@ValentinRadu@jpcharles01 Agree with that split. For the gift version, timing matters too: send the offer close to when the first product would run out, not right after delivery, so the gift lands when they are ready to reorder.
@MEEcom44 Ideally the gift wins, since it's what keeps the price anchor. Simplest fix is to set the first threshold low enough that a cart still clears it after the BF code, then test it with the code applied. That's the exact spot where it breaks without anyone noticing.
@digital_darts That math is why I'd swap a flat 30% for tiers: 15% off at one cart value, 25% at a higher one. The deep discount only kicks in when the order is big enough to carry it. We stopped building tier rules by hand, we describe them in our own words now.
@sheun_hub Gift buyers and self-buyers need different December paths. For self-buyers on consumables, offer a subscription or membership perk on the next order instead of another code. Gift buyers get a "did they love it" email in January. What's your split usually?
@ecompayouts I'd add skip and pause right next to cancel, in the portal and in the pre-renewal email. Some renewal-day disputes come from people who simply had product left over. That same day is why we added chargeback protection to our subscription stack.
@chrisorzy Unique codes fix the sharing part. If you keep one public code, two Shopify settings still help: limit it to one use per customer, and make only a customer segment eligible, like customers with 0 orders. Then check what it combines with before BF.
@zach_cohen3 Makes sense. 5 core kits on a par level is easy to forecast. The 10-15 seasonal ones are where I'd expect leftover kits once the season ends. How do you usually clear those, unbundle them or discount the kit?
@jpcharles01@ValentinRadu Agree on value over a bigger code for the 2nd order. A gift with the next order keeps the price anchor and still gives them a reason to come back. We build gift rules like that with Flowly by describing them in our own words, in any language.
@zach_cohen3 That tradeoff is real. A middle path: pre-kit only the 2 or 3 fixed bundles that sell most, and let mix-and-match go out as loose picks. On the storefront side, mix-and-match is what we built BundleFlow for. Curious how many bundle variants you pre-kit today?
@kushj7777 Exactly, it stings because nobody notices until the margin report. Easiest fix is to keep the public code from combining with wholesale pricing. We built Flowly for rules like that: you describe the discount in your own words and it builds it in Shopify. https://t.co/egWgW0EjaO
@spencer_gilmore@itsalecdale same reason a lot of brands start looking around once volume grows. I work on Subscribfy, a Shopify app for subscriptions and loyalty. Happy to do a quick side by side on fees at your volume if useful, no pressure.
@MirMurtazaNoah I'd add one step: test the discounts you will actually run together, a code plus your automatic offer plus free shipping. Each can work alone and still not combine at checkout, because both discounts have to allow it. Which combo worries you most?
@ValentinRadu Shape over depth is the right call. One Shopify detail that makes depth worse for subscription brands: the code gets saved to the subscription contract, so set how many payments it applies to. Otherwise the BF discount keeps running on renewals long after BF.
For subscriptions on Shopify checkout, Shopify's help center lists Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, https://t.co/eVhBMndVxR, Adyen and Stripe as supported gateways. I'd confirm Bankful with both subscription apps before switching, since renewals need a gateway that can bill saved cards.
@sailesh_balu@ValoriLuca Shopify's own Bundles app handles fixed sets well. Mix-and-match is where it gets fiddly. We built BundleFlow (free) for that: shoppers pick the items on the product page, and any bundle can also be sold as a subscription. https://t.co/OQmdmMZ2lx
@palmbeachthemes I would bundle slow leftovers with a bestseller rather than put them on a clearance page that trains people to wait. A mix and match or build-your-own box can move those SKUs without a sitewide markdown. Keep the discount on the bundle, not on the hero product by itself.