Hi, Michelle. I'm going to try to respond to this post, as my eye is finally better! But only to this post and its thesis, that SSPX is, like your cat coming in and going out, somehow indecisive and neither leaving the modernist Church (as heretical) nor giving up its decades-long struggle and accepting Vatican II's doctrine and new mass and ending the division. I don't want to enter a protracted discussion--I'm not qualified and anyway would bore you! In anticipation, cutting to the chase, I am so glad they stay right up in Rome's face without yielding an inch of traditional doctrine and liturgy.
It is true that in pursuit of clarity over the doctrinal points at issue, there was some wobbling. Bishop Fellay in April of 2012 offered to accept Vatican II as long as it could be 'interpreted in light of tradition,' said the new mass was both valid and licit, and said the 1983 Code of Canon Law that expressed points at issue of VII as Church law could be accepted. SSPX clergy and laity protested, and in July of 2012 a General Chapter was called and issued a new document to Rome that said SSPX demanded "freedom to prohibit, correct, and reprove" VII, to exclusively celebrate the old mass, and the erection of internal tribunals to bypass the new Code. That unequivocal position has been maintained by the Superior General replacing Bishop Fellay up to now, Father David Pagliarani. These conditions were presented by SSPX to Rome at that time as firm clarifications of Fellay's offer, and the negotiations collapsed. The July statement and the election of Pagliarani represented the dominance of the SSPX 'hardliners' with a moderate wing seeking a personal prelature with Rome and a loosely organized breakaway group led by the expelled Bishop Williamson, the 'Resistance.'
SSPX has grown and its bishops have aged and it is physically impossible for them to continue to confirm laity and consecrate new priests to celebrate mass and administer the sacraments, and this 'state of necessity' has led, after years of discussion, to a scheduled consecration of new bishops, resulting in threats of new punishments by Rome. The names rumor is suggesting will be consecrated are all hardliners with positions of authority within SSPX, and because SSPX endured excommunication for so many years without diminution of its support and a complete erosion of Rome's coherent justification for such a radical punishment of Catholics guilty only of practicing Catholicism as it had been for centuries, there is no dread of that outcome, but only confidence that Rome will eventually come to its senses.
I personally pray that SSPX will stay right where it is, as I heard Bishop Fellay express it at one of the Kansas City conferences, 'out on the porch in the rain knocking on Rome's door, and Rome comes, and SSPX asks if they are ready to reject the errors of Vatican II and Rome shouts "No!" and slams the door and SSPX resumes knocking.' If Roman authority are men able to see and hear, eventually the relation of the terrible chaos in the world to the flawed doctrine of Vatican II (as powerfully predicted in Lefebvre's "They Have Uncrowned Him') will become clear. SSPX continues to express that connection at every opportunity, SSPX laity like myself continue to try to show it, and as long as we stay the course there is hope for the precious doctrine and liturgy of the True Church and not that protestantized mess holding the real estate but not the truth.
@FrLavery Well, those are different issues. Not even the pope can contradict the traditional teaching of the Church. And however cleverly narrated, he is. They have. All since the Council. SSPX stays on the porch, in the rain. Knocking. What else can good men do?
I see it too often in the obituaries of my class of 1962. They lived a Catholic life, were active members of a parish, and then in their 80's, died in a nursing home, and the notice says there will be a gathering to 'celebrate their life.' No extreme unction, confession, communion, or Catholic burial.
More outrageous unverifiable numbers by Merz.
Russia has been conservatively killing Ukrainians at a rate of 10 to one. So if Merz's numbers are correct… Then 500,000 Ukrainian soldiers were killed in the same month.
The verified body exchange numbers don't support your ridiculous claims Chancellor.
@MilitarySummary It's a race to see how many Russian soldiers die in a month vs. the number of Iranian protesters. The numbers keep going up from those that make them up.
But only what Russia and Iran believe/know counts for anything. Thus their lies just waste breath.
La FSSPX retoma su apostolado en Venezuela, interrumpido desde mediados de los años noventa. Tras varios años sin presencia sacerdotal, los contactos se reanudaron progresivamente y, en octubre de 2026, dos sacerdotes viajaron a Caracas.
https://t.co/tcIf8zjc5R
@themadameverite Капитализм - ты вырастил это, ты не смог это продать из-за конкуренции с корпорациями, банк забрал твой урожай и ферму из-за долгов по кредитам, приди в себя ебанашка!
This is the most intelligent answer I see here. Blaming AI is just another diversion from blaming the forces that use AI to indebt us, who are driving our country into ruin. And Marjorie went in the same direction with the Covid vaccine. Instead of supporting the vaccine for those who need it, it was total war on the vaccine. Now it's total war on AI.
@JohnCornyn@dallasnews I'm tired of you and Trump. And Cruz. I'm tired of anyone who thinks Jews are dispensed from conversion to Christianity. It's in the same category as denying sex reality or the real poverty of our American people. You will let us drown in debt and give our taxes to the devil!
@DocPriyamMD Shame on any of you who prescribe fluoroquinolones like Ciprofloxacin to any patient who will not die without one.
My life is likely over. And I wish that were hyperbole.