@joshwgoodson It could work, 100% but to me it screams buddy hire. If Phil is calling plays you should get a crooter, if it’s system familiarity plenty of people have seen a west coast offense, if it’s to be a TE whisperer hire him for that not like he had a job you had to pry him from
@joshwgoodson I’m a fan of thinking outside the box! There are outside the box hires that you could sell me. However those outside the box hires are young innovators and not 48 year olds who blew their shot
@joshwgoodson It’d be so sick if you actually ever addressed what I actually said for once
It absolutely could work I’ve said as much!
My concern is the only two defenses of the hire have been
“Have you considered Phil is omniscient”
“He’s actually really good but I won’t expand on why”
@joshwgoodson By what account was he the best “sales person” at the company. And he got his crack at it already and he was dogshit and for over a decade everyone agreed on that but apparently you have to have blind trust
@PanthersGuy26@joshwgoodson Well I certainly wouldn’t expect the next one of those guys to be older than those guys like Jason. I would be happy with a P4 promotion ie Ra’shaad Samples, a G5 HC ie Major Applewhite, a G5 OC ie Cam Aiken/Mitch Dahlen, a retread ie Arbuckle, a young innovative NFL guy etc
@PanthersGuy26@joshwgoodson Because the goal (in my mind) was for him to be a CEO type and hire insanely competent, accomplished, and qualified coordinators
@joshwgoodson I don’t have a crystal ball and I acknowledged these hires can work it’s just with less frequency
There’s still hires to be made it can be turned around just not an enthusiastic start
The only time he was OC he went 5-27 and was promptly demoted
@joshwgoodson It’s not about whether it works or not. It’s about good process. Hiring a friend who hasn’t been an OC for a full season, that partial season being over a decade ago, is old, has been out of a job for over a year, and has no college experience that’s bad process
@ztapenguin@TuffyTalkNow 1) he’s only been an OC for part of 1 season over a decade ago and he got demoted
2) no college experience
3) it’s a pure buddy hire
@joshwgoodson Spidey senses say even if so you should get a crooter OC and not a 50 year old who has only been an OC once for less than a season a decade ago and never in college