The Nazis didn’t invent “race science”, Marx and Engels were all over it as well. The Fabian’s also promoted eugenics. Marx himself was a racist and antisemitic.
Be kind of ironic if race science proves to have foundations but historically just for the wrong reasons. It will bury a central dogma of far left ideology.
1 It was state capitalism (ie fraudulent socialism)
2 Much spying and other info exchange happened, the soviets were and remained poor at innovation
3 Blowing large sums of capital on tech projects when people are queuing for bread and toilet paper isn’t an own
4 Something about Chernobyl
Fuentes says something rather like this about the GOP, they are “controlled opposition”, their fight against the far left is purely a performance lacking any substance. This pattern is repeated in other countries like a program.
The left can control the right, but not real anti authoritarians.
@Rakeshhkumaar State capitalism substituted the private business owners with a team of bureaucrats and their bosses. A weakening in power relations between the workers and who controls them.
Reductio: The argument collapses into “rights exist only as privileges granted by whoever holds the monopoly on force.”
Assume the claim is true: there are no negative rights; every right (including freedom from murder) exists only insofar as some person or group expends labor and deploys a credible threat of violence to enforce it; therefore “who has the right” is decided by those who supply that enforcement.
This immediately yields absurdities:
1Rights vanish the moment enforcement is withdrawn. In a failed state, a remote wilderness, or any situation where no third party is willing to protect you, you have no right not to be murdered. A killer who succeeds is not violating a right; he is merely operating in a zone where the relevant “provider” chose not to supply one. Most people regard this as false: the murder is still a rights-violation even if no one stops it or punishes it.
2Arbitrary denial is licensed. If the providers decide who has the right, then a regime or dominant group can simply refuse to “provide” the right not to be murdered for a disliked minority, class, or outsider. On the argument’s own terms, those people then have no such right, and killing them does not violate a right. This is the logic that underwrote every system of legalized oppression in which the powerful defined the protected class. The conclusion is that rights talk reduces to “whatever the enforcers currently choose to defend.”
3Self-defense becomes incoherent. If you successfully stop an attacker with your own force and no third party’s labor, the argument must say either (a) you had no right that was being protected, or (b) you magically became the “provider” of your own right in the moment of resistance. Neither is coherent. The ordinary understanding is that the attacker was already under a duty not to kill you; your resistance simply prevented the violation.
4Infinite regress on the providers themselves. The enforcers’ own right not to be murdered, and their right to decide whom they will protect, must themselves be provided by still further enforcers. There is no ground floor. The claim that “who has the right is up to the person providing it” cannot be applied consistently to the providers without circularity or an infinite chain.
The underlying confusion is between a right and its contingent protection. A negative right is primarily a duty of non-interference that binds everyone (do not murder, do not steal, etc.). Whether that duty is effectively backed by third-party force is a practical question about security, not a question that determines whether the duty or the correlative right exists. Enforcement can be imperfect, selective, or absent without extinguishing the right; that is precisely why we can still call the unpunished murder a violation. Treating the right as identical with the labor that happens to enforce it erases the distinction and turns every rights claim into a description of current power relations.
@WilliamKin65977@_Credible_Hulk Why not answer the question?
I can pay another person(s) for protection, this does not have to involve “society” or any notion of “rights”. It’s just a mutually beneficial transaction.
@garylfrancione Absence of evidence isn’t evidence of absence, and there is evidence even in other species.
Who are the geneticists?
https://t.co/yinsixctvB
@kim_siever Without profit wealth does not accumulate
Without wealth accumulation there’s no capital to purchase capital goods
Without capital goods workers labour in primitive low productivity conditions
@MurphyOfMercia Accept the Nazis were another kind of socialist faction and also supported by the German communist party. History is much more nuanced than the urban myths have it.