I started this account because I saw in Starship the potential for a $10,000 return-trip ticket to the moon and I wanted to start a fundraising club to help get it bootstrapped. I gave up on the club when I saw SpaceX was raising the money well enough on its own.
The 9 engine v4 Starship also strikes me as smart design for passenger safety. A single vacuum raptor going out in a big deal on a Starship with only 3 of them (though engine-out has been demo'd). 6 vacuum engines should be significantly more fault-tolerant.
One thing to remember, even if Starship reusability disappoints, is how much it sucks to splash down in a little capsule far out in the ocean and need a rescue mission. 20~60 tons of downmass connecting directly to an elevator down to a line of vans will be an amazing capability.
One thing I look forward to as a spectacle is the first test of the skirt landing backup option. To carry passengers with a high confidence of their survival, Starship needs to be able to emergency land in other places than the tower. They're not planning to add legs for this.
@peterrhague@eager_space They abandoned the possibility of cost savings in the napkin sketch phase. Of those who stayed to work on it, the sincere ones weren't competent, and the competent ones weren't sincere.
I'd like to see airliner-like Starship, but there's no guarantee we get it. Note that this outcome is still a significant upgrade from Falcon 9 / Dragon and could support in-space manufacturing and moon industry.
@KsNewSpace There's a possibility they make these changes to have a basically functional system and then they're stuck for 5+ years at refurbishable Super Heavy supporting weekly (fleet) launches, expendable 200 ton stripped cargo Starship, and recoverable 50 ton pressurized Starship.
@KsNewSpace There's a possibility they make these changes to have a basically functional system and then they're stuck for 5+ years at refurbishable Super Heavy supporting weekly (fleet) launches, expendable 200 ton stripped cargo Starship, and recoverable 50 ton pressurized Starship.
@KsNewSpace They pushed very hard for propulsion system performance. They probably need to back down for reliability and longevity, add a heat exchanger for clean LOX tank pressurization for one thing, adding significant mass to Raptor.
@KsNewSpace There are structural limits to how long and skinny they can make it, and the area on the bottom doesn't support unlimited vacuum Raptors. But I don't think this is about performance greed. They're trying to make it work. Right now, they're not recovering Super Heavy.
I don't really get why this type of comment has been showing up so much lol. This is an intentionally ablative add-on that's already been carbonized and would likely have to be replaced regardless. Pretty clear that it's just a cheap/easy stopgap for a more permanent fix.
The GPUs were very, very overpriced at the prices SpaceX and other AI bubble participants paid for them. We may see the price for new equivalent replacements drop to <10% of what SpaceX paid, let alone used ones from data center liquidations.
In my honest appraisal, spectacular as the catch was, the continuing propulsion problems are a bigger negative indicator. They may have pushed too hard for performance, but does the concept even work with lower performance engines?
In the space enthusiast world, it's easy to think of SpaceX as a rocket company, but it diversified bigtime, and what it diversified into is kind of dodgy. They are *heavily* invested in depreciating GPUs they rent out to companies with no apparent route to profitability.
Anyone who was surprised by the Starship catch wasn't paying attention. They already demonstrated intact re-entry, navigation to a precise location, and hover on previous flights. They just weren't aiming at a landing tower (which previously demonstrated Super Heavy catch).
We're seeing one-step-forward-one-step-back in the Starship project. They tower caught Super Heavy two years ago, but now it's been a year and a half since they did that. I certainly didn't see that coming.
@Jacks0nPainter Lunar re-entry isn't needed. A simplified HLS-like Starship can do LEO-LLO-LEO propulsively. If they want to be conservative, they can transport crew to and from LEO by F9/Dragon, but Starship is planned to become a passenger vehicle anyway.