People who are blaming John Thune for last night are a special kind of stupid.
Start with the obvious... Republicans swept in 2024 without the SAVE Act. Trump won every swing state, we flipped the Senate to 53 seats, and we held the House. Same voter rolls. Same registration rules. If those rules made it impossible to win, explain November 2024. You can't.
Second, Thune never had the numbers in the Senate to get the SAVE Act passed. Under the filibuster, a bill needs 60 votes just to get to a final vote. Obviously, they didn't have that. A rule change (meaning, getting rid of the filibuster to pass the SAVE Act) needs 51 votes. With 53 seats, four defections kill it, and there were more than four Republican senators unwilling to nuke the filibuster. Sen. Cramer told Politico there were 25-30 Republican senators who privately opposed nuking it. Again, Thune DIDN'T HAVE THE VOTES.
Third, the bill itself had real problems from a conservative perspective. Read the text yourself. Requiring in-person voter registration would hurt rural voters, OUR voters, most by forcing them to drive to a county office to prove their citizenship. And since when do conservatives want Washington dictating how states run elections? Oh yeah, WE DON'T. The bill should've been narrowed to voter ID requirements, which would've been a million times better than the system we have now.
The SAVE Act was nothing more than political theater. A bill everyone in that chamber knew was dead, kept alive as a ready made excuse if the blue wave hit. And here we are. Nancy Mace & other GOP House members/MAGA influencers are running with this narrative and have been saying it for months.
The truth is we didn't lose seven Senate seats because a bill didn't pass. We lost them because voters simply rejected what we offered. Until we're honest about that, we'll keep losing.