Piyush

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @shan3839 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Then according to same logic there would have been no words for agriculture too in CPIE. Why is that Agriculture related terms increased in CPIE even though they were yamnaya pastoralist

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @shan3839 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Same goes for pastoralism. Already told you none logic is clear to rule out one homeland over other.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @shan3839 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 This doesn't proves the absence of fish term. It can't, pastoralism can not wipe out words related to diet.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @shan3839 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Plus it also doesn't shows any domination of pastoralism in the vocabulary too so it also don't fit with Steppe homeland.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @shan3839 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 There is no word for fish/freshwater fish in PIA and CPIE so according to our logic this contradicts khvalysk and stog diet.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Indo-European secondary products terminology and the dating of Proto-Indo-Anatolian. Though i just read it to get evidence related to pastoral words in PIA and CPIE.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Same goes for many site though there's no forced evidence that proves horse can prove a homeland for language. The word for sheep and cow is not in a hell proves a homeland.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Animal names are not the average base to prove a culture pastoral though. And yet these So called nomadic groups didn't have words for herdsmen, cowherd, protecting the herd etc. Also khvalysk and sredny stog relied on meat and fish consumption but we have no word for fish in PIA

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 The word for horse means "swift one" btw it doesn't proves Caspian homeland still. There were NEO-ANA horse in 6th-3rd millennium BCE Anatolia.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 If you ignore the words for animals it has no wide vocabulary for pastoral lifestyle. same as limited vocabulary for agriculture.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Not really. It does shows connection but it draws (?) for the word to mean pasture which means the meaning is unclear yet. Herdsmen, cowherd is also missing. Plus PIA/CPIE shares word for grapewine.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 It still was present, and no it does not make sense. PIA also have no shared word for herdsmen, butter, cowherd etc. And many more. Milk ok, even if i ignore it, it still doesn't makes your point strong. Both agriculture and pastoral related terms are limited in PIA

[अमित्राजित् @indrasya160726]

@Tatsuya9JP @Shaurya3858d @rahowaii @Sassan256424653 @GamerEQ7 What’s your model? Some white dudes invaded, we instantly forgot all our languages, and said, 'Yes saar, you are Brahmins, we are Shudras — we surrender'? That’s your ultra high-IQ theory?

(No R1a, NO proof of ANY Invasion)

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Btw, if you have accpeted same limited words logic of yours, you also can't prove them pastoralist too.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Yes because it can be semantic shift too and you accepted it that "we could never know", if we think Greek was in Steppe then it is absolutely probable for semantic shifting that can be attached to a different land other than farming. I am not saying PIE was extreme farming group

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 Look, the original meaning from mother can semantically shift to mean other thing, and you can't predict it. How you said the root "to drive" can be linked to pasture land but i said it by different way both can't be correct and wrong at the same time.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@beaker_the12224 @SR1_aryan @Tatsuya9JP @KarPritam39929 The thread you made discusses about limited cereal terms in PIA, but if you say the words for field meant "to drive" that doesn't just mean pasture land where cows were drivine it can also mean a field where plow was drivine. It shows no strict probabality of Steppe land.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@Thought_Wander @Indic_Arya_LM @shreyask10x @Gojo_playz007 @LalitAditya1212 Show me that statement dumbass.

[Piyush @_piyush15]

@Thought_Wander @Indic_Arya_LM @shreyask10x @Gojo_playz007 @LalitAditya1212 Understand the word illiterate "not a homogenous" doesn't mean it has added layers, it spaned over centuries of composition, was originally composed by different priest families, one mandala being younger than other doesn't prove shit dumb.