@MBDscience I had 4 days of negative LFTs after my children tested positive. I had symptoms after 2 days so booked a PCR (positive). The LFTs only showed positive the day after I did the PCR.
@wonkywitch Except that I never said that. I said petrol was not essential, as my subsequent posts have made clearer. Lots of people replied to explain why they need to drive, but the intention of my post was simoly to point out that lots of people need to consider alternatives to driving.
@AuthorSJB I wasn't intending it to be inflammatory (although it clearly has been). There was no intended criticism of either teachers or NHS staff in my post. I was objecting to the idea that I, as a teacher, would have an automatic right to fuel when others need it more.
@paulkleinyoo@MissBowdenEng Agreed, but their need for petrol might not be. Many people drive to work when viable alternatives do exist. Somehow this discussion seems to have become about whether people are essential or not, which was not my original point.
@paulkleinyoo@MissBowdenEng Did I ever say they weren't? I simply said that not all of them need petrol and that petrol, if scarce (which it currently seems to be) should be distributed based on need. The majority of journeys are short distance ones and many people (not all I know) do have alternatives.
@emmaweaver@MissBowdenEng I understand that and have never disputed many people's need for fuel. My objection was always to the idea that I should get fuel because I am a teacher (or whatever) rather than because of need. If I fill up then somebody else cannot. I am not trying to do down NHS staff.
@AuthorSJB @angelaclinton14 @Emma37083572@Craig_bellshaw@MissBowdenEng Could have been better phrased, certainly. It's not essential for all teachers to have petrol. We're all in a hole if we are entirely dependent on large amounts of petrol. We don't seem to have learned anything from the last fuel crisis and structural change is necessary...
@louiseh372 I agree. All shift workers have that problem. I am massively for better public transport. People need to use it enough to justify it, though, so services must be frequent enough for it to be viable. Dispite many posts here, many journeys are short and could be done in other ways.
@apsamuelson@MissBowdenEng I assume you're just trying condescension as a wind up. There are of course times when individuals may need to use a car. My OP was simply objecting to rationing by employer rather than on need. Posts implying I hate the NHS, disabled kids, rural dwellers, etc are way off.
@lerrup@MissBowdenEng Impossible, I'd say. I don't dispute that. Our current car dependence is a problem, as comments here confirm, and strategic planning should be trying much harder to address that. Some do need to drive, but all need to have choices and commuting miles should not be the norm.
@mcnultym1971 @AuthorSJB@MissBowdenEng Conversely, no point having the ambulance driver if no fuel in the ambulance, and many ambulance workers could still get to work without a car. If that driver gets the fuel, somebody else who might actually need it doesn't. PS. No need to be demeaning.
@BOBTAYL01081689@MissBowdenEng I am a grown up, thank you. I also agree that you might have a need for fuel. The problem is that so many people think they have exceptional needs and a selfish attitude to scarce resources, just as happened with toilet roll.
@Tom_K_doctor @MissBowdenEng If you have a need, yes of course. If you lived in the same city and could get the bus or travel another way then I think you should do that and save the fuel for those in greater need.
@MarvellousMrsP@MissBowdenEng I agree. The original post I made was simply to say that people like me should not be able to get fuel, ahead of others, simply because I happen to be a teacher. There is no reason why a doctor in a city, who could get a bus, should get fuel when others may have greater need.
@AuthorSJB@MissBowdenEng Why are you overreacting. Of course it is essential for staff to look after people and to go to work. It is just not essential for them all to drive cars to get there. A nurse is important, as is the bus driver who gets them to work, the person looking after their children, etc.
@MissBowdenEng I'm not having a go at people here. I recognise that I have chosen to live in a city and have chosen to apply for relatively local jobs. I do, however, think that the costs of car use (physical, environmental, social, time) are rising and will increasingly influence choices made.
@MissBowdenEng It is not essential for teachers to have petrol, nor for NHS staff - the whole 'list' idea is divisive and irrelevant. It IS essential for emergency services - fire engines, etc, should be usable and public transport must run. For almost all others, private car use is a choice.
@hannahjruth@MissBowdenEng Not much option in the short term I agree (other than a 'war footing' of staying with somebody closer). In the long run commuting such distances by car is going to become harder and harder though, and more expensive in both money and time...