@OldManLutheran Before Dan’s video, Wes’s PHD was already over. His commitment resigned over the summer because they found serious plagiarism.
He can still be an apologist, but his effectiveness will be tainted by his lack of integrity. He likely won’t be a scholar.
@stackerco You’re right, God does not just care about control. However, paying attention to a competent teacher will likely lead to greater learning.
Jesus also set up a small group of devoted followers, to whom He gave secret teachings, authority, and power. They then died for Him
@ScottTheAmazing Fair enough, I just find it somewhat improbable. If you are familiar with the simulation hypothesis, I think the same argument holds against the idea that we would share the planet with Jesus compared to the near infinite other options. Improbable under MM, expected under ER
@ScottTheAmazing Again very eloquent and I agree with almost everything you are saying. I would only have a small difference with your idea of Abraham 3 and the Greek concept of necessary being. That aside,
If we have infinite progress what are the odds that we are the first round?
@ScottTheAmazing Thanks! I think I really agree with you here, though you phrase it more eloquently that I could.
Can we have children after our exaltation that can undergo theosis?
If so there could be an infinite chain going forward. That might be the intuition behind infinite regress
@daxiel1992 I think both could be infinite, I don’t think that infinite entails singular, but I’m only loosely attached to the speculation on the Fathers mortality. I think both did something infinite
@daxiel1992 I’m interested in how you deal with the sermon in the grove. Do we just take the ‘was there ever a father without a son or a son without a father’ as idle speculation?
F and fielding both taught ER
@ScottTheAmazing I think that the eternally of God is real but its philosophical implications can be handled symbolically. To us God is eternally God. He also could have a father and still be the eternal father to us. If not He is less father and more some alien who adopts us.
@ScottTheAmazing I really like that, does this apply to us as well because we are eternal?
I think it can have multiple meanings, deep symbols typically do.
Thanks for sharing that with me I really appreciate it
@ScottTheAmazing I should clarify that I don’t think Oslerism is a break off church or some kind of heresy. It is one interpretation among many and it is still faithful to modern prophets. I am just stating my personal bias against rejecting Joseph’s climatic sermons.
@ScottTheAmazing It seems to me that there are many break off churches that agree with Joseph up to a point then break ways. Some stop at 1830 (bikertons), some Kirkland (rlds) some Nauvoo (culterites). I personally want to follow him all the way because I think he is closer to Christ than me.
@ScottTheAmazing I’m interested in your interpretation of the ring in more detail.
I am for the idea that the Father had a father, just not that it terminates in an infinite regress.
Will exalted beings create like the Father does? Will they have sons? Are we truly the same species as God?
@ScottTheAmazing Infinite regress is the name of a presumed logical error. The straw man is that it locks down the position past what Joseph taught. Joseph gives an analogy to a ring, without beginning or end, which is neither infinite nor a regress.
@ScottTheAmazing That is a strange interpretive framework. 98% of Joseph preaching doesn’t directly support eternal families, yet that is a treasured doctrine.
The word of Joseph Smith and the prophets take precedent over scriptures. Also Joseph understands the revelations better than us.