@IChotiner@CrisisGroup@NewYorker Israel mixes military goals (destroying Hamas's military) w/ political ones (destroying Hamas as a movement). Esp the latter is impossible. But even if achieved, that alone wouldn't end threats from Gaza. So long as Pals remain in Gaza, they will seek liberation. 7/7
My interview with @IChotiner on Gaza/Israel. TLDR; Gaza's day-after is here and it's ugly. https://t.co/i4I9v3z4m2
A thread @crisisgroup@NewYorker (1/7)
@IChotiner@CrisisGroup@NewYorker This hasn't been a war for hearts and minds. It's been total war also against the civilian infrastructure, which Israel deems hostile because Hamas is everywhere in Gaza 6/7
There's more food now in the north-but there's no cash to buy it with. In the south, which until the start of Israel's assault on Rafah was better off than the north, much of Gaza's population is now jammed into a thin strip along the coast w/ diminishing food and water (2/2)
This is where the Gaza debate stands today. Everyone agrees the Israeli siege of Nasser hospital killed hundreds of Palestinians who were buried in a mass grave. Does it really matter if Palestinians buried the bodies themselves or whether Israel did it? https://t.co/YwOiBoAfqr
@sfrantzman@CrisisGroup The choice is binary: let the civil authorities work & save lives, or continue to target them, fuel famine, & encourage social disintegration. There is no third option. It's not "whitewashing" to say the police are vital to preventing mass death by starvation & disease (2/2)
@sfrantzman Thanks for highlighting our report "Stopping Famine in Gaza". Whatever Gaza's civil police may or may not have done since 7 Oct, only they & civic groups cooperating with them can effectively safeguard aid and facilitate distribution (1/2) @crisisgroup https://t.co/s8YoOPiv8p
Hamas is holding to its demands in ceasefire talks, including to end the war. But Israel doesn't have a path to victory. Any marginal risk reduction Israel achieves by continuing to fight is more than outweighed by its loss of global stature. Just end the war. @crisisgroup
@CrisisGroup Otherwise Gaza is on track for the worst famine, relative to population size, of the past decades. At the start of the war, the worst scenario seemed depopulation of Gaza via Egypt. Today another looms: depopulation by starvation and disease (7/7)
@CrisisGroup The Gaza gov't is battered but still can ensure public order if allowed to operate. There is no alternative nor time to create one. With a ceasefire Israel would be more likely to accept police activity (6/7)