The spiral of silence is a theory of public opinion developed by German political scientist Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann in the 1970s. It describes how people tend to remain silent when they believe their views are in the minority, which in turn makes the majority view appear even stronger and further discourages dissent.
Core idea
People constantly scan their social environment (through media, conversations, and observation) to gauge which opinions are dominant or gaining strength. Those who feel their view is on the rise or already majority are more willing to speak out. Those who perceive their view as losing ground or minority become more reluctant to express it, fearing social isolation. This silence makes the minority position seem even smaller, reinforcing the spiral.
Noelle-Neumann called this the “spiral of silence.” The fear of isolation is the key psychological driver. Humans are social animals who monitor the “climate of opinion” to avoid being rejected or ostracized.
Key mechanisms
•Quasi-statistical sense: People develop an intuitive sense of the distribution of opinions in society, largely shaped by media.
•Willingness to speak out: Strongly influenced by the perceived trend (which side is winning) rather than just the absolute majority.
•Media’s role: Mass media are especially powerful because they can present a particular view as the majority or as the direction of the future, even if it is not yet so in reality. This can create a “silent majority” or amplify a vocal minority.
•Hard cores: There are always small groups (the “hard cores”) who will speak out regardless of isolation. They can break the spiral if they gain enough visibility.
Classic conditions
The theory works best when:
•The issue is morally or emotionally charged.
•There is a clear perception of a dominant opinion.
•Social isolation has real costs.
•Media coverage is relatively uniform or strongly framed in one direction.
Evidence and examples
Noelle-Neumann tested the theory extensively in Germany, especially around political issues. Later research has found support in various contexts (e.g., environmental issues, political correctness debates, wartime public opinion). Classic illustrations include:
•People underestimating support for certain policies or candidates because dissenters stay quiet.
•Rapid shifts in expressed opinion once a new “climate” is perceived (the spiral can reverse).
Criticisms and limitations
•Individual differences: Not everyone fears isolation equally. Personality, education, and strength of conviction matter.
•Social media: The theory was developed for mass media. Online spaces can create “echo chambers” or allow minority views to find communities, sometimes weakening the spiral or creating multiple competing spirals.
•Pluralistic ignorance: Related but distinct — people can misperceive the majority opinion. The spiral of silence focuses more on the dynamic of speaking vs. remaining silent.
•Empirical mixed results: Some studies strongly support it; others find weaker effects depending on the issue and culture.
Connection to the earlier discussion
In the Serbian context we discussed (two years of agenda-setting around corruption, the Novi Sad canopy collapse, and the student protests leading to a “referendum atmosphere”), the spiral of silence is relevant in both directions:
•For a long time, fear of isolation or professional/social costs may have kept many people quiet about systemic problems despite private dissatisfaction.
•Once protests became large and visible (especially after 2024–2025), the perceived climate shifted. More people felt it was safe or even socially rewarded to express opposition, accelerating the spiral in the opposite direction and contributing to the binary “for or against” atmosphere.
The theory helps explain why public opinion can appear more unified than it actually is, and why it can shift relatively quickly once the climate of opinion changes.
A transgender physician has been suspended from a "gender affirming care" clinic in Canada after being accused of disturbing sexual misconduct with a vulnerable patient.
Dr. James "Jemstone" Bathe identifies as a lesbian and a "Guernsey cow."
https://t.co/DcUyqW1xSX
Woman of the Day Karen Harrison, born OTD in 1960 in Glasgow, the UK’s first female train driver and the first woman to preside over an ASLEF conference. She endured ten years of sustained verbal and physical harassment from management and staff but refused to give up.
In 1977, 17 year old Karen applied to British Rail to become a Secondman, the first step on the way to becoming a train driver. In those days, a Secondman assisted the driver of the train by operating the heating systems, shunting the train when required and generally assisting the driver. It was a sort of apprenticeship. They could learn by observation before sitting the drivers’ tests and exam.
She proceeded to the interview stage but only because she’d applied as K. Harrison and British Rail thought she was a lad. When it realised its mistake, it tried to shunt her into the typing pool but she stood her ground. No, she said: train driver.
The law was on her side. After all, this was 1977; the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 removed the barriers to women’s employment if they were otherwise suitable for the job.
Then again, the law is also on the side of women and men who hold gender critical beliefs. It doesn’t stop them from being harassed, investigated for spurious reasons (“malicious communications”, anybody?) and even hounded out of their jobs, does it? The process is the punishment. But I digress…
Karen started work at Old Oak Common, a traction maintenance depot west of Paddington, formerly used for storing and servicing locomotives. The unrelenting wave of misogyny started immediately.
"Ten years of hell, ten years of heaven. It's a bit tough when you're only a teenager and you're hit by this gigantic tidal wave of hate. To a lot of the men, I was the proverbial turd in the swimming pool. Every day I walked into the mess room I'd be s***ting myself, but strutting about pretending not to be. I couldn't let them create no-go areas for me; that would've established a precedent and we couldn't have that, could we? It would've been the beginning of the end."
There was next-to-no support from colleagues or management. Almost to a man, they didn’t want her there and they used every opportunity to ensure she knew it.
“It was open warfare. People wouldn’t work with me, people put notes up about me, my locker was defaced. Graphic pornography went up in the mess rooms.”
By people, Karen meant men of course. All of her harassers were big brave men, including some who probably prided themselves as respectable family men with wives and daughters. When I say “almost to a man”, there was an honourable exception however: the old-style Communists at the depot. “It was like being raised by wolves. They did a grand job, bless them."
Ultimately, don’t mess with a Glaswegian. Karen overcame every single manmade obstacle thrown in her path and qualified as a train driver in 1979. She credited her resilience to her Scottish genes, “rich in stubbornness”.
After her ten years of hell, Karen transferred to Marylebone and it must have been like emerging from the deep, dark forest into the light. A member of ASLEF, she earned a solid reputation with her fellow trade unionists, campaigned for improved conditions for women in the rail industry, and in 1995 was elected as lay member to preside over an ASLEF conference.
A bout of meningitis put paid to Karen’s career as a train driver but she secured employment as a full-time officer for UNISON and represented members at employment tribunals (that was in the good old days of course when unions actually knew was a woman was). She never lost a case and her experience prompted her to study law at Oxford as a mature student.
“It was hard, f****** hard, but it's easier than driving a trains for a living. It's hard to get too stressed about exams when you've experienced things like brake failure approaching a red signal, especially when you can see another train crossing the junction in front of you. I still miss the camaraderie of my mates in ASLEF. I miss them terribly. The folk at my college are the closest I've got to that old espirit de corps and they put up with an old bag like me with great stoicism."
Karen was due to graduate in May 2011 — her plan was to work as a barrister specialising in labour law and human rights — but she died a matter of weeks before her 50th birthday.
Today, just 6.5% of train drivers are women but there is a touching tribute to Karen at Euston Station: a giant mural encouraging more women to apply.
Meanwhile, her old union UNISON, whose membership is 70% female, continues to insist that blokes in dresses are women too, and its leadership has described gender critical views as misinformation, aligned with far-right tactics to restrict single-sex spaces to just women.
I think I can guess what Karen Harrison would have to say about that, but those women (and men) who are trying to restore sanity to their union from within might be heartened by her words.
“I never wanted to be pushed out. I knew if I’d left the railway, I’d have let these people win and what was happening was wrong and it wasn’t fair.”
The Women of the Day are Sophia Jex-Blake, Mary Pechey, Isabel Thorne, Matilda Chaplin, Helen Evans, Mary Anderson and Emily Bovell, known as the Edinburgh Seven, who had to face down a mob of rioting male students at the University of Edinburgh OTD in 1870 trying to prevent them from sitting their anatomy exams.
The University’s special treatment of women began the previous year when Sophia Jex-Blake applied to study medicine. It was an all-male preserve and tried to stop her, claiming it couldn’t possibly be expected to make arrangements for “just one lady” so she advertised in newspapers for other women to join her. Mary Pechey responded straightaway, followed by the other five.
“Do you think anything more is requisite to ensure success than moderate abilities and a good share of perseverance? I believe I may lay claim to these, together with a real love of the subjects of study…”
The University had no choice but to admit them so it thought of another cunning wheeze. It announced it would charge them more than men for attending the same classes. The Seven paid. Sophia actually tutored the other six in mathematics.
The real trouble started when the women came top of the class, making four of them eligible for a prestigious scholarship on the basis of their stellar results. The University promptly awarded the scholarships to four men with lower marks.
Under the influence of some of the professors, faculty staff who had initially supported the women began to back off. Male students began treating them with open contempt, slamming doors in their faces, crowding into seats that they usually sat in, bursting into "horse laughs and howls" whenever the women approached.
Sophia said: “What means were used in the interim I cannot say, or what influence was brought to bear: but I do know that from that day the conduct of the students was utterly changed, that those who had hitherto been quiet and courteous became impertinent and offensive…It was as if a conspiracy had been formed to make our position as uncomfortable as might be".
Her doorbell was wrenched off, her nameplate damaged five times, fireworks were attached to her door. The rest of the Seven had smoke blown in their faces and filthy letters sent to them. They were waylaid in quiet streets. Obscenities and insults like “whore” were shouted at them in public. (Does that sound familiar at all?)
The women started taking precautions, walking around campus together as a group for safety, but events came to a head exactly 156 years ago today in what became known as the Surgeons’ Hall Riot.
Sophia said, “On the afternoon of Friday 18th November 1870, we walked to the Surgeons’ Hall, where the anatomy examination was to be held. As soon as we reached the Surgeons’ Hall we saw a dense mob filling up the road…The crowd was sufficient to stop all the traffic for an hour. We walked up to the gates, which remained open until we came within a yard of them, when they were slammed in our faces by several young men…who stood within, smoking and passing about bottles of whisky while they abused us in the foulest possible language.”
The women had managed to pick their way through the threatening crowd while several hundred men blocked their way, pelted mud and rubbish at them and shouted insults and threats only to find themselves trapped when the gates were slammed in their faces. They had to endure the hostility until a sympathetic student opened the gates for them.
The women sat their exams and despite their ordeal, all of them passed, four with honours. Edith Pechey won first place over all of the candidates. None of that made the slightest bit of difference to the University. It denied all seven women their hard-won degrees.
Some male students were shocked by the way they had been treated and escorted them back to their digs safely. For weeks after, those students acted as bodyguards, escorting them to and from classes.
Despite the vocal support of Charles Darwin and 300 others, the Court of Sessions delivered the final blow and supported the University's right to refuse the women degrees. They also ruled, by a majority, that the women should never have been admitted in the first place.
Five of the Seven had to go to Paris or Bern to qualify as doctors. Sophia Jex-Blake returned to Edinburgh in 1878 to set up practice as the city’s first woman doctor but that she considered that the case brought such unwelcome publicity for the University, it helped to pave the way for more to follow.
“I believe that it was the seed sown in tears in Edinburgh that was reaped in joy elsewhere.”
This is just devastating.
Labour's Naz Shah MP establishes Baroness Cass was basically misled and pressured into a quote which the government minister then hawked around.
That might have worked in 2016, but gender has moved on.
At a Stonewall reception in parliament last night on the draft Bill on Conversion Practices a speaker said:
"Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller." Everyone laughed uproariously at this.
Is it funny Stonewall that a generation of young lesbians have been told that they are in fact trans and need to destroy their healthy bodies and minds? Is it funny that middle-aged lesbians want to warn against this?
When was it exactly that you lost your moral compass?Is there any lower for you to go? How dare you pretend this Bill would protect young homosexuals - all you want is to destroy them.
@annimaye246@treesey Maybe, or maybe she has experienced sexual abuse from the father - many transitioning adolescents have, especially girls.
Either way, it’s barking mad and can only harm her, to criminalise anyone who expresses concern to her.
@TheJuliaFarnese As the only surviving daughter, I’m lucky that 1 of my brothers stepped up to help. But, yeah, “sister’s husband” did way more for my parents than my other two brothers. One of them barely made Mom’s funeral as he was shopping for sports gear 🙄
@zchzmm@goldman You illustrate my point perfectly. You want to believe there’s a conspiracy against your generation when the truth is that everyone other than the 1% have been screwed over.
Keeping us angry with each other is a genius distraction
Woman of the Day Dr Josephine Baker, born OTD in 1873 in Poughkeepsie, New York, the leading expert of her time on children's health. She reduced infant mortality rate by 40% in Hell’s Kitchen but if you think that was welcomed by her male peers, think again.
In 1900, Josephine graduated from the Women's Medical College set up by the pioneering sisters Elizabeth and Emily Blackwell, and after scoring very highly in the civil service exam, she qualified as a Department of Health medical inspector. She was assigned to Hell's Kitchen, one of the worst slums in New York with a mortality rate of 4,500 a week — yes, you read that right, 4,500 a week — 1,500 of whom were children.
“I climbed stair after stair, knocked on door after door, met drunk after drunk, filthy mother after filthy mother, and dying baby after dying baby."
Josephine rolled up her sleeves and set to work. She assembled a team of nurses to teach mothers how to care for their babies: how to clothe them to keep them from getting too hot, how to feed them well, how to keep them from suffocating in their sleep, and how to keep them clean. She set up a milk station dispensing clean milk and invented an infant formula that was safe, thus enabling women to work so they could support their families. She tackled infant blindness caused by inherited gonorrhoea by inventing a safe eye treatment. She insisted that midwives be trained, registered and licensed. Infant mortality rates plummeted.
Having told a New York Times reporter during WWI that it was "six times safer to be a soldier in the trenches of France than to be a baby born in the United States”, Josephine used the resulting publicity to set up a school lunch programme for older children and to insist that each school had a doctor and nurse.
Recognising her achievements, the city formed the Bureau of Child Hygiene in 1908 and appointed Josephine as chief, a position she held for fifteen years.
By the end of her tenure and as a direct result of her public health initiatives, New York had the lowest infant mortality rate of any city in the USA or Europe. You would think she’d have the full support of male physicians in the city, wouldn’t you?
Not a bit of it. Fewer sick women and children meant less money for doctors. A number of Brooklyn physicians actually raised a petition urging the mayor to put a stop to her programme: “It is ruining medical practice by its results in keeping babies well.” Josephine tartly responded: “This is the first compliment I’ve received since the Bureau of Child Hygiene was established.”
(You’ll have to read my thoughts at this stage. Those doctors put me in mind of a subpar prison nurse who grumbled, “I can’t get my work done for having to see to all these sick women.”)
In 1916, the dean of the New York University Medical School recognised Josephine’s considerable expertise and asked her to present lectured to his students on public health. She agreed on one condition: that she also be allowed to enrol and attend classes. It was a step too far. The college explicitly barred women from attending the college and he refused to change the rules so she told him to find someone else.
“I can hardly be accused of acting unreasonably because I declined to act as teacher in an institution that considered me unfit for instruction.”
No one else could match her experience so the dean gave in, which meant he had to open the doors to other women as well. I can practically hear his teeth grinding even now, 110 years later.
When Josephine began delivering her first lecture to male medical students, she was immediately interrupted by thunderous clapping.
It wasn’t applause. It was “the flat, contemptuous whacking rhythms with which the crowd at a baseball game walk an unpopular player from the outfield”. At the end of her lecture, they did the same. Josephine left the classroom “frightened and tired...from talking a solid hour against a gloweringly hostile audience”.
Those men kept it up at every lecture she delivered for YEARS and never once stopped to think just how lucky they were to attend lectures by such an outstanding public health expert. They were too busy drowning out her voice and behaving like spoiled brats.
I’d like to tell you that this kind of idiotic behaviour by second- and third-rate men just doesn’t happen anymore but you’d know straightaway I was being sarky.
Josephine was offered the post of Assistant Surgeon-General of the USA and would have become the first woman ever to hold a federal government position but she turned it down so that she could continue her vital work. It is estimated that she saved around 82,000 lives.
A 14 yr old girl
“Her periods were very erratic and heavy. If she went to the toilet and tried to clean herself up, she had lads banging on the door saying: 'I know what you're doing. If all the blood hadn't flushed straightaway, the lads would follow with, 'Oh, you dirty cow'’
@jk_rowling In Canada, a man who raped a three-month old infant is housed in a women's rehabilitation facility with a mother-child unit.
When Amnesty says "human rights," they mean men.
"Trans rights" means granting predatory and depraved men more rights than women.