Really informative post about the unfortunate loss of muscle and increased insulin resistance that occurs after a injury-related spell of physical inactivity.
Muscle is the largest consumer of glucose in the body, and it stays responsive to insulin only as long as we use it.
Within a few days of inactivity, even healthy, lean people become measurably insulin resistant. One week of immobility can raise insulin resistance sevenfold, and after a few weeks of it, the insulin resistance can linger for weeks after the person is moving again.
The single-leg cast studies show how local this is. Put one leg in a cast and leave the other free, and within days the immobilized leg becomes about half as insulin sensitive as the active leg. Same person, same blood, same insulin, same meals. The only difference is whether the muscle is working.
Inside the unused muscle, inflammatory signaling ramps up, and the muscle starts making more ceramides, lipids that directly interfere with insulin signaling. The resting muscle effectively creates its own insulin resistance.
This matters most with age. Each injury, illness or hospital stay brings a burst of insulin resistance and lost muscle, and older adults rarely regain all of it. Over the years, those losses stack up, leaving less muscle to handle every meal that follows.
The good news is that the effect works in both directions. Breaking up long periods of sitting every 20 minutes or so, even with brief muscle contractions, blunts the glucose response to a meal.
If one immobilized leg can lose half its insulin sensitivity in days while the other leg stays fine, it's clear that muscle contraction is one of the most important regulators of insulin sensitivity we have.
Walk into hospital with coeliac disease and they take the bread away.
Walk in with a peanut allergy and they take the peanuts away.
Walk in with a liver damaged by alcohol and they take the alcohol away.
Walk in with lungs damaged by cigarettes and they take the cigarettes away.
Walk in with type 2 diabetes, a body that can no longer cope with sugar, and they bring you breakfast: cornflakes, orange juice, white toast and a little pot of jam.
Then the insulin trolley, to push down the sugar the breakfast put up.
Then a carton of juice by the bed, in case the insulin pushes it too far.
Then a line in your notes: poorly controlled.
This is the disease they diagnose by making you drink 75 grams of glucose and watching your body fail to clear it.
Every other patient on the ward is kept away from the thing that's hurting them.
The diabetic gets it on a tray, three times a day, with a drug to clean up after it.
Large fat cells predict type 2 diabetes better than total body fat does. Adults with normal glucose tolerance had a small sample of belly fat taken and were followed for years. The people whose fat cells were largest at the start were far more likely to develop diabetes, even after accounting for how much body fat they carried and how insulin resistant they already were.
Fat cells that grow very large struggle to store more fat safely, so more fat spills toward the liver, muscle and pancreas.
If someone is trying to judge their metabolic risk, how their fat is stored can tell more than how much of it they carry.
One of the most fascinating things about skeletal muscle is its ability to take up glucose from the bloodstream without requiring insulin.
And this becomes particularly important in people with insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes, and it helps explain why physical activity is such a powerful tool for improving metabolic health.
Here’s how it works.
🧵
@BenBikmanPhD Really informative post about the unfortunate loss of muscle and increased insulin resistance that occurs after a injury-related spell of physical inactivity.
High insulin can cause insulin resistance, and a healthy person can develop it in just a few days.
Insulin resistance is usually described as the starting problem, with high insulin as the body's way of making up for it. That's partly true. When tissues respond poorly to insulin, the pancreas does release more to keep blood glucose in range.
The relationship also runs the other way. When researchers gave healthy young people a steady infusion of insulin for about four days, raising it only to levels the body reaches in everyday life while keeping blood glucose normal, they became measurably insulin resistant. Their bodies cleared less glucose in response to insulin, mainly because less of it was stored as glycogen. Their pancreas also responded less to a rise in blood glucose afterward.
A similar change showed up when insulin was raised a different way. When the researchers infused glucose for three days so the volunteers' own pancreas released more insulin, the amount of glucose their bodies stored in response to insulin also fell, even though their total glucose uptake didn't change.
The researchers concluded that high insulin should be viewed as a cause of insulin resistance that keeps itself going, in addition to being a response to it.
This matters because insulin often runs high for years before blood glucose looks abnormal. If high insulin makes cells less responsive, then a way of eating that keeps insulin elevated from morning to night keeps feeding the problem, even while glucose readings look fine.
If someone is hoping to restore insulin sensitivity, it's clear that bringing insulin down deserves as much attention as bringing glucose down, and that starts with how much and how often a person eats foods that call for a lot of it.
One of the reasons I focus so much on dietary carbohydrates is that no nutrient in the blood is as volatile as glucose. It can climb sharply within minutes of a meal and fall just as quickly. And as much as the blood sugar spike after a meal gets most of the attention, when it comes to hunger, the drop that follows may matter more.
In a study of more than a thousand people wearing continuous glucose monitors, researchers looked at what happened to blood sugar in the hours after eating and how hungry people felt afterward. The size of the spike wasn't the best predictor of hunger. The dip was.
Some people's glucose rose after a meal and then settled back to where it started. Others rose and then fell below their starting level about two to three hours later. That second group, the "big dippers," got hungrier sooner, ate their next meal earlier, and took in more calories over the rest of the day.
This helps explain a common experience. Someone eats a breakfast of cereal, toast, or a pastry, feels fine for a while, and then by mid-morning is hungry again and looking for a snack. It isn't a lack of willpower. Their blood sugar went up quickly and then came down below where it began, and the body responds to that drop by pushing them to eat.
It also shows why the same meal can affect people so differently. One person's glucose barely dips after a bowl of oatmeal, while another's crashes. This is one more reason a glucose monitor is so useful. It shows not only how high a meal sends your glucose, but how far it falls afterward.
Meals built around protein and fat, with fewer refined carbohydrates, tend to produce a smaller rise and a gentler return, which means less of a dip and steadier hunger.
If someone keeps feeling hungry a couple of hours after eating, it's worth looking at whether that meal is sending their blood sugar up and then down below where it started.
Cutting carbs can raise how many calories a person burns, and the effect is biggest in people who secrete the most insulin. After losing weight, adults were randomly assigned to diets with 20%, 40% or 60% carbohydrate for 20 weeks with protein held constant. Total energy expenditure, measured by doubly labeled water, was about 209 calories a day higher on the low-carb diet than on the high-carb diet. In people with the highest insulin secretion at the start, the gap grew to about 308 calories a day, and the hunger hormone ghrelin was lower on low carb.
There are essential fatty acids and essential amino acids. There is no essential carbohydrate.
The body does need some glucose, mainly for red blood cells, which have no mitochondria. But the liver and kidneys can make all of it through gluconeogenesis, typically around 100 to 150 grams a day in adults, using lactate, glycerol from fat, and a small amount of amino acids.
Carb tolerance still varies a lot from person to person, and my new book, The Carb Crisis, explains why. The evidence is clear: carbs are optional, not required. Preorder link in the first reply.
For 60 years the blue tits of Britain broke into the milk on your doorstep, and all they ever took was the cream.
It was first seen in Swaythling, near Southampton, in 1921. A blue tit landed on a bottle, pecked through the cap and drank. By the 1950s every tit in the country seemed to know the trick. Housewives put out saucers, stones and upturned cups. The birds learned to follow the milk float down the street and be waiting at the next step.
You will remember the bottle. Silver foil on top, and beneath it 2 inches of thick yellow cream that had risen overnight, with the white milk underneath. The first one down in the morning got it on the porridge.
That cream was the whole point of the burglary. A bird cannot digest milk. It has no means of handling the sugar in it. Cream is nearly all fat, with very little sugar, so the tits drank down to the line and stopped.
A wild animal weighing 11 grams, with every bird table and berry bush in the street to choose from, worked out how to open a sealed container to get at butterfat.
Then the habit died, in about 10 years. Nobody trapped them or changed the caps. The milk changed. It was homogenised so the cream no longer rose, then skimmed so it was hardly there, then moved to a plastic jug in a supermarket.
The blue tits inspected the red top, found nothing in it worth stealing, and went back to the hedge.
They were the last creatures in Britain to judge a pint of milk on what was actually in it.
The most successful drug advert in history said Lipitor cuts the risk of heart attack by 36%, and the truth was in the footnote.
What the headline said:
- 36% fewer heart attacks
What the asterisk said:
- On the sugar pill, 3 people in 100 had a heart attack
- On Lipitor, 2 people in 100 had a heart attack
Both statements describe the same trial. 3 down to 2 is a drop of about a third. It is also a difference of 1 person.
What that means for the 100:
- 1 avoided a heart attack
- 2 had one anyway
- 97 were never going to have one
- 100 took the tablet every day for over three years
- 100 were exposed to the side effects
Nobody sat in a surgery was ever told "this will help 1 in 100 of you." They were told 36%, by a doctor who had been told 36%, by a rep who was paid on it.
Lipitor went on to sell well over $100 billion.
That asterisk is the most expensive piece of punctuation ever printed.
From 13 December every white loaf in Britain must contain folic acid, a synthetic compound the NHS says some people should avoid.
Parliament never debated it.
100,000 signatures will secure that debate.
We are past 56,000.
Sign and share:
Insulin resistance and its twin sister hyperinsulinaemia probably account for 80% of my work as a doctor It predates T2D by about 10 years Critically it responds to a low carb diet more than a low fat diet Please look at our review published here https://t.co/mrIAUmLFPR @BenBikmanPhD@BraciaRodzen@ketoproject1
I'm finally leaking exactly how we got Mary from 460lbs to 200lbs.
No Ozempic.
No weight loss drug at all.
4 more things we implemented into her lifestyle that helped her lose over 260lbs over the last few years:
Metabolic health can be shaped by diet, exercise, and physiology.
Read how the glucose ketone index (GKI) could help monitor metabolic health in Frontiers in Science, by @tnseyfried, @I_mitochondria, @DrJosephMaroon, and others ➡️ https://t.co/T5nsnGDeaW
A single night of sleep deprivation is enough to impair muscle protein synthesis. (I’m a terrible sleeper, so I share this with some dismay.)
In a randomized crossover study of healthy young adults, one night of total sleep deprivation reduced postprandial skeletal muscle protein synthesis by 18% the following day (and lowered testosterone by 24%).
Unfortunately, this means a single bad night is therefore enough to create meaningful anabolic resistance. This immediate and acute drop in muscle protein synthesis helps explain why chronic sleep loss is linked to reduced muscle mass.
https://t.co/KLpJmG3x4t
UK healthy life expectancy FALLS A Lot, WHY??? in 2022-2024 it was 60.7 years for men and 60.9 years for women, according to the Office for National Statistics (ONS). This was a drop of 1.8 and 2.5 years respectively compared with 2019 to 2021 POOR METABOLIC HEALTH because of junk food is a major contributor https://t.co/nmn1a9sFsh