عبد الله

وَأَنَّ ٱلْمَسَٰجِدَ لِلَّهِ فَلَا تَدْعُواْ مَعَ ٱللَّهِ أَحَدًا

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

🧵My threads

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

@MusaTheTheist @Ahraz__ Ironically, this is actually how it may feel like talking to the Shi’a about Ghadeer.

Y’all can’t even use Ghadir Khumm as proof of successorship or Imamah. See my thread:
https://t.co/dAr8KwWSVU

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Exposing a Fundamental Contradiction in Shi’i Theology: Ghadir Khumm

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Sarih al-Sunnah, by Abu Ja’far Muhammed b. Jarir al-Tabari (d. 310), page 24

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

al-Tabari’s (d. 310) takfir of an Ash’ari like-view:

«The correct view according to us, is that the Qur’an is the speech of Allah, uncreated, however it is written, and wherever it is recited, and in whatever place it is read. Whether found in the heavens or on earth.

[…]

[doox @guessijustwasnt]

Tfw, you’re an ash’ari and yo find out Al-Tabari takfirs you for believing in another Quran, other than the one on the earth.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

or professes it with his tongue as a creedal matter, is a disbeliever in Allah, whose bl*od is lawful [to spill], disassociated from Allah, and Allah is disassociated from him.»

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

@SeyedAli_1 @FutureEthics The Hadith quoted seems to be inauthentic, and Allah knows best. See my thread:

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

A thread🧵

A small analysis of its chains of transmission, textual inconsistency, aswell as scholarly criticism of its problematic transmitters.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

@Zikr312 @FutureEthics Sorry, not ahsant. The Hadith he quoted is not authentic. See my thread:

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

A thread🧵

A small analysis of its chains of transmission, textual inconsistency, aswell as scholarly criticism of its problematic transmitters.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

@omar_balban @FutureEthics You’re right. The Hadith quoted is weak. See my thread:

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

A thread🧵

A small analysis of its chains of transmission, textual inconsistency, aswell as scholarly criticism of its problematic transmitters.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

@Samcfc08 @FutureEthics The Hadith he quoted is weak, brother.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

A thread🧵

A small analysis of its chains of transmission, textual inconsistency, aswell as scholarly criticism of its problematic transmitters.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

@FutureEthics https://t.co/GPn6WXW5SI

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

A thread🧵

A small analysis of its chains of transmission, textual inconsistency, aswell as scholarly criticism of its problematic transmitters.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

A thread🧵

A small analysis of its chains of transmission, textual inconsistency, aswell as scholarly criticism of its problematic transmitters.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Did ‘Umar actually ever congratulate ‘Ali at Ghadir Khumm?

A thread🧵

A small analysis of its chains of transmission, textual inconsistency, aswell as scholarly criticism of its problematic transmitters.

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

🧵My threads

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Shi’as consider Sunnis to be non-Muslims:

[عبد الله @SjNoMadMe]

Shi'as consider Sunnis to be non-Muslims:

A short thread🧵:

The Shi’i ‘infallible’ Imam Abu Ja’far was asked about the one who denies an Imam, to which he said:

«Whoever denies an Imam (an infallible) has disassociated himself from Allah, and is free from His religion.»

[...]