Voters don’t want the country remade. They want the tariffs to go away, they want the Iran war ended, they want ICE to stop terrorizing folks, and above all, they want prices to come down. On that last point, Biden failed and they punished Dems; Trump failed and they punished Rs.
Ossoff, Hamilton, and Talarico are all well left of center compared to their states. Have you Third Way boys even been to these states? I see Lucas you’re from the suburbs of LA…
The Biden Admin had a theory of the case:
just make good public policy and the public will thank you.
I don’t have to remind you how well that worked for them.
Repeal the tariffs and the war and make Trump sign or veto it.
many things about the next two years will be hard and scary but we can take grim pleasure in the fact that Trump will spend the entire presidential primary actively trying to fuck with and humiliate all the candidates
I don't think "strategic moderation" involves holding the same views mostly as the national party, unless we're arguing that the party itself has shifted more to the center post Biden.
The debate about whether moderation was useful in the midterms is really confusing to me given that nearly every candidate who won a purple state strategically moderated on key positions. (The one example is arguably Jackson, though Maine is typically a blue state).
i feel like there was an albeit brief taboo against talking like your were running a eugenicist breeding program that has eroded in my lifetime. i for one miss when we did not talk about women like this
@ZaidJilani Chait could possibly argue that Harris moderating didn't hurt her but it's bizarre to suggest it was helping her close the gap. She opened with a lead that quickly faded. She couldn't break free of Biden in voters' minds.
I think all the nations pundits vastly overestimate how much attention voters pay to niche changes in language from politicians. Kamala Harris lost because she served an unpopular president and was his representative.
This is significantly accurate, but still is wildly overly charitable to Israel. "Collateral damage" is belittling of mass slaughter, and inaccurate insomuch as IDF troops have knowingly carried out rage-driven targeted murders of innocent civilians including children.
@hecubian_devil I don't think Manchin was necessarily pro-trans.
I get your overall point. I just think that a lot of what Turek says was understood but just not openly articulated among many Dems in the past.
Democrats say they're going to do the Green New Deal, then call it off for fear it might have to be built within 100 miles of a migratory bird sanctuary.
Republicans call the Green New Deal communism, then secretly build it themselves when they realize it's cheaper than NOT doing it.
Astead: Nobody of honesty looks at El-Sayed winning by 7—when Third Way told me he could never win—and thinks that's an underperformance.
They're trying to manufacture consent for a specific ideological lane to emerge in 2028. I find it to be something that's a pre-context for Josh Shapiro and Pete Buttigieg and some folks like that.
I actually wouldn't put Elissa Slotkin in that group...
I will wade into the Democratic candidate quality discussion to make what I think is an important point.
In my view, progressive U.S. Senate candidates faced a particularly difficult mix of circumstances in 2026, and simply measuring their performance against the 2024 presidential results misses much of that context.
Merkley had to deal with a weak Democratic gubernatorial performance in Oregon; Flanagan with Minnesota's fraud scandal; Nixon with a strong candidate in Moody and a Florida electorate shifting right amid domestic migration; and of course Troy Jackson with Susan Collins.
Over time you would expect this to "even out" where just looking at swing from a previous Presidential election in a midterm year would be useful. But I think it's pretty clear on a case-by-case basis progressives just had to deal with disproportionately tough headwinds in 2026.
Split Ticket's WAR metric from @lxeagle17 generally does a *very* good job of accounting for these contextual factors, particularly in Minnesota and Oregon.