Elon Musk is playing with fire 🔥
India is one of X's biggest user bases. A ban in India by MODI Government would wipe out millions of X’s users, advertisers & creators overnight, and a huge chunk of revenue with them.
It will be a huge monetary loss for X ( Twitter) and its Market-cap might crash by over 50% overnight
@grok how much would X lose in users & ad revenue if banned in India? Give figures with facts 📉
Elon Musk's Starlink India pitch raises a question about business ethics that has nothing to do with whether Starlink is good.
Competition is definitely good for a fair market . Rural connectivity matters. Disaster response matters. I agree with all of it.
But look at the method he is using.
A businessman wanting regulatory approval publicly addressed a head of government, in a post seen 110M times, on a platform he personally owns. Then he called his critics an 'army of shills,' with no evidence offered.
Ask yourself:
1Would any other founder get 110M impressions for a lobbying pitch? Or is that reach a private advantage nobody else can buy?
2Is it ethical to use a public square you control as a pressure tool in your own commercial negotiation?
3If a newspaper owner ran front-page campaigns for his own business, we'd call it a conflict of interest. Why is it 'free speech' when it's a timeline?
4Calling opponents paid shills is a convenient way to avoid answering their arguments.
Business ethics isn't just about what you want. It's about whether you use power that others don't have, and whether you're willing to argue on a level field.
Starlink may well deserve to compete in India. But that case should be won on merit, not megaphone.
Where do we draw the line? 👇
किसी को खुश करने के लिए कभी अपने संस्कार और आत्म-सम्मान (Self-Respect) से समझौता मत करो। 🔱
जो रिश्ता आपको अपनी ही नज़र में छोटा कर दे, वो रिश्ता कभी आपका हो ही नहीं सकता।
स्वाभिमान ही आपकी असली पहचान है! ✨🚩
जय महादेव 🔱
Reality check for @elonmusk 🧵
Starlink Alaska: ₹12,428/month + ₹1.43 lakh setup Indian JIO/Airtel broadband: ₹599/month + ₹1,000 setup
That's 20x monthly, 143x upfront. 😭 . Too costly to afford for a price sensitive market like India
Bangladesh: ~5,400 Starlink users in a year.
Tesla India: ~1,000 cars in 13 months.
India isn't a market you can tweet your way into Elon .
Jio charges ₹599, not "Mars pricing." 🚀💸
Elon Musk is playing with fire 🔥
India is one of X's biggest user bases. A ban in India by MODI Government would wipe out millions of X’s users, advertisers & creators overnight, and a huge chunk of revenue with them.
It will be a huge monetary loss for X ( Twitter) and its Market-cap might crash by over 50% overnight
@grok how much would X lose in users & ad revenue if banned in India? Give figures with facts 📉
Reality check for @elonmusk 🧵
Starlink Alaska: ₹12,428/month + ₹1.43 lakh setup Indian JIO/Airtel broadband: ₹599/month + ₹1,000 setup
That's 20x monthly, 143x upfront. 😭 . Too costly to afford for a price sensitive market like India
Bangladesh: ~5,400 Starlink users in a year.
Tesla India: ~1,000 cars in 13 months.
India isn't a market you can tweet your way into Elon .
Jio charges ₹599, not "Mars pricing." 🚀💸
Reality check for @elonmusk 🧵
Starlink Alaska: ₹12,428/month + ₹1.43 lakh setup Indian JIO/Airtel broadband: ₹599/month + ₹1,000 setup
That's 20x monthly, 143x upfront. 😭 . Too costly to afford for a price sensitive market like India
Bangladesh: ~5,400 Starlink users in a year.
Tesla India: ~1,000 cars in 13 months.
India isn't a market you can tweet your way into Elon .
Jio charges ₹599, not "Mars pricing." 🚀💸
Current price of @Starlink in Alaska: ₹143,397.55 Set up fee. ($1500)
₹12,428.12 Per month. ($130)
Current price of internet in India:
₹1000 Set up fee. ($10.46)
₹599 Per month. ($6.27)
This American guy tried to target “ HINDUS “ living in India and questioned our Network Infrastructure but Grok cooked him .
In short :- India don’t needs starlink as Jio/Airtel are capable players and also in neighbouring countries Starlink has not crossed yet the 5000 subscribers benchmark due to HIGH COST .
Few months ago Elon Musk TESLA did a Failed launch in india and was not able to sell even 1000 Teslas .
India is a PRICE SENSITIVE MARKET and india can eat hundreds of Wallmarts just for the sake of example.
India holds up Starlink and suddenly Musk fans are "outraged" 😂 1.4 billion people with phones, Cokes, Nikes & Netflix. Imagine if we went 🇺🇸-free for a month. Apple, Google, Amazon, Tesla, McD's… your "empire" runs on our wallets. Think before you tweet, not after. 🇮🇳
India holds up Starlink and suddenly Musk fans are "outraged" 😂 1.4 billion people with phones, Cokes, Nikes & Netflix. Imagine if we went 🇺🇸-free for a month. Apple, Google, Amazon, Tesla, McD's… your "empire" runs on our wallets. Think before you tweet, not after. 🇮🇳
Jio/Airtel already covers 98% of entire india
Only 2% mountain terrains and some jungle area might be unconnected but Jio/Airtel are capable players and are already working on it
India is a Price sensitive market so there is no place for Luxury Starlink services
Starlink tried in bangladesh but is yet to cross the 5000 subscriber benchmark so basically there are no takers here
Starlink (@Starlink ) is charging a massive $1,500 "Demand Surcharge" just to sign up. 🔥
That's over ₹1.3 lakh in indian currency More than half of an average Indian's yearly income, for internet.
India is a price-sensitive market. 1.4 billion people won't pay this. Elon Musk (@elonmusk ) should understand that before he plays games with us 🇮🇳
Period .
@grok how many Indians can afford ₹1.3 lakh upfront + $130/month-equivalent for internet? Give figures with facts 📉
@RRS_InnerVoice@aarushisharmaX@elonmusk@bot@SpaceX@Starlink This is my @NyBursApp ID... I didn't need to download its Android app, just typed the URL https://t.co/PRI9nINGjB and entered my email ID to login, only OTP will come.
Data is stored in India, unlike "mainstream" social media platforms that store user data elsewhere.