@tomboy_inc@tracewoodgrains Why do you think we should only care about things that might affect smart people? Should unintelligent people be condemned to exploitation and misery?
@GuyInSF2@libpol_org@jessesingal It’s interesting that every single pangram critic “doesn’t have the time to get into it” or provide any evidence for their claims. Quite a striking pattern if the case is really so compelling
@sparstormo@qualiascript EA is not, and is not meant to be, a “foundation to build a society.” EA has specific core principles, and they are principles that stand or fall independently of what any particular EA’s other views are. A defense of every idea macaskill has is obviously irrelevant
@timnitGebru@VladimirNyk Like it would make no difference if I had just linked the epoch report instead of linking to a chat that linked to it. What’s in the report is what’s in the report
@timnitGebru@VladimirNyk 1) I have not read and am not responding to your “whole line of work”
2) It’s fine that you don’t like the way I chose to search for evidence bearing on the claim I responded to; you can just read and respond to it directly if you think there’s something wrong with it
@sparstormo@qualiascript Not only am I not relying on AI “heavily” in this thread, I don’t believe I’ve ever used it for anything I’ve posted on here. You’re welcome to run a collection of my posts through pangram
@sparstormo@qualiascript 1) you didn’t offer a critique, you made an unsupported claim
2) I’m well aware of Singer’s role in the development of EA ideas (I’ve taught this material). This does not change the fact EA does not depend on utilitarianism, which was your original claim
@graykevinb@albedoa@bigcheeeeeese@habibislop@MaleManlpulator@max_spero_ A random guy who was frustrated by people asserting a high rate of false positives without evidence. He wanted a useful tool to push past the he said/she said, challenging people who disagree with him to present actual proof
@seconds_0@graykevinb He’s wrong because he’s wrong, not because he’s 21. It’s bad for discourse quality and establishing trust to dismiss people for extraneous factors rather than on the basis of the quality of their arguments
@sparstormo@qualiascript It’s true that many of the most prominent philosophers who have developed EA ideas are utilitarians or sympathetic to utilitarianism, but this obviously doesn’t prove that one entails the other
@sparstormo@qualiascript The philosophical foundations of a set of ideas aren’t a question of jurisprudence. EA doesn’t rest on utilitarianism (many EAs are not utilitarians), and it seems like your assumption that it does is your only justification for the claim about rights