@peterrhague Perhaps that is true with the initial designs for two-stage full reusable systems. Those were costed at $9 billion which was probably overly optimistic.
My guess is that most of the engineers realized that the shuttle as built wasn't going to be a universal space truck.
@peterrhague Shuttle had to be cheaper than Titan to get funded and for that they had to be able to launch once a week.
I'm surprised that anybody believed that, but I've been unable to find any real account that explores that question.
@joebarnard Me too...
I thought that Vulcan had a good chance to get ahead of New Glenn and Ariane 6 in launching for Amazon LEO and yet here we are with Ariane 6 in the lead in terms of satellites launched.
What a weird world...
This is utterly terrible for DoD and NSSL. From the NSSL wiki page, SpaceX has 3 phase 2 launches and 17 phase 3 launches planned for 2027.
Vulcan has 19 phase 2 launches and 2 phase 3 launches, also all planned for 2027.
This is not a path for success. DoD has hard choices...
Based on data received by our Launch Director, we confirm that the Vulcan vehicle launched from Space Launch Complex 41 suffered an anomaly 10 minutes into the flight and failed to deliver the Amazon mission to orbit.
Every flight generates data, and every flight teaches us something. Since the anomaly just occurred, we donโt have any specific data yet to understand what occurred today.
ULA exists to provide assured access to space for our nation and for the customers who depend on us. That purpose is why we take on some of the hardest missions in spaceflight, and why we hold ourselves to the standard of mission success. Today, we did not meet that standard.
We will work closely with our customer and other appropriate organizations to find the cause, determine the appropriate corrective action, and return to flight as quickly as possible.
ULA is committed to full transparency with our customers, and they will have visibility into the investigation process, which utilizes rigorous methodology and corrective action.
We will provide further updates when new information becomes available.
@Space_Strategy The analysis I've read said that refurbishing the SRBs was basically a wash - with all that you didn't save any money. You also had to deal with casings that were seriously out of round.
@kylecordes@Networkninja2k The problem is that bespoke payloads are a pain to deal with - most launches are custom and require special analysis - and they don't really pay very much.
Launching the identical thing over and over scales much easier. That's the lesson from starlink.
@Networkninja2k@kylecordes I did a video where I suggested that SpaceX might be willing to do launches for others who produce payloads that can fly in the Pez dispenser (or a taller version) as that would be simple for them to do.
I don't think they will go back to bespoke launches. Too much hassle...
@augustz Vulcan launch ramp up projections have never been realistic. Neither have New Glenn projections.
Peter Beck said 1/3/6 for the first three years of Neutron, and that seems like a reasonable projection.
So, "no".
@Brownson_Review I do videos when I think I have something unique to say and care enough about the topic to go to the effort.
This doesn't hit the bar right now...