ROSES

RepOrting standards for Systematic Evidence Syntheses in the field of environment

[Neal R Haddaway @nealhaddaway.bsky.social @nealhaddaway]

@YungEnChee1 @lingtax Sadly, this is quite common (see Sánchez-Bayo and Wyckhuys in Biol Conservation earlier this year. One solution is to support editors and reviewers by helping them to use reporting standards for evidence syntheses like @Roses_reporting.

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

You can download or save editable versions or @Roses_reporting forms and flow diagrams via ‘File>Make a copy’ or ‘File>Download as’ #SystematicReview

[Andrew Pullin @aspullin]

Disappointed that so many published, peer-reviewed evidence syntheses, including some claiming to be systematic reviews, still use such poor methodology and reporting when it could easily be improved using available resources. @EnvEvidence @Roses_reporting https://t.co/EkFGcxcTmC

[Neal R Haddaway @nealhaddaway.bsky.social @nealhaddaway]

Have you ever conducted a #SystematicReview or #SystematicMap?

Please take some time to tell us about what software, tools and technologies might have made your life easier!

You can fill in the survey here: https://t.co/5KeDIOnDmo

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

If you'd like to help us translate ROSES forms into other languages, please get in contact! https://t.co/6qTt0tOe9F

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

ROSES forms for systematic reviews and maps in environmental evidence syntheses have now been translated into Chinese! Find them here: https://t.co/7JmRRhPkdX #reporting #transparency #SystematicReview

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

And read about the story behind ROSES there, too!

[Neal R Haddaway @nealhaddaway.bsky.social @nealhaddaway]

Check out my recent interview with @MetaEvidence on evidence synthesis technology, CEE, and #systematicreview and mapping methods development at @SEIresearch https://t.co/5Art0PslH3

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

Is your #SystematicReview ROSES ready? Find helpful protocol and review/map forms to make your review #transparent and #open on the ROSES website! https://t.co/1JRmWDa6T8

[NPMetsa @NPMetsa]

Just filled @Roses_reporting form for a systematic protocol. Almost ready to submit to @EnvEvidence.

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

@NPMetsa @EnvEvidence Great work! Feel free to send us any comments or suggestions about your experience with ROSES!

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

Did you know, @ROSES Systematic Review Protocol forms contain 38 items that you can check against and report to make your #systematicreview protocols more #transparent and reliable? See the form here: https://t.co/8hj2KT2xh3

[Neal R Haddaway @nealhaddaway.bsky.social @nealhaddaway]

Thinking of conducting a #systematicreview or #systematicmap? Check out @Roses_reporting forms to make sure you've included all the relevant information: https://t.co/tIYGwYMvvi

[Neal R Haddaway @nealhaddaway.bsky.social @nealhaddaway]

@MichelleMaden @emilylovedhim @katiebarnard23 Actually, @Roses_reporting works for all types of literature - quant, qual, any science, reviews of reviews, etc.

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

Latest ROSES article from @EnvEvidence journal explains why @ROSES is an important step forward for #systematicreview transparency and builds on the important work of @PRISMAStatement focusing on the environmental field. https://t.co/uzzwSWBKK4

[CEE Joburg @CEEJoburg]

Response by ⁦@nealhaddaway⁩ ⁦@biljana_macura⁩ ⁦@paul_msg⁩ ⁦and ⁦@aspullin⁩ to “Every ROSE has its thorns” in ⁦@EnvEvidence⁩. On ⁦@Roses_reporting⁩. https://t.co/eclFxMaBFl

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

Some great discussions about ROSES reporting standards here - great to see people are helping us push the boundaries on rigorous evidence synthesis!

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

ROSES forms can help to make open data more discoverable, and ensure authors include necessary information in their #systematicreviews https://t.co/1JRmWDa6T8 https://t.co/N2GBzS42V8

[Neal R Haddaway @nealhaddaway.bsky.social @nealhaddaway]

Lessons here for @EnvEvidence, too. We should be making every decision and result Open Access. SOOOO many reasons to do this. #evidencesynthesis #systematicreview https://t.co/Rv1eoo1FRe

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

Did you know that several journals currently endorse or enforce ROSES forms for #systematicreviews/#systematicmaps, with more following soon? Find out who at the ROSES website:

[ROSES @Roses_reporting]

Check out https://t.co/1JRmWDa6T8 to find out how! https://t.co/GteIHAXkMc

[Harsha Dayal @Dayal70]

To save the research literature, let’s make literature reviews reproducible https://t.co/pOgVBoGqlg

[Neal R Haddaway @nealhaddaway.bsky.social @nealhaddaway]

Better standards and guidelines can bolster research literature reviews https://t.co/weLCisiS0k via @TC_Africa #systematicreview