TRADE REVIEW - 48 small losers, 4 big winners, +7.2% from closed trades
As promised, the reviews on my tech shorts $AMD $MU $SNOW $RBRK. I'm still new to the short side, so here are the numbers and what I can do better.
Final exit: I waited for a gap down, a big washout and the $VIX above 35. Got it on Friday and covered everything.
In total: from 11 to 20 Nov I closed 54 trades in 15 stocks. 48 were losers, costing about 16R (1.8% of the account). 6 were winners, but only these 4 made the difference: 81.4R and +9.0% on the account. The other two made 0.03% and 0.04%. Net result: closed trades made +7.2% of the account.
Still open: short $COST, $WMT, $KO and $DG, all in profit for now. I'll review them when they close.
$AMD
- Setup: 5 days up, 4 gap ups, ~45% off the lows. Shorted the rejection at the resistance gap, with $QQQ and $SPY rejecting key averages.
- 8th try, 7 failed tries cost 2.7R
- Short $591.54, stop $594.08 (-0.43%)
- Size ~20% of account, kept most overnight
- Avg cover $495.46 (+16.2%)
- 37.8R (35.1R after failed tries), +3.7% on the account
- Last shares: 60.7R, +26.1%
- 8 covers over 7 trading days (12-20 Nov)
$MU
- Setup: $QQQ rejected the 21 EMA and semis sold off into the close. $MU was one of the least extended and rejected its old base support. Shorted near the high of day.
- 13th try, 12 failed tries cost 3.9R
- Short $825.33, stop $827.62 (-0.28%)
- Size ~35% of account, ~10% overnight
- Avg cover $774.87 (+6.1%)
- 22.0R (18.2R after failed tries), +2.2% on the account
- Last shares: 93.3R, +25.9%
- 10 covers over 8 trading days (11-20 Nov)
$SNOW
- Setup: short against the 21 EMA. It was moving in tandem with the cybersecurity group.
- 4th try, 3 failed tries cost 0.7R
- Short $308.38, stop $310.12 (-0.56%)
- Size ~25% of account, ~15% overnight
- Avg cover $283.74 (+8.0%)
- 14.2R (13.4R after failed tries), +2.0% on the account
- Last shares: 28.7R, +16.2%
- 10 covers over 8 trading days (11-20 Nov)
$RBRK
- Setup: cybersecurity gapped up into resistance on a weak day. $CRWD and $S stopped me out, $RBRK worked.
- 1st try
- Short $121.62, stop $123.52 (-1.56%)
- Size ~10% of account, all held overnight
- Cover $107.57 (+11.6%)
- 7.4R, +1.1% on the account
- 1 cover, 2 trading days (19-20 Nov)
What worked:
- Small losses. The 48 losers cost 1.8% of the account, and the worst one 0.11%. I move my stop to breakeven fast. So 10 of the 22 failed tries before the winners exited within 0.1% of entry. With an 11% win rate, closed trades still made +7.2%.
- Runners. The last shares made the most R: 60.7R on $AMD, 93.3R on $MU, 28.7R on $SNOW.
What I can do better: manage the winners
- Cutting before the close to reduce overnight risk makes sense. But on $MU I sold more than half on day 1, at 1-2%, to pay for the paper cuts. Those trims paid back about two thirds of them (2.5R of 3.9R). The last shares made 93R.
- Holding everything to the final cover would have made about 190R and +20%, not 81R and +9%. That is hindsight, but it is a gap of 109R. All 48 losers together cost 16R.
Note: all stops above are the high of day 1, which I use as my swing stop. My intraday entry stops were tighter. 1R is about 0.1-0.15% of the account, so the R above is conservative.
Thanks, Lucian! To be honest, I usually also stop at third try on the long side. But on the short side I'm still learning to turn the system. upside down and I'm taking my time to figure out how to better read the price action. Can definitely wait a bit more for confirmation before executing without widening my stop that much. The great thing about landing one at 1st or 2nd try with super small stop to high of day is that I feel that I have the right to hold a large position overnight if I close the day with cushion. Great that you will be posting starting from January, I'll be following you on the journey
That's true @LeifSoreide, but it tells me whether I should be taking profits sooner, trimming on day 1 or letting it run. It points out my bad behaviours when I overtrade or do take a trade that I did not plan for, etc. It doesn't need to predict the future, it only needs to help me adjust in real time based on what happened on my last few trades.
@ETFbreakouts@LeifSoreide Do it, Josh! It was a game changer for me. I do not have trading buddies or participate in groups, so this programme with Claude really helps me. It's like a virtual coach.
Proud of my trading this week. Ended it at all-time highs.
Covered the rest of my tech shorts today: $AMD $MU $SNOW $RBRK. Great trades, I'll post some trade reviews on these during the weekend. They could go lower next week, but the odds of a bounce rise every day...
Best risk/reward on the short side now is staples, imo. Opened heavy shorts in $COST and $WMT today. I'm on a hot streak, so I'm pressing it. Still short half my $KO and two thirds of my $DG.
Capital is hiding in staples. When tech gets its oversold bounce, I expect that money to rotate out and this group to crack.
Got exactly what I wanted. Gap down, big washout and VIX spiking to 35+. Covered all my tech shorts $AMD, $MU, $RBRK and $SNOW.
Yeah, they migh continue lower next week, but the risk of losing unrealized profits is not great here. Awesome 2-7 day shorts on these.
I feel that the best reward is probably on large value stocks that have not yet cracked. So, I'm short some staples.
@ETFbreakouts Today still did not feel like panic to me. See so many people buying the dip on neoclouds etc... Hopefully we get an ugly gap down open tomorrow and a big washout, with the VIX spiking to 35+. That would be my dream, to cover the shorts.
@ETFbreakouts I didn't even know what the stock market was in 2018, but I trust you :) I'll likely short against the MAs again if there's a bounce, until I'm proven wrong and have to flip.