@CasualArtyFan I think it’s a combination of the “shoot n scoot” mentality and the manpower issue. Towed artillery is seen as less survivable, but also, it’s far more manpower intensive, often requiring crews of 2-3 times that of self propelled.
@navalnewscom@SafranElecDef I would assume that it would come with a lot of limitations on installation due to the exhausts from the rockets? I know this came up as an issue when the Royal Navy trialled Martlet (LMM) fitted on their DS-30 systems.
@drgarethmottram@niuclasach79535@FennellJW Take a look at the 200mm mini torpedoes like the Black Scorpion, which should be light enough to allow even an S100 Camcopter to carry them!
@FTusa284@HyperVoreian I’m not saying it would have, merely that those competitions were before its time. The FREMM, however, did make both. Ultimately the FDI is a compromise, just like T31/AH140, with some weaknesses, especially the low number of originally planned VLS (just like T31)…
@FTusa284@HyperVoreian As for not making the shortlists in Canada or Australia, it wasn’t around at that time, just as T31 wasn’t. It did make the final shortlist in Norway.
@FTusa284@HyperVoreian The T26 has three, two of which have not been even close to smooth sailing. Hunter has been a bit of a mess, Canada’s River class has been a mess. Even the baseline T26 is still not in service yet.
FDI has two so far, both of which have gone smoothly so far���
@MartinXHendy@thinkdefence The Sea Giraffe 1X has been fitted to both CB90 and even the 8.5m long Kraken. Obviously it’s no Artisan, but it’s still a pretty capable radar, especially for such small craft.
@FnahtanoJ I have to say, I enjoyed shooting both the L85 and L86 in small doses on the ranges, though reloading was very much a muscle memory problem. I do always wonder if we might have been better adopting the AUG, as Australia & NZ did (& FIDF for that matter).
@thinkdefence The counter argument is that it’s not all that much cheaper than Martlet, but for a less capable missile. If we massively ramped up production of Martlet, we could potentially get the unit cost lower.
@FennellJW@SWDWilliam@NavyLookout Only since they have been at war. Before that, Iran shot down multiple high value drones, and Russia has tried to force down drones as well.
@FennellJW@SWDWilliam@NavyLookout They’re far more vulnerable in practice, because our opponents have demonstrated a willingness to sink them or force them out of the skies. The same is not true of manned systems. That is a huge vulnerability.
@FennellJW@SWDWilliam@NavyLookout We’ve also seen from operations worldwide that potential enemies are quite happy to force unmanned systems down. When that unmanned system is a £100m+ ship, that gets painful fast.
@FennellJW@SWDWilliam@NavyLookout Even on commercial ships, their engine rooms are low maintenance, not no maintenance. Having to fly someone out to a point 2000 miles in the North Atlantic in high winds because an engine is showing warning lights is far from ideal.
@FennellJW@SWDWilliam@NavyLookout It’s really not though. Having a small crew on board to troubleshoot and perform routine maintenance is a massive advantage. Take a small ship out into the North Atlantic for a week without having the crew to troubleshoot, and see how effective it’ll be...
@SWDWilliam@FennellJW@NavyLookout That’s why I strongly believe we should be pursuing lean-manned ships, at least for the large USVs. Obviously the small types should be entirely uncrewed, but anything over about 30m should at least have provision for a modest crew.
@nathanhirst1986@LizWebsterSBF Your gym usage is frictionless until you leave that gym’s membership. Funnily enough, your usage stops being frictionless. The UK chose to become a third country because of the Tory’s red lines, rejecting continued market access.
@KingstonTwex@Gabriel64869839 It’s not about being cheaper than the threat, it’s about being substantially cheaper than the target it is defending. If you’re protecting a very high value target, even losing £1m systems becomes uncomfortable but bearable.