A disappointing footnote to the #BharatSummit proceedings: when I got to Hyderabad, I learned that 115 of the 315 speakers whom the External Affairs Ministry had cleared for the event ended up being refused entry to India or having their visas cancelled, apparently on the instructions of the Ministry of Home Affairs. It is completely unclear under what provision of law the government has taken such a drastic step, but it is obviously impossible to reverse it since the conference concludes tomorrow. What a shame that a proud democracy has become so insecure that it must stifle any voices it fears will be critical!
India is becoming a very strange country
An Automobile manufacturer @anandmahindra talks about AI
A Railways Minister @AshwiniVaishnaw talks about GDP & Economy & GPUs
A Highways Minister @nitin_gadkari talks about Ethanol Blending in Petrol
The Commerce Minister @PiyushGoyal talks about manufacturing Tunnel Boring Machines
A Food Delivery CEO @deepigoyal with a background in Mathematics and Computer Science talks about Biomedical Engineering, Neuroscience & Medical Sciences
An IIT Director Kamakoti talks about Bovine Urine and it's impacts on health
Army officers are now attending Religious events conducted by a Godman
And the Prime Minister talks about everything that is either at least 12 years old or 20 years into the future
Seriously....what exactly is going on here?🤔🤔🤔
Antilia, one of the world’s most expensive private residences, stands on land once owned by a trust for orphaned children. Think about the irony: land meant to shelter the underprivileged now houses one of the richest families on Earth. Legal or not, is this morally right?
Hello Ranveer, it is also prudent and ethical to disclose your interests.
Ranveer Allahbadia (BeerBiceps) is an angel investor in Temple, the health-tech and AI wearable startup founded by Deepinder Goyal. While the exact decimal percentage of Ranveer Allahbadia’s personal equity is not publicly specified in regulatory breakdowns, he participated in Temple’s landmark $54 million seed funding round as a prominent angel investor.
https://t.co/2RKg2pqJrz
Dear Temple Team,
Doctors are asking for scientific evidence, not your financial history, personal sacrifices, or business credentials. Stop calling legitimate scientific scrutiny “rage.”
You have responded to questions about medical accuracy with investment figures, return policies, personal reputation, and promises of future studies. None of these constitutes scientific validation.
A few simple points:
1.A 14-day return policy is not scientific validation. Patients can feel better on placebo treatments too. Subjective satisfaction cannot establish medical accuracy.
2.Spending $30 million doesn’t prove efficacy. Medical history is full of expensive technologies that failed rigorous testing.
3.Personal reputation is not evidence. Science doesn’t become more credible because a successful entrepreneur believes in it.
4.Customer investment is not independent validation. Financial confidence and scientific credibility are two different things.
5.Promising future publications doesn’t validate present claims. If you make health-related claims today, doctors are justified in asking for evidence today.
6.Individual experiences cannot replace properly designed validation studies. We need accuracy, reproducibility, clinically meaningful outcomes, and independent testing.
And one final point:
Doctors are not against innovation. We are against asking the public to trust medical claims before the evidence is available.
If Temple delivers what it promises, doctors will be among its biggest supporters.
But science is not a popularity contest, and criticism is not “rage.”
You cannot answer questions about scientific evidence with a balance sheet, a biography, and emojis.
Publish the data. Let independent researchers examine it. Let the evidence speak.
That’s all we’re asking.
@theliverdoc
I don't want to give this more oxygen than it deserves, but this is the antithesis of what a creator response should be when it comes to expert opinion. None of these arguments make scientific sense, (not even marketing sense) but techbros will be techbros 🤷🏼
Since I shared that I was helping my mom fight cancer, I've learned a lot about what a caregiver can do.
Here's my new video where I walk through 5 steps that I'm taking and what I wish I'd known sooner.
The sad reality is that 2 in 5 people in the US will get cancer in their lifetime. If you include caregivers, pretty much every family is impacted.
This is my attempt to share what I've learned with anyone going through the same thing. I hope you find it useful.
📌 Watch now: https://t.co/jLyvoe4UWt
Healthfrauds, I will skip your AI generated slop response and come straight to the points raised on so-called P32 Wellness nonsense founded by celebrity cricketer, Yuvraj Sigh.
Wear your helmets and seat belts. This will feel like an educational crash and thrashing, because you cons deserve it.
Your statement - “Dr Philips, we will skip the insults and answer the science.”
Oh really? You want to skip what was deserving for you health con and want to address the imaginary? Sure, I can play this game. Lets science.
Your statement – “Unlike your argument, Protocol32 is NOT for anyone with cancer, we NEVER claimed it. It is for healthy adults, especially vegetarians who run short on B12, DHA and creatine.”
So why is your product not just B12, DHA and creatine? But a mumbo jumbo mix of more than 30 other components? The other responses you made are like farts in a wind tunnel, they are just critiques of the paper I posted, which means you have no clue about the papers I did not post on the same topic. This is a shoddy way to do healthcare business. But then let me address few other really wonderfully ignorant and health illiteracy proving statements of yours below.
Your statement – “Liver NIH LiverTox rates bacopa and boswellia E, unlikely to cause liver injury. Curcumin and ashwagandha carry a real but very rare risk. Our booklet says so in print, and members get ALT and GGT tested on day 1 and day 90, for subscribers its paid by us. You say 13 of our ingredients carry toxicity risks. Name them, with the dose at which each harm was found, and we will answer each one in public.”
This must be your best-worst proof that you all do “science”. You should have taken the insult, taken the L and stopped doing more harm to your product which was already dead to begin with for “whatever wellness”. The herbs cited carry risks, some risks are larger and known, some smaller – category E (as you mentioned) – unlikely to cause liver injury – BECAUSE THOSE WERE THE ONLY ONES REPORTED AND PUBLISHED THERE IN THE USA (see Bacopa series in India and new ones being reported) – this does not confirm that the botanical is safe on its own, or that it is safe when used together with other botanicals! Herb-induced injury is idiosyncratic (meaning no dose or duration is required and liver toxicity can happen in few hours to few days and even after years of use). You do not even know this basic and is calling me out on “name them, with the dose at which each harm was found, and we will answer each one in public” – man you guys are really dumb and you are selling a health product? GET OUT OF HERE.
Child, or whoever non-medical is trying to respond to me on science on Twitter, you should have been aware of the fact that multiple botanicals in the same product increases risk of organ toxicity. Take the example of curcumin and green tea. Damage with curcumin + green tea is far worse for the person than either alone (https://t.co/gDGU1XPxcj)...
...and you have more than 8 active herbal/botanical extracts; or 11 if also counting the 2 plant-derived carriers in your product AND is going to be the most dangerous wellness product in the Indian market right now. You have ZERO data to disprove my points.
You statement – “Protocol32 is taken every day for years, while most of these trials ran for weeks or months, so we set maintenance amounts, not treatment doses. We do not claim a trial result at a dose the trial did not test. Every one of the 32 ingredients is on the FSSAI permitted list, within its FSSAI limit.”
You have ZERO trials ongoing, done or published to showcase the benefits or objectify the actual harm from this product. FSSAI’s limit does not mean it is a safe limit that can be used on people at population scale. FSSAI will give a stamp & seal in any case because it is Yuvraj’s face on the product and only looks at good manufacturing pracitces - their approval is for a clean factory, not what the product can do to people. Dont be so naiive. Do you think the scientific and public community in India are that stupid? You think you can do this and get away with the con?
Your statement – “Many brands hide their doses in a proprietary blend. We print every dose, form and specification, and even what the raw material costs us. We did that so any doctor could check our work and question it. We welcome that. A clinical trial of Protocol32 is under way, and we will publish the results, whatever they show. Some of your points are fair. Where we can do better, we will.”
So basically, you have no idea about what your product does. Protocol 32 does not have a public Clinical Trials Registry - India (CTRI) registration lookup ID, but your product is already commercially available through paid endorsement and invitation.
You want to do better? STOP LYING. There is no clinical trial underway - it had to be a prospective trial and HAS TO BE registered, which right now, seems to be hiding behind the bushes on the internet. Care to show us the proof of registration?
You want to really do better?
Throw the damn product off your shelves and give that money to help the Government build better roads, provide better facilities in public transports, build bridges that will connect underserved communities to basic healthcare, promote meal programs in school to help children fight protein malnutrition, and help clean our rivers.
Idiots.
It was Modi who agreed to reduce tariffs on American goods to zero.
It was Modi who committed to buying $500 billion worth of American goods.
It was Modi who had agreed to stop buying Russian oil because Trump asked him to.
But according to some it’s the opposition and CJP who are being controlled by foreign powers.🤦🏻♂️
Stop lying @IndiaUNGeneva
Don’t use our tax-payer funded office to lie globally. I am a Member of Parliament & can testify to brutal & illegal clampdown on peaceful protest. We are not a democracy. We are a nation held captive by a bunch of fascist thugs @UNHumanRights
Elon Musk shared reports of Reliance-backed firms' donations to the BJP, stepping up his campaign against the corporate giant he had accused of blocking the entry of Starlink into India.
Details: https://t.co/vktc7F4avF
#ElonMusk#Starlink#BJP#MukeshAmbani#Reliance
How do we know you are telling the truth, @rsprasad ?
You have zero credibility left. You’re a sacked minister who was unceremoniously dropped when you became a liability.
A man who spent years defending every government falsehood now lectures others on “truth”?
Spare us the moral lectures. Your political career itself is built on selective amnesia and convenient outrage.
This is @aakashibhatt and @shantanubhatt95
To the People of India Who Refuse to Be Silenced,
There are moments in the life of a nation when the mask slips, when the machinery of power reveals, in all its nakedness, just how deeply it fears the people it claims to represent.
Mass curfew. Trains halted. Roads barricaded. Modes of transport shut down. The internet blacked out. Loudspeaker announcements warning people not to join a protest. Peaceful protesters being assaulted and violently detained.
Read that again... Let the sheer absurdity of it sink in!
What sounds like a scene lifted from the pages of a dystopian novel is, for those living through it, a chilling reality. An entire apparatus of power mobilised to prevent ordinary citizens from exercising one of their most fundamental democratic rights: the right to raise their voices, to demand accountability, to stand up and be counted.
When a regime ends up mobilising its entire machinery to silence its people, it reveals not its strength, but the depth of its fear: the fear of a people who have stopped being afraid.
I have often wondered that if the current dispensation can deploy its entire might, its money and its machinery of manipulation to silence a single voice of truth; if it can falsely implicate and persecute our father, Mr Sanjiv Bhatt, on trumped up charges without an iota of evidence, only so that Narendra Modi could never be held accountable for his role in orchestrating the Gujarat Genocide, then imagine how profoundly it must fear the day when thousands upon thousands of voices of truth rise together, against them, demanding accountability.
Today, that day is no longer a distant hope!
To every person who has stepped out onto the streets, to every individual who has refused to surrender their conscience to intimidation, to every voice that has risen despite the threats, the barricades and the fear: Your courage will shake the very foundations of a system that seeks to sustain itself through fear, division and intimidation.
You are reminding those in power that a nation is not their possession. And you are reminding us of something even more profound: fear is not the only inheritance we can pass on to the next generation. Courage is, too!
You give hope to those who defended the soul of this country and languish behind prison walls today for their convictions. You give hope to their families, who’ve been fighting long, lonely battles for justice. You give hope to all those who have watched, helplessly, as the democratic promise of our nation has been battered, its social fabric torn and its people driven apart.
But, above all, you give hope to the ordinary citizen.
To every person who has looked at the fractures in our society and wondered whether this country, so wounded by hatred and division, can ever find its way back to itself.
You are telling them, that it can!
That India is not beyond repair. That the promise of this nation has not been extinguished. That beneath the din of propaganda, beyond the walls of intimidation, and underneath the suffocating weight of injustice, the conscience of India is still alive.
For decades, our father, Mr Sanjiv Bhatt and countless others fought this lonely battle for justice and democracy, paying an unbearable price for standing by their convictions. They fought when the odds were overwhelming, when solidarity was scarce, when speaking out carried a terrible personal cost, and when standing by one's convictions meant losing one's freedom.
They fought when the fight was lonely.
They endured when the world looked away.
There were moments when, as daughter, I would wonder whether a society that abandoned its defenders deserved their sacrifices.
But watching India's youth take to the streets, fearlessly demanding justice, accountability and their fundamental rights, you have restored my faith in the people of this country.
The institutions meant to protect our democracy have too often faltered. Sections of the media have abandoned their duty to question power. Yet, where institutions have failed, you have found the courage to stand.
The system may have failed us, but you, the youth will not fail the country!
If our father were free today, he would be walking alongside you, shoulder to shoulder, on the front lines, not as a spectator, but as a comrade in arms. But though he cannot walk beside you, the ideals for which he stands live on in your courage.
When I see you all, I see the hope that the sacrifices of our father, Mr Sanjiv Bhatt, Umar Khalid, Gauri Lankesh, and countless others will not be erased by the passage of time, buried beneath propaganda or rendered meaningless by injustice. Their stories are a reminder of the price that truth-telling can exact. Your courage is a reminder that the values for which people suffer can continue to inspire those who come after them.
History will remember this moment, not simply for the thousands who took to the streets, but for what their presence represented. For the young people who refused to accept that silence was the price of safety. For the citizens who chose solidarity over indifference. For those who stood up, not because victory was guaranteed, but because surrendering their principles was unthinkable.
For generations to come, let it be remembered that there were people who refused to abandon their country to despair. People who dared to reclaim the democratic space that belongs to every citizen. People who insisted that education must liberate, that justice must be impartial, that constitutional rights must mean something in practice, and that a better future cannot be built upon fear, hatred and enforced silence.
And let it be remembered that, when the hour demanded courage, the youth stepped up.
History has repeatedly shown us that no arrangement of power, however entrenched, can forever extinguish the human longing for freedom, dignity and justice.
And today, in you, I see that struggle finding new life...You are not merely protesting the present. You are fighting for the soul of India's future.
An India where dissent is not a crime, where justice is not a privilege, where constitutional rights are not empty promises, and where no one must pay for the courage to speak the truth with their freedom.
Today, you have reminded us that India is not beyond redemption, that its conscience is not dead, and that its future need not be surrendered to fear.
Do not underestimate what that means...
Do not underestimate what your courage means to the political prisoners and defenders of society languishing behind prison walls, to the families waiting for justice, to the citizens who have nearly lost faith, or to the generations who will inherit the country you help shape today.
You may not see the full measure of what you have set in motion. You may not witness every fruit of your labour. But the courage you demonstrate today will become the inheritance of tomorrow!
And that is how change begins … not always with an immediate victory, not always with the fall of a wall, but with ordinary people discovering that they do not have to accept the world as it is.
The road ahead is, and will not be easy. But darkness, however deep, has never made the dawn impossible.
More power to you ... May your courage endure, your solidarity grow, and your struggle bring us closer to the India our Constitution promised us!
With unwavering solidarity and all our support...Always!
@neha_aisa@Cockroachisback@IYC@abhijeet_dipke@SauravDassss@AshutoshRanka@dhruv_rathee@RahulGandhi@priyankagandhi@rautsanjay61@SanjayAzadSln@MahuaMoitra@derekobrienmp@MamataOfficial@kharge@SupriyaShrinate@supriya_sule@yadavakhilesh@ShashiTharoor@nsui
#JantarMantar #delhijantarmantar