@GetMadMike@ElectionMapsIF I’ll be sure to let the high school history teacher and the nurse (careful, she’s black, you might piss your pants if you ever met her since she’s not white) that live diagonal across the street that they’re wealthy. Or maybe you’re thinking of the social worker instead?
@ElectionMapsIF Sure thing buddy, you keep telling yourself that and being all afraid of the scary brown people instead of actually getting to know them.
@SaveOurStates The amount of attention a state gets under the EC is purely a quirk of political coalitions. There is nothing inherent in the structure to help rural states at all. If the close states happened to be more urbanized ones, their interests would be far more powerful than under PV,
@SaveOurStates The 10 smallest states (WY, VT, AK, ND, SD, DE, MT, RI, ME, and NH) received 2 campaign visits in total in 2024. And it has nothing to do with the states being small, it’s because NH was potentially competitive.
@ccwriter@ajzeigler Happened to Florida in 2000. They seemed to get over handing their EVs to the loser.
And who cares who gets the EVs? What’s the value to giving your state’s EVs to the candidate the lost the election just because that candidate won the state? It doesn’t make a difference.
@ccwriter@ajzeigler Yeah, it was slapped together at the last minute because they couldn’t find a better solution and had to be modified almost immediately because of obvious flaws, hence the 12th amendment in 1804.
Trump won the PV in 2024. What’s with the non sequitur?
@jsors2020@LuckyMcGee The EC allows a presidential candidate to win with even fewer votes. You could win the EC with *half* the votes from the population of the 12 largest states. At least with a PV mechanism, you would need 100% of their votes to win.
@CameronCorduroy The only things more stupid than the Electoral College are the arguments made by Electoral College proponents.
None of them understand it!
“It was carefully planned.” Nope.
“It’s designed to protect rural states.” Nope.
“5 states would elect the prez otherwise!” Nope.
@ingelramdecoucy Yet more evidence that EC defenders do not understand the EC. The EC does not provide an inherent bonus to rural states. It provides a bonus to low population states via the guarantee of 2 senators per state. Turn NYC into 100 states and suddenly the EC would have an urban bias.
@AndrewCFollett (3) Why are you endorsing a system that enables a quarter of the population to elect a president over the objection of the other three quarters?
@AndrewCFollett (1) Runoffs are common in the world and several states even use them in elections for various offices.
(2) If no one knows what elections to rig, how is it possible that presidential campaigns always focus on the same handful of states? Everyone knows the likely swing states.
@Pickens001@greendragonhq Again, you do not understand. If 50.1% of CA votes for candidate A, that person gets all of CA’s EVs. If 50.1% of TX, FL, NY, PA, IL, OH, GA, NC, MI, NJ, and NC vote the same while candidate B gets the other 49.9% plus 100% of the votes of the other 38 states, then A is president
@hulsey_ryan@greendragonhq There is no inherent advantage to urban or rural areas in the House, Senate, or EC. It is purely a facet of the historical construct of the states and their current political alignment and correlations. Republican states have just chosen to oppress their cities.
@Pickens001@greendragonhq Mathematically the EC allows someone to be elected president with 50.1% of the vote in 12 states and 0% of the vote in the other 38. It does the exact opposite of what its advocates claim, that it requires broad support. Again, you do not understand the system you are defending.
@hulsey_ryan@greendragonhq So we’ve already moved the goalposts from “rural areas don’t rule cities like conquered provinces” to “the cities totally deserve it” even though the cities are the growth engines while the rural areas are dying.
@Pickens001@greendragonhq Like most EC defenders you don’t actually understand how the EC works. The EC enables a quarter of the country’s population to outvote the other three-quarters.