How much of your mortgage interest will you ever see back?
I can talk you through the economics of the property we currently rent.
We pay £36,000 a year in rent.
The property would cost around £750,000 to buy.
Assuming a 10% deposit, that’s a £675,000 mortgage.
At 5% interest, that’s £33,750 a year. Just in interest…
Then there’s the £75,000 deposit and £27,500 in stamp duty.
So you’ve committed over £100,000 of your savings upfront, and you’re still paying almost £34,000 a year in mortgage interest.
And that’s before maintenance or the opportunity cost of having £100,000 tied up in the property.
So, would you rather pay £36,000 a year in rent and keep your £100,000 invested, or commit that money to buying, lose £27,500 immediately to stamp duty, and still pay almost the same amount in interest?
That’s why I don’t accept the argument that renting is simply throwing money away
I think this will be one of the defining economic stories of our generation.
In July 2025, I wrote an article titled “Owning a Home Is No Longer the Smartest Investment.”
I explained why I’ve chosen to rent rather than buy, and why I believe the decades-long upward trajectory of house prices is unlikely to continue.
A lot of people disagreed with me.
Our parents told us that buying a home was one of the smartest financial decisions you could make.
But younger generations were sold that dream at a completely different price.
(A bit like getting a university degree, you could say)
Over the last 10 years, first-time buyers paid high multiples of their income to get onto the property ladder, taking on large mortgages, only to discover that property doesn’t deliver the growth their parents enjoyed.
Those who bought decades ago benefited from falling interest rates, the shift from single-income to dual-income households, and easier mortgage availability.
I manage investments for a living, so I find Britain’s obsession with property really interesting.
I’ve deliberately chosen to rent.
Not because I don’t want to own a home, but because I questioned whether buying one at those valuations represented good value.
The money I could have spent on a deposit and stamp duty has been invested instead.
For example, shareholders of companies benefit from economic growth, innovation and rising profits.
My income has grown faster too due to inflation.
That means my purchasing power relative to property prices has improved.
My savings are also more liquid than property, giving me far more financial security.
And with mortgage rates around 4-5%, the trade-off between paying a landlord and paying mortgage interest was minimal.
I think we’re witnessing a fundamental shift in how wealth is created in Britain.
Some of the core themes in my writing and podcasts has been “what happens when the advice that worked for our parents no longer works for us?”
My original article: https://t.co/V90xPDr2Eh
Most people are simply too short-term in their thinking.
I believe one of the greatest gifts of taking an active interest in investing is that it gives you a much more optimistic outlook of the future. You get a peek through the keyhole at technologies that could become mainstream 10 or 15 years from now.
A great example is Jensen Huang talking about Nvidia’s CUDA technology back in 2008, and how it dramatically accelerates computing speed.
18 years later, CUDA powers the AI tools we use.
People take that for granted. They just see ChatGPT as something that launched in 2022.
@bubbotron3000 Not with the renters rights bill. They can’t even refuse pets now.
And just to clarify, the intention is to buy. Just being patient until they are significantly better value (measured by house price-to-earnings ratio).
Absolutely! I just haven’t felt comfortable with the price-to-earnings multiples on property. Ultimately, that’s what dictates the size of the mortgage, and makes affordability especially sensitive to changes in interest rates.
I do actually think there’s better value coming back into property now and we’re waiting for the right time to buy. If I had to guess, it would be in the next 2-3 years but hopefully sooner 🤞
Over 2 million fixed rate mortgages end next year, and if mortgage rates remain high, I suspect a lot more properties will come onto the market at a fair price
@jjcrhh House prices are not included in the inflation measure. Rents are included in CPIH.
Nominal property prices have failed to keep pace with inflation, so in real terms, the average house is worth roughly what it was 24 years ago
I live in London. And my decision isn’t actually about it being an investment, but I do consider value for money.
My rent is £36k a year. The interest on a mortgage to buy the same property is about £40k. Just the interest.
So then it becomes a decision: do we deplete six-figures of cash savings on the deposit and stamp duty, going back to zero savings, or keep the cash growing and pay the same in rent as we’d pay to the bank in interest.
And eventually use that cash to buy our long-term home when house prices where we want to live offer much better value.
You’ll probably already see decent value in the market for those type of homes, if you’re taking a long term view on living there.
I have lots of clients/prospects selling big inherited properties but they’re reluctant to sell at the price they’re being offered. So they’re considering renting them instead, but they need a lot of work and rental income would fall into personal name. So I reckon they’ll be forced sellers, especially when they see prices falling further.
But over the next 10 years, you’ll be able to cherry pick whatever you want.
Terry Smith runs a ‘quality growth’ fund, where he has always been willing to pay a premium for quality businesses (“growth at a reasonable price”). That philosophy has always been clear in his factsheets and communication.
Anybody with a good understanding of investments (which many IFAs and retail investors simply don’t have) should recognise that a portfolio of high-quality consumer staples and discretionaries, delivering consistent single-digit growth, will benefit from failing and low interest rates, but underperform when rates rise.
His philosophy has been consistent for decades, dating back to his ICAP days (although I do think he’s abandoning some of those principles this year).
The problem is that many investors don’t understand the role of the fund in a portfolio, or the market conditions in which it’s likely to perform well or poorly. They simply look at past performance, conclude he’s a star fund manager and assume that performance will continue.
I have been saying for a long time that Brits don’t have strong opinions or passionate about anything any more. Whether it’s politics, religion, etc. We think we are passionate about football until we go to a game in Italy or Germany. We’re more “keep calm and carry on” and “don’t cause a fuss” kinda people now
If inflation is being driven by supply-side shocks, crushing demand won’t fix the underlying problem. It will just leave high inflation AND a recession.
They even cut rates 6 times last year whilst inflation was above target, so it’s nonsense to suggest they’d be raising rates (or keeping them elevated) in a recession
@trevgoes4th That’s supply side inflation. Raising rates won’t do much to change that unless there’s evidence of it feeding into wages. If we get a recession and higher unemployment, they’ll need to cut rates into higher inflation