@Historycourses This is in London and its illegal to ride on the sidewalk. My question is which parent is stupid enough to let their 5 year old ride to school knowing fully well they need to ride in the street. What the actual heck??
@rabbimarkiz I never implied I want to tell anyone what to do. Nor is me listening to the logic behind their beliefs relevant. I have my own view of gender and them explaining theirs won't change my mind just as me explaining my view won't change theirs. Live and let live
@rabbimarkiz Theres no benefit of doubt to give. They have their views and identity in a certain way as a result. I disagree with what they are doing but they are their own people that are fully entitled to their beliefs just as I am
@rabbimarkiz I definitely believe they exist. Would be stupid to ignore the fact that people transition. I don't agree with their choice or their definition of gender but they are fully entitled to do as they please and view themselves how they want.
@rabbimarkiz Finally, correct me if I'm wrong, but the problem with calling someone by another name is onaas devorim. If there is a halachic issue with calling them that name it MAY not apply
@rabbimarkiz That's true. But keep in mind that many things in today's world are complicated halachically. Give them the benefit of doubt that they are trying to do the right thing.
@rabbimarkiz I don't think most religious people who don't want to call someone by their new name are trying to hurt them or be nasty, so I am explaining their reasoning.
@rabbimarkiz I don't agree with trans people from a religious perspective. I do however think they should be treated with respect and if they would like to be called by a new name, that's fine.
@CraftsmanBob@GeorgeIsa1@FBINewark Are you aware of the fact that in NJ there are hundreds of synagogues, many with only 50 or so members and there is no way financially that they could all be protected as in Australia? They cannot afford private security or expensive security systems.
@rabbimarkiz I'm not saying they are right, but it is their worldview you are trying to refute, so your refutation(is that a word? ) doesn't prove anything.
@rabbimarkiz True, but the reason why people don't want to call trans people by their chosen name is because they disagree with transitioning for religious or other reasons and feel that calling them by the new name is in a sense agreeing with the transition. So it isn't really a comparison