@FirstNBased@Edenlife9 Okay ill admit no secular historian i know has made that study. But my brother if you want to do your own research and work out her age chronologically be my guest. Either way her age would be around 17-19 years old
@Ashleyn0911@Edenlife9 First of all most of the muslim men i do know actually follow it. Second of all its not about being fair or not. In islam women are rewarded for every drop of sweat that falls from their forehead whilst wearing the hijab. There hijab is there to protect not oppress
@Ajzdmy@Chillin_Dillon@Edenlife9 Some cultures it is fine to do that? When nuns and female orthodox jews wear a veil it isnt bad. But when muslims do it we are the bad guys.
@HoMoHAMmadFraud@LoneStarLegendX So you admit its propaganda but still call it the truth. You know sometimes i really wonder why you guys hate muslims so much. Im pretty sure 98% of you guys havent had an actual conversation with one. And to have this level of hatred makes no sense
@Harley199os@its_The_Dr Old from 100 years ago. We cannot call someone a pedo 1400 years ago based on todays societal norms. Otherwise that means all of your ancestors are also pedos and at one point everyone before todays generation was also a pedophile. We cant compare todays societal norms to 1400ago
@Harley199os@its_The_Dr In todays society yes. However he was not a pedo. 100 years ago in england and wales a girl was allowed to get married at age 12. Now 1400 years ago imagine the difference of responsibilities and age of maturity back then. A 12 year old from today does not compare to a 12 year ol
@FirstNBased@Edenlife9 That is her age after puberty. Please if you are so educated you can work it out chronologically and find out that she was actually a lot older than 6-9. So modern historians who did look into this matter do believe that arabs did count age after puberty WALLAHI
@FirstNBased@Edenlife9 Muhammad ibn Jarir al-Tabari believed that Aisha was older (he worked a chronological timeline to work this out) old school historians took those numbers literally that she was actually 6 and 9. Modern historians who arent really that mainstream which ill admit say that that is h
@Som39333288@Y_entertain@Edenlife9 Whether he was 55 or 17 it does not matter. 100 years ago it was possible to get married at the age of 12. Now imagine 1400 years ago. How is it logical to compare todayβs society to 1400 years ago.
@FirstNBased@Edenlife9 Okay if you are ignorant enough to even fact check this statement. Please use chat gpt. Its available to everyone. Itll tell you the same thing
@Hardhaterpro7@Y_entertain@Edenlife9 In 1926 is was legal for a girl to get married at age 12 in england. And that was only 100 years ago. Now imagine 1400 years ago what the societal norm was. Im pretty sure it was legal 100 years ago because they was more matured and ready to take on more responsibilities
@EnzoZoen612690@Edenlife9 To be honest either way for me it does not matter. Whether she was 19 or 9. First of all if she was 19 that ruins the argument that our prophet was a pedo. Second of all we cannot compare todays societal norms to 1400 years ago. Rebecca was 3 joseph was 19 i believe?
@Chillin_Dillon@Edenlife9 some modern Muslim scholars and historians have argued that she may have been older, based on other historical evidence and chronological calculations. These estimates often place her in her mid-to-late teens, but these views are not the traditional or majority position.RESEARCH!