Theoretical computer scientist. Algorithms, complexity, mechanism design & computational social choice. Interested in old problems and surprising mathematics.
@chenna1985 Even if it was peer reviewed it could still have mistakes, and that would in fact be much more likely. This is a degree of certainty which is far beyond what is usual in mathematics for these conplicated proofs.
The fall of the Riemann hypothesis has revealed an even BIGGER mathematical challenge, easily worth trillions:
Characterizing what it means for a complex program (e.g., Lean proof) to be human-cognitively irreducible, and developing techniques & tools for automatically simplifying it.
For the first time in God-knows-how-long, the biggest challenge facing mathematicians is aligned with the biggest challenge facing technologists. I'm so excited.
@GPotoshin@nihilunbounded I beg to disagree. A proof is a proof even if no one understands it. Secondly a solitary mind could definitely have an opinion on what is and isn't interesting. The social constructs are secondary. I think a lot of people are now going to adjust their conceptions of mathematics.
@KompaniLinge@zjmillermit@PastNostalgic@TheDavidHasbun lean>>>peer review. I think you need to adjust your priors as to what is trustworthy. Peer review has a ridiculous failure rate. There were mistakes in so many peer reviewed big theorems. Lean makes the odds of this being the case far lower.
@TheDavidHasbun This is simply untrue. We just have to adjust our motivations. What valuable work can humans do in the age of AI? The proofs aren't fake, in my own area there's been more progress in a year than in the last decade, by far.
@superalesha How would the Levent/antgropic break under review lol. I trust the Lean code and the people who vetted far more than I would a peer-review of the whole proof. At this point it is more certain to be correct than anything that hasn't been formalised.
@ObhishekSaha While I agree that he is doing singular stuff, I don't think that this means what it used to mean. Saying he is the person to solve RH is erasing too many contributions. This was already a problem before AI, Perelman was unhappy claiming all the credit, but now much more so.
Also, I wish people would stop calling it the "Claude proof", as I am seeing on this website, and instead credit the person involved: Levent Alpoge.
Levent is not just an Anthropic employee, he is a top-level mathematician. Others with similar access to frontier AI models/tokens (and trust me, there are many such people) were not able to come up with a proof of RH.
Levent has been on a truly generational run since summer, proving time and again his ability to solve conjectures thought out of reach. Jacobian conjecture, Hadamard matrices, complex structure on S6, etc. And now GRH.
I think the mathematical community, a large part of which is anti-AI, has treated him poorly, at least from what I've seen on social media.
The honour of proving RH, if the proof holds up, belongs to him.