if I claim to be a wise man,
it surely means that I don't know.
This is a former elder & seminarian's place to discuss theology & share posts from the blog
Though we debate aspects of being in Christ, think we can all agree:
if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creature
[having been]
created in Christ Jesus to do good works
[which we do with]
our liberty which we have in Christ
[so we]
do not turn [our] freedom into an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another
Sigh. We aren't debating whether God must create and sustain all that exists. Creation absolutely depends on God
We are exploring whether creation is a necessary consequence of who God is or a genuinely free expression of divine agency. And that is a modal question in philosophical theology
Could God have actualized a different possible world?
Could God have refrained from creating altogether?
Is God's decision to create contingent, or does God's nature necessitate the existence of creation?
You answered that He could not because creation is necessitated by His nature
Nope. Just asking you to clarify the postive account for your view
There were several terms and questions but here's an easy two
---
(1) "determine" is a term that can be ambiguous. It could mean to decide or resolve that X occur or it could refer to some divine mechanism that necessitates that X occur. **It seems clarity is needed to disambiguate which sense is meant by "determine"**
(2) If by "ultimate cause” one means more than having a purpose for what one decided that should be clearly stated.
The additional claim made is that this decree (which seems to be analogous to determination) makes something certain. **Missing is why a decree makes something certain?**
@Matthew0390@DPGBehler@dhanabarger You disproved nothing. And I didn't say I wouldn't articulate or defend my view. I just wasn't going to let you distract the discussion away from your claims
@wcmclaa Absolutely ridiculous claim.
A quick starter pack
Alvin Plantinga
William Lane Craig
JP Moreland
Garrett DeWeese
RT Mullins
Alan Padgett
Guillaume Bignon
John Peckham
James Dolezal
@Matthew0390@DPGBehler@dhanabarger What I hold, for the moment, should not matter when it comes to articulating your own viewand handling critiques
I've offered a clear syllogism and the common definition for contingent in these discussions
The modal collapse is a common criticism against your premise
From this I assume the answer to my question is Augustine is the infallible benchmark for the Bible's table of contents. Is that right?
But from this principle it seems any bishop could offer a list. What makes one list or one bishop more authoritative than another?
Athanasius was a bishop also. Yet his list of deuterocanonical books is not the same. Why prefer Augustine over Athanasius?
That's not the argument. Many patristic writers include deuterocanonical books alongside the OT and NT. And others throughout the history of the church pushed back on their canonical status. In addition the books that were included also varied
We then ask which council or bull established the infallible, dogmatic "table of contents"?
This seems even worse, as clearly Jesus is the way, truth and life. All who believe in Him will have eternal life. And the certificate of debt was cancelled at the cross
I don't understand why many Catholics would rather fight to elevate Mary rather than God
God is our refuge and strength ... in whom [we] trust
Psalm 46:1; 91:2; Heb 6:18
@Matthew0390@DPGBehler@dhanabarger A contingent statement is one that is true in some possible worlds and false in others. It sits directly between what is necessary (true in all possible worlds) and what is impossible (true in no possible worlds)
@Emydius@wcmclaa You can ditch the testimony of a contemporary to the synods when the NT canon was being firmed up
But you ignored the question: which council or list is the infallible benchmark?
Sorry, I didn't read 2 pages of screenshots when your comment above stated things very clearly
Looking at that opening...
God will "certainly" choose the best/optimal matches your original statement that there is "no possibility" to not choose best
These all fit the notion of "require" and none change the basic premise nor prevent modal collapse
@Matthew0390@DPGBehler@dhanabarger Premise 2 is your statement that God must choose the best/optimal option
The rest of the syllogism shows the ramifications. It's called modal collapse
Nothing you said deals with what logically flows from the argument you made that results in modal collapse
1) essentially God is perfectly wise and good by nature
2) perfect wisdom and goodness require that God always do what is best (or optimal)
3) Among possible acts (including the act of creating and not creating), there is a uniquely best option
4) God necessarily performs that uniquely best act. (From 1-3)
5) God actually creates this universe (W)
6) W was the best option (from 4-5)
7) Therefore, God could not have done otherwise than create W. W’s existence is necessary, not contingent.
@Matthew0390@DPGBehler@dhanabarger Does God lack any agency beyond expressing the single act His nature requires?
If yes that means nothing God does is contingent since God's nature can't change
That means God creating this universe was a necessity act of God
A decision governed by nature and wisdom (among other factors) is one that is ultimately determined by the agent to be one way and not another. That is an agent causal account of LFW
Now, if you want to argue that something that is not God determined God's choice to be one way with certainty you'd start to carve out a soft determinist view of decision making