Dude, if you can't be bothered to watch my nine part, 1 hour per episode, YouTube series entitled "Me explaining what you couldn't possibly understand otherwise," that devastates all of your arguments, before responding, then clearly you know I'm right.
@Solomonzikel You didn't derive this so your proof doesn't follow. A god is here, now, watching, changing outcomes. Need only be powerful, irresistible. Not good, first or creator. A creator needn't design, certainly needn't do all the fabrication, or survive the work or hang around as a god.
@Solomonzikel Here's the problem: you mix design, fabrication and ongoing godding like Christianity taught. That doesn't follow from from your experience and knowledge of existence. Designers needn't build. Builders needn't still exist, or track what they built. God is a now/future concern.
@m966021 Exactly. An apparent God that kicks ass if you don't worship and obey would still be God. It's just the invisible God people quote to win arguments that has to be good. Otherwise who cares what that God thinks?
@Olasejoe My claim: we have no real theory about the origin of stuff or God or whatever and any theory for one covers the other. Ultimately we don't really know. Your claim: you know what was first and what It thinks about drinking wine.
@lucasmiles In the revolutionary war people died to free us from the combined pope of the church (by the way Charles is the leader of the Church of England to this day) and King of the government, but you want to restore the government picking your religion? Come on. This isn't iran.
@kyletanderson Morals are the same with and without gods. You can tell, when people quote scripture for some modern thing it doesn't mention or justify some hideous thing it does (slavery, genocide, rape), that we're all doig the same thing, same basis, and scripture does not always serve it.
@SpeedWatkins God of power need only kick ass to rule us. Good? Bad? Whatever. God referenced by humans for authority has to be good. So that God, flexible as the humans using it, always is.
@Olasejoe@DickThickrod It's rather childish to ask why something you don't want to happen to you is wrong. It's childish to ask why it would be wrong to do that to somebody else. Let's get at least one step higher on moral complexity before we act perplexed.
@Olasejoe Yes that's what everybody says about their gods. Of course their God is the exception. Its the other gods that need to be rejected. Obviously. Whether you're a Mooney, a Muslim, a Methodist or a Mormon this makes perfect sense.
@RubinReport I think we should be concerned about the Quran and Muslims but only because I see how Christians twist the Bible to whatever purpose they want, their holy book is a conscience and reason get out of jail free card. Seems like this is how holy books work.
@Solomonzikel When you see Bible believers turn the Bible to modern purposes that it never mentions, say abortion for instance, which would never come to mind if you simply read the bible, you realize the Bible isn't guiding them. It's the other way around.
@SpeedWatkins I think this shows that Christianity is full of quiet atheists. There's a real payoff among family and friends and employers sometime for playing the game, but scripture gets turned about like there's no sense that there's a real God who cares how you use its NIL.
@SpeedWatkins It's interesting to me how much Christianity, and people who deal with Christians, quotes scripture about things that would never come to mind if you read the scripture. To me this shows disrespect for any intent, or Being with intent, behind scripture.
@CelljamJ@bernardtjoy Being able to analyze, organize, mass manipulate, debate, codify it? I'm not even sure we can rule out an elephant or ape considering norms, future behavior of the tribe. But still I'll accept that that's just us. But that's not "morals" in general.
@CelljamJ@bernardtjoy When a mammal mother defends young, rat works to free its fellow, elephants help the injured, monkey comforts abused monkey or even when the bullied monkey goes and bullies another, I think it's hard to say these aren't revealing the origin, still on the scale, of what we do.
@Romy_Holland I think flashlights are handy to have at night, batteries go bad and homeless people know they can just get tonight's flashlights off of a bike. Discard them when the batteries go bad and get another one another day.
@matt_olma You've got the one recommended by your noble great-grandparents. I think ancestors are underrated in, for instance, Christianity. We speak of church fathers and early Israelite Fathers with great respect but don't honestly acknowledge how important great-grandma was.
@bernardtjoy Evidently not since I would consider morals among animals evidence of morals in nature. And similar morals in humans therefore "natural." We navel-gaze. I don't see that elsewhere. Seems unnatural. We make up morals like covering navels on tv. Seems unnatural.