At bigger scale, one of the prolems I see is the SOPs.
Things just get messy, and the focus becomes how to fix the machine with the increased volume.
For example creatives becomes a BIG mess.
10 ads a week, easy.
250 ads a week, MEEEEESSSSSSSS.
So you need to change the SOP so that the team can handle it
By the time most brands find their Black Friday winning ad, Black Friday is over.
Here's how it usually goes
The offer goes live right before the big day. New ads launch at test budgets, because nobody knows yet which one works.
Three days later the data's in. You've found it.
And the window is closing.
So you shove budget at it as fast as you can, over about two days. You get it up a good amount, but still feel like it had so much more to give.
From what I have seen, the brands that handle this well start earlier.
Not the full Black Friday offer. Something lighter. Early access, a warm up deal, a smaller version of what's coming.
That one decision buys them five things:
-> testing happens before the window, so winners get found while there's still time to use them
-> those winners get scaled gradually up to the big offer
-> by the big days the account is already spending a lot
-> scaling campaigns are already built and running, instead of being set up under BFCM
-> and when the full offer drops, it lands on an ad that's already proven and already carrying real budget
The difference can be enormous.
One brand has a proven winner that's been climbing for two weeks, taking serious spend through the peak without breaking.
The other has an ad that finally started working, then is shut off.
There are many ways of doing BFCM, but this is one that I really like.
The smartest thing Rockstar did with GTA 6 was refuse to answer anything.
Seventeen months between trailers. In all of 2024 they released nothing new, just the same trailer reuploaded in better quality.
Here's the part that's easy to miss.
That silence wasn't empty. It was the most productive marketing they did.
With no official information, the audience made their own. Frame by frame breakdowns. Map theories. Countdown accounts. Release date predictions. Millions of hours of fan content, all of it free, all of it keeping the game in people's feeds for three years.
If Rockstar had answered every question, there would have been nothing left to argue about.
That's the trade almost nobody thinks about.
When you say everything, you leave your audience nothing to say.
The gap is what creates the conversation.
10 questions that will tell you more about your business than any dashboard.
If a competitor copied your product tomorrow, who would still choose you?
Can you say who this is for in one sentence, without using the word “everyone”?
What’s the last thing a customer told you that you didn’t want to hear?
When did you last buy from your own site, all the way through, on your phone?
What do people almost buy, then don’t? Do you know why?
Which of your ads would you stop scrolling for if it wasn’t yours?
If you had to double your price, what would have to change?
What’s the one test you keep meaning to run and keep pushing back?
If you disappeared for a month, what breaks first?
What are you doing because it works, and what are you doing because you’ve always done it?
The uncomfortable ones are the ones worth sitting with.
The five stages of launching a new ad:
1. refreshing after 20 minutes as if something could possibly have happened
2. it spent $1 and got one click, this is the best ad anyone has ever made
3. hour six, zero sales, this is the worst ad anyone has ever made
4. day two, it’s fine actually, you were insane yesterday
5. day nine, it’s your top performer and you’ve completely forgotten you nearly killed it on day one