Iโve been seeing some takes about an issue that happened about a year ago, when Sheikh Maqari talked about hadith mutawatir and related issues.
What happened afterwards was honestly disappointing. Some Izala Imams and their followers started insulting and mocking him. Sheikh Guruntum even made it personal, saying Sheikh Maqari didnโt have the wit to discuss the topic.
But this is where I start asking questions about consistency.
Listen to Sheikh Gumi, for example, when he discussed the narration about the jinn being sent to the Prophet Muhammad(SAW). Sheikh Gumi questioned the narration/interpretation, despite narrations on the subject being found in Bukhari and Muslim. He even brought up the Qurโanic principle that Allah protects His Messenger.
Nobody from their side says Sheikh Gumi doesnโt know what he is talking about. Nobody says he is too ignorant to discuss hadith. Nobody starts insulting him.
Why?
Because he is one of them.
But let another Imam who isnโt from their circle discuss a difficult hadith, and suddenly the man doesnโt know anything about Islam.
The same thing happens with the discussion about the parents of the Holy Prophet.
Some of these same Imams and followers are very comfortable saying that the parents of the Prophet are in Hellfire because of narrations in Bukhari and Muslim.
Yet there are scholars who have taken a different position on this issue, including scholars who discuss the concept of Ahl al-Fatrah and the Qurโanic verse:
โAnd We would never punish until We had sent a messenger.โ โ Qurโan 17:15.
So there is clearly a scholarly discussion here. People have different understandings of the evidence.
My issue isnโt even which opinion you choose to follow.
My issue is the double standard.
If Sheikh Gumi can question or interpret a narration differently, why is another scholar suddenly stupid, ignorant or unqualified to discuss the deen simply because he is not from your movement?
And if you can speak so confidently about the parents of the Prophet being in Hellfire, why is it so difficult to show the same respect and restraint when another scholar discusses a hadith differently?
You can disagree with Sheikh Maqari. No problem.
You can disagree with Sheikh Gumi too. No problem.
But why does disagreement become scholarly reasoning when it comes from someone you like, and ignorance when it comes from someone outside your group?
This is what bothers me about sectarianism.
Sometimes, people donโt even listen to what is being said anymore. They first check who said it.
If he is from our group, he must know what he is saying.
If he is not from our group, he must be wrong.
That is not how serious scholarship should work.
Unfortunately, the Izala sect operate more like a cult and they don't uphold the principle of fairness if you are not from the sect.
Manzon Allah yayi sallah akan raqumi,
Yi akan raqumi ya fi yi a kan kasa ne?
Sbd conquest ya karya azumin sa, karya azumin ya fi bari ne?
Manzon Allah yayi shafa, yin shafa tafi wanke kafa ne?
Manzon Allah yayi kasru, yin kasru ya fi ciki sallah ne?
Shine aka CE Maka Sai dai idan shine ya ce ya fi, ba wai Dan kawai ya koyar shi ke nan Sai ace ya fi ba.
Wallahi bayan jahilci akwai hauka da rashin hankali a lamarin wahabiyawa. Yanzu mene ne abun wahala ko rudar wa a maganar da ya yi?
Dalibai jahilai, malamai kuma yan son rai da son zuciya + jahilci.
@Abdulshamza@osamah_yabo@jibreelKhalil To gaskiya son zuciyar ka yayi clouding judgement din ka, idan har abinda kaji ka fahimta a maganar sa shine ya fifita ziyara akan umrah to se dai nai ma adduโa Allah ya cire maka son zuciyar da kungiyanci ya sa maka.
Watakila akwai wa kullaliya a ran ka game da Maqari shiyasa
@KashereSaadatu@j0_szn@The_Umdazz Na fahimce ki, wannan kam matsalar su ce, ni bana ma son sa baki a lamarin maโaurata cos se ka gama zaqewa su baka kunya.
My point was just akan maganar ya bugi qirji ne, which from the way he refused to live in her house ka san ba irin mutanen da za su kwanta su ki nema ba ne.
@KashereSaadatu@j0_szn@The_Umdazz โYa bugi kirji ya nemi nashi saboda gudun gori din manaโ
Me yasa mata suke gani kamar duk namijin da bashi da arziki laifin sa ne? Ku fita ku ga yacce talakawan suke neman na kan su ba dare ba rana amma Allah be basu arzikin ba.
Kun manta cewar samu na Allah ne ba zafin nema ba
@Abdulshamza@osamah_yabo@jibreelKhalil A yanzu haka kai ne ka nuna jahilci a fili tunda jahilcin ka ya nuna idan aka ambaci umrah a magana ana nufin za a kaskanta ta ne. Atleast kar qungiyanci ya dinga rufe muku ido.
Yace ba don umrah bane saboda ya jaddada muku abinda zai kai shi musamman.
Jahilan banza jahilan wofi