multiple Muslim MPs have now aired their concerns about him.
He repeatedly attacks Jewish figures - including Ed Miliband. He says, over and over, that Jewish activists who have spoken out on Gaza are "champions of antisemites" or similar. He's defamed people so often in my opinion that I can't see how a court could rule honest opinion or public interest.
Surely this must raise questions about the veracity and reliability of media narratives he's helped create? Surely it raises questions about the political judgment of political figures appointed by the government to advise on extremism and racism to be so closely associated with Tait? Surely it must be concerning that our public discourse and government decision-making has been underpinned by smears and Islamophobia?
I find it really striking that so many people don't seem perturbed by the fact that this guy was running an anonymous troll account AT THE SAME TIME that he was part of a campaign group spending £100k attacking the Labour Party, without any indication of where this money is from, alongside two sitting MPs who are then elevated to the House of Lords. I find it amazing people aren't wondering whether Tait's thinking and "research" informed THEIR thinking, underpinning reports calling for massive expansion of police powers to tackle "extremism" - the "extremism" and "hate" identified by Tait, like marching against war crimes.
I'm confused that so many people refuse to acknowledge, let alone care about, the issues of transparency and accountability that are raised.
I doubt that many people who have defended Tait care very much about what I have to say, but here's a fair warning nevertheless: you are going to start looking extremely weird if you defend Tait and think this is all a nothing-burger.
It's mad - MAD - that this troll has had such political influence, driven so much media coverage, infected the minds of our political class and fed into govt proposals about ending free speech and an independent media, the right of assembly and democratic dissent.
It's mad - MAD - that people who have presented themselves as sober experts on hate, extremism and antisemitism are staking their reputations defending this troll and his excretions.
Isn't it - at the very least- interesting to ask why?
How is this guy a Professor? Embarrassing.
It's not defaming someone to express an honest opinion, which I've done with Tait. To make it clear: in my opinion, Tait is Islamophobic.
I know our discourse is in the toilet when it comes to Muslims in public life, but here's a handy PSA about anti-Muslim racism.
If someone repeatedly calls Muslim politicians "Islamists" without any evidence beyond their ethnicity and religion, that is racist and Islamophobic.
Islamist is a slur - it means someone who wants to replace democracy with theocracy and rejects democratic norms. It is obviously defamatory to accuse Muslim politicians who explicitly reject Islamism of being Islamists.
If you combined Islamist with extremist, you are then saying they want to replace democracy with theocracy AND want to achieve those ends through extreme measures like violence. You are getting extremely close to calling that person an Islamic fundamentalist who would support the use of political violence like terrorism.
I'm not making this up.
The UK government literally defines the terms Islamist and extremist.
The 2026 UK government paper "Protecting what Matters," published with a foreword by Keir Starmer, defines Islamism as follows:
"Islamism is a political ideology; its proponents seek to impose their interpretation of religion and ‘sharia’ as law by state power, and, in various manifestations, justify acts of terror to achieve their goal of a global Islamist state – their version of a ‘caliphate’ or ‘Islamic state’. Islamists do not represent the Muslim communities of the UK."
The UK government formally defined extremism in 2024. This is the definition:
"Extremism is the promotion or advancement of an ideology based on violence, hatred or intolerance, that aims to:
- negate or destroy the fundamental rights and freedoms of others;
-or undermine, overturn or replace the UK’s system of liberal parliamentary democracyand democratic rights;
- or intentionally create a permissive environment for others to achieve the results in (1) or (2)."
"Islamist" and "extremist" ACTUALLY mean something - they're not just descriptors like creepy or gross. They are factual statements about a person's beliefs, views and philosophy, and are plainly defamatory if they are untrue and are not reasonably asserted.
It is no different to repeatedly calling Jewish people "Zionist supremacists who want to replace our government with a theocracy run on Talmudic principles through violence" without any evidence, simply based on the fact that they are Jewish.
It is no different to saying a Hindu politician supports Hindutva terrorism without any evidence beyond the fact that they are Hindu.
Tait has repeatedly identified SPECIFIC people who he calls Islamists. He presents no evidence worthy of the name. He calls some people Islamist extremists. I know some of these people and there is not a hint of truth to the allegation, nor is there any reasonable reason to state it. It is WILDLY defamatory to effectively call someone an Islamic fundamentalist who embraces violence to end democracy if it is untrue.
So @colwight, seeing as you're so keen to post on this topic in your name, and I'm sure your University has online codes of conduct, do you want to endorse Habibi or not?
I'm waiting.
I'm loving the response to Habibi-gate. These people are all telling on themselves and incidentally admitting extremely damaging things. Completely rattled - and they should be.
Here, Austin is telling everyone he is a MASSIVE bell-end who doesn't seem to care about Islamphobia or the sort of grotesque hate that sees a Holocaust survivor as a "stain" and Muslim figures recklessly described as Islamist extremists.
That's... really quite unsurprising considering it's, well, Ian Austin.
Much more consequential is an article today that inadvertently places habibi right at the centre of political power, and also exposes the most rotten aspects of the Labour Party antisemitism crisis and the current assaults on civil liberties occasions by protests against Israel's conduct in Gaza.
More on that anon... but it's good stuff.