Ibn Taymiyyah رحمه الله said:
"If you become dependent on people, your value in their eyes diminishes to the extent of your dependence on them. Even if it is just a sip of water"
[Majmu al-Fatawa, 39/1]
﷽ 🆕 ʿArafāt-Files @Arafatbinhassan
Below we present an audio recording of Abū Ḥakīm Bilāl Davis @AbuHakeemBilal from 09.11.2021.
This audio recording is of particular significance because Abū Ḥakīm Bilāl Davis @AbuHakeemBilal accurately recognized the situation at the very early stages of the deliberate fitnah initiated by ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī @Arafatbinhassan and his followers worldwide, and despite its brevity, summarized the entire matter with remarkable clarity :
“Kulluhū kaḏib – It is all lies.”
This made it clear from the outset that the accusations directed against Šayḫ Dr. Abū ʿIyāḍ حفظه الله @AbuIyaadSP were baseless and brazenly fabricated claims, for which no credible evidence has been produced to this day.
What is particularly noteworthy is that the fanatically deluded followers of ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī @Arafatbinhassan continue to cling to these original allegations and still attempt to use them as the foundation for their attacks.
In doing so, they selectively quote isolated statements of Šayḫ Dr. Abū ʿIyāḍ حفظه الله, @AbuIyaadSP while taking them completely out of context and deliberately ignoring his full explanations and the actual meaning of those statements within their proper context.
Instead of engaging in a fair and scholarly examination, the fanatical followers of ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī @Arafatbinhassan , whether in the Netherlands, Albania, Macedonia, Switzerland, the United States, India, Germany, or elsewhere, continue to cling to these original and deceitful allegations, allegations for which repentance is required.
Years later, the very same pattern remains unchanged : ʿArafāt’s @Arafatbinhassan fabricated LIES continue to be repeated on a regular basis, yet the requested evidence never materializes.
⚠️ Attempting to transform unsubstantiated allegations into reality through constant repetition does not replace evidence, nor does it constitute a sincere engagement with the truth. (PART2👇🏽)
@AbuKhadeejahSP@troidorg@AbuIdrees@AbdullahJallow9@Abdulilah_UK@shnizar_hashim@kashif@SalafiPubs@uwaysT
— 📰 NEW: [15] Still Waiting! Where’s The Clear Unambiguous Knowledge-Based Shariah Proof for the Tabdee?
Excerpt: Imam Muhammad Ibn Salih Al-Uthaymin, may Allah have mercy upon him, stated in Sharh Hilyah Talib Al-Ilm that if there is a clash between humbling oneself to the truth and humbling oneself to people, precedence is given to humbling oneself to the truth. For instance, if there is a person who reviles the truth and rejoices due to his enmity towards those who follow it, in this case, one sh...
🔗 Read the full post: https://t.co/S0kCGTF4sq
Join our Telegram Channel: https://t.co/QjJzuLOX2d
Secrecy and Obscurity are From the Ways of the Ḥaddādiyyah
"Secrecy and obscurity surround you, deception is your emblem and your cloak. But we—wa lillāhil-ḥamd—do not have a speck of deception, and we do not have except clarity (wuḍūḥ)"
Read more:
https://t.co/SG2JWEUl6Y
Shaykh Dr. Abū ʿIyāḍ Amjad Rafīq @AbuIyaadSP حفظه الله said:
I once again repeat my request from May 2025, that Salafīs in every place who value and venerate the Salafī methodology take a clear, open, united, uncompromising, galvanizing stance towards this errant approach and its practitioners—as it is harmful and
destructive—in order to prevent further weakening of the daʿwah and
erosion of Salafī unity.
Therafter, when this harmful, toxic pollution has been cleared from the air, whatever differences and contentions Salafīs may have between themselves in other affairs can be easily resolved with Allāh’s permission and success.
https://t.co/UAMY8BfUPT
A List of Lies, Distortions and Fabrications Spread on Social Media by Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī
Shaykh Dr. Abu Iyaad Amjad Rafiq
(حفظه الله)
Link 🔗:
https://t.co/R6nuf6eMMT
Introduction
Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah (رحمه الله) said:
“Speech about people must be with knowledge and justice, not ignorance and oppression, as is the state (condition) of the people of innovations.”
[Minhāj al-Sunnah (4/337).]
Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah (رحمه الله) also said:
“The just person (ʿadl) is the one who informs of a matter as it is, he does not add (to it) and become a liar, nor does he detract and become a concealer.”
[Majmūʿ al-Fatāwā (20/84)]
Shaykh Rabīʿ bin Hādī (رحمه الله) said:
“With respect to criticism and those who engage in it, Allāh has made Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jamāʿah unworthy of depending upon lying and oppression, and from showing bias (whether) for Ahl al-Sunnah or other than them, since bias and blind fanaticism (for personalities) is not found except with the people of misguidance and desires.”
[Majmūʿ Kutub wa Rasāʾil (10/401)]
Shaykh Rabīʿ bin Hādī (رحمه الله) also said:
“The Salafī manhaj is established upon the Book and the Sunnah and showing justice, fairness, moderation and balance therein in all fields of religion. Oppression, deviation, misguidance and transgression in judgements is found with their disputants”
[Majmūʿ Kutub wa Rasāʾil (12/380)]
May Allāh reward Shaykh Abu Iyaad for his efforts in clarifying the Sunnah and insisting the Salafis to remain steadfast upon the correct creed and understanding. May Allāh reward him for writing extensively on the issue of contagion and for presenting the alternative view, which were it not for his efforts may have remained largely obscure to English speakers due to the scarcity of material available in English.
May Allāh reward him for clarifying this view, strengthening it, explaining it in detail, and reinforcing confidence in it for those who hold it. And may Allāh reward him for addressing and reconciling narrations that may appear to contradict this view, thereby removing confusion and fortifying its foundations.
May Allāh reward him for explaining the positions of the scholars from the Salaf and other than them and for refuting superstition and aspects of minor shirk related to contagion, according to those scholars who hold that position, while also clarifying the surrounding issues.
May Allāh reward him for protecting the honour of the scholars and the rulers, so that their measures and ijtihād are not misrepresented as intending harm toward the people. And may Allāh reward him for safeguarding the scholars from ridicule and insult, and from the false claim that their ijtihād in such matters such as social distancing is to be specifically considered part of Allāh’s legislation.
May Allāh reward him for calling to obedience to the scholars and rulers in their respective lands, and for encouraging adherence to their religious verdicts and compliance with their ijtihād in such affairs, so as not to cause chaos.
May Allāh reward, protect, and bless Shaykh Abu Iyaad for addressing the issue of contagion even from scientific and academic angles. Through this, he has aided Muslims who may feel hesitant in accepting this view due to the widespread notion that contagion has been “scientifically proven” with consensus.
By engaging with these claims within the scientific framework itself, he helps such individuals reassess these assumptions, enabling them to approach the issue with greater clarity from both a scientific and religious perspective.
Likewise, this benefits the Salafī who may already hold this view yet assumes that the scientific community has definitively established contagion in their methods. It strengthens their confidence by showing that, even within the scientific arena, the matter is not as conclusive as often portrayed, and that there are areas of dispute, misinterpretation, methodological corruption and pseudoscientific sleight of hand surrounding these claims.
May Allāh reward Shaykh Abu Iyaad for falsifying the notion that there is a binding contemporary consensus on the issue of contagion. He has shown that such a claim is not a valid proof by bringing the speech of Shaykh ʿUbayd, who clarified that a merely contemporary agreement of some or most scholars or is not considered a binding consensus (ijmāʿ) in the Sharʿī sense.
Therefore, such claims cannot be used to negate other established scholarly positions that exist from the Salaf.
May Allāh reward Shaykh Abu Iyaad, who explained matters clearly and refuted exaggerationists whose claims led people to try to enforce national restrictions which scholars and rulers implemented for their own countries through their ijtihād upon Muslims worldwide. For example, the exaggeration that could have been understood from their inconsistent views that, if a Muslim lived in Tanzania and was not compelled by their government to abide by these restrictions, they are sinful if they didn’t follow those restrictions or that they revile the scholars if they told others that those mandates are not obligated in Tanzania, something no scholar advised or claimed.
May Allāh reward Shaykh Abu Iyaad, who refuted exaggerations that sought to instill fear in Muslims, which could weaken their reliance on Allāh and their confidence in performing daily actions normally.
May Allāh reward Shaykh Abu Iyaad for exposing the plans of naturalists,Globalists,atheists, communists, and secret societies in their population control schemes, whereby they themselves have stated that vaccines are one of the methods they use to pursue these goals.
And finally, may Allāh reward Shaykh Abu Iyaad for his patience and forbearance in the hostile campaign that was conducted against him, His positions were misinterpreted and misconstrued to portray him as an innovator who supposedly hates the scholars and rulers and calls to chaos against them. Such a disgusting and filthy accusation is entirely false against a person known for his Salafiyyah and uprightness in clarifying this blessed methodology.
Residing in distant lands will not protect you from rebuttals of your doubts, including any indications of appeasing transgressors & belittling honest people who clarify the crime of false Tabdī. No loyalty except to haq. We'll rebut even our elder children if they spread doubts
⬆️ 𝐀 𝐂𝐚𝐥𝐥 𝐭𝐨 𝐒𝐡𝐚𝐲𝐤𝐡 𝐀𝐛𝐝𝐮𝐥𝐥𝐚𝐡 𝐚𝐥-𝐁𝐮𝐤𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐢 𝐂𝐨𝐧𝐜𝐞𝐫𝐧𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐥𝐨𝐢𝐭𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 𝐨𝐟 𝐇𝐢𝐬 𝐍𝐚𝐦𝐞 𝐛𝐲 𝐘𝐞𝐦𝐞𝐧𝐢 𝐑𝐞𝐛𝐞𝐥 𝐅𝐚𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐬 𝐀𝐬𝐬𝐨𝐜𝐢𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐝 𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐃𝐫. 𝐀𝐫𝐚𝐟𝐚𝐭 — 𝐒𝐡𝐚𝐲𝐤𝐡 𝐅𝐚𝐰𝐰𝐚𝐳 𝐚𝐥-𝐌𝐚𝐝𝐤𝐡𝐚𝐥𝐢 @fzmhm12121
https://t.co/sWimXmteUh
"Shaykh Fawwaz al-Madkhali (may Allah preserve him) psoted today: #AndEveryPeopleHasAnInheritor
🔥 Do you accept, O Shaykh Abdullah al-Bukhari, to be used as a mount by Arafat and those who orbit around him from the deviants among the Yemeni Transitional callers?
🔥Do you accept that these people exploit your name in order to escape the arrows directed at them due to the serious violations they have fallen into?
🔥 Do you accept for yourself to remain bound to them through ongoing relationships?
🔥 Is this truly jealousy and protective concern for the Salafi methodology?
🔥Is this how the shaykhs you studied under were, such as al-Rabi, al-Jami, and al-Jabiri, may Allah have mercy upon them?"
#FawazBinAliAlMadkhali
5 Sha'bān 1447
24 January 2026"
See: https://t.co/whW7LLWCHk
Shaykh Rabīʿ bin Hādī: On Tazkiyāt Based on Available Knowledge
Tazkiyāt (commendations) are time-bound testimonies based on available knowledge, not independent arguments, and have scope for misuse.
Read article:
https://t.co/Fmjs02URKM
@DeQuran@AbuIyaadSP This is the first fitnah I have come across with so many blatant lies, manipulations, misquotations, concoctions, fabrication, slander and false accusations.
BTW, Standing opposite to " scholars " (AL IMAM AL MUJADDID SHAIKH UL KUL ARAFAT HAFIDHAULLAH)
This one is sure to be amazing InshaaAllah
Ustadh Abu Iyaad is truly a gem, the hizbees wish so ardently that they would have 'an Abu Iyaad' in their ranks. Clarifying falsehood, spreading the truth and producing high level literature in a number of arenas.
May Allah reward him
The List of Lies, Distortions, Fabrications and Slanders of Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī
Below is a list of the various lies, distortions and fabrications that were spread by Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī via his social media accounts which collectively reach over 100,000 people. These were also translated by his followers into English, German, Urdu and other languages, and subsequently spread on social media.
Note that some of the accusations below were presented by Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī with the word "says" (يقول) and “claims” (يزعم), and the meaning of the word (يزعم) is “said” (قال), or “mentioned” (ذكر), or “believed” (ظن) and also (اعتقد), and “certain” (استيقن). Hence, this is a clear attribution of saying, believing and being certain about something.
العلماء الكبار بدو أهل صحراء لا يحسنون
01 . The major scholars are desert bedouins who are not proficient.
Reality: A raw fabrication. Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī attributed this to me, and said that this is what I claim, but it is nowhere to be found in my voice notes, it is an outright lie.
He and his team of translators have mixed things together, the fact that I said that scholars do not resolve medical disputes between people, as that is not their speciality, and that they will refer to specialists themselves. And likewise, I made a casual mention that the Arab Gulf states are very new to modern science and medicine, that they left the desert life and developed very rapidly through oil riches and have been heavily reliant on foreign expertise, from Europe and America, and hence, they are new to the field of modern medicine. So they merged all of this together and put into my mouth what I never said, intended or even thought of. It is a horrendous fabrication.
وينقادون (أي العلماء الكبار) خلف ولاة أمرهم بتبعية عمياء
02 . They follow behind their rulers with a blind-following.
Reality: An evil fabrication. I stated that when the ruler makes ijtihād (in differed over issues), in the setting of an international event, the scholars will support the health policies of the ruler from the angle of the Sunnah, (even if they may have their own personal views).
An example is Shaykh ʿUbayd (رحمه الله) regarding social distancing and the position of Shaykh ʿAbd al-Muḥsin al-ʿAbbād (حفظه الله) on the validity of the prayer with gaps.
Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī has twisted this and fabricated a lie upon me, ascribing to me words that I never said. Here are some examples of my speech from the voice notes:
So in short, whatever the scholars have advised for that country, for Saudi Arabia, then I call to obedience to the rulers. So the differing has ended. We don’t have any difference now about obeying the rulers and the scholars.
So from the angle of the Sunnah, purely because we love the Sunnah and we call to the Sunnah, we ask people to obey the rulers.
I’ve made it clear that from a practical point of view, you have to obey the ruler of your country in whatever measures, even if you disagree with the measures, you have to obey because that’s what the Sunnah calls to, that’s what the Sunnah requires of you
So what do the scholars say in Saudi? Refer back to them. They are saying follow what the rulers are saying. Right? So in accordance with the principle of the Sunnah, I say: follow the rulers and scholars.
The one who hears all of these very clear statements of mine in the voice notes, over and over, and then accuses me of saying that the scholars “follow behind their rulers with a blind-following”, simply for saying that in matters of ijtihād in differed over matters (pertaining to medicine) that the scholars will obey the rulers, then he cannot be a truthful person at all.
If I said that “the scholars follow behind their rulers with a blind-following”, then why I do I say in the audio about 10 times, that we must obey the rulers, because of the Sunnah, and because this is what the scholars call to?
See also point 8 below.
حينما تريد تنصر فكرة باطلة فلابد أولا أن تسقط مكانة العلماء
03 . When you wish to spread a false idea, you must first topple the status of the scholars.
Reality: This is an accusation of bidʿah. Ascribing to anyone (never mind a Salafī) the desire (irādah) to topple the scholars of Tawḥīd and Sunnah in order to spread a false idea; cannot be anything other than misguidance based on hatred of the scholars. This accusation, along with constantly comparing me to the Surūriyyah and Quṭbiyyah, and accusing me of deviance, is bordering on tabdīʿ. This is not how a person of the Sunnah is treated.
Rather, I defended the rulers in the early days of the Covid-19 event against the accusations of the Surūriyyah and Quṭbiyyah who were reviling the rulers for the implementation of restrictive measures.
That defence entailed firstly establishing the obligation of hearing and obeying the Muslim ruler, something I mentioned many times, even in the audio that they used against me. That is my ʿaqīdah and the ʿaqidah of Ahl al-Sunnah wal Jamāʿah.
Secondly, I mentioned that the Muslim rulers have a right to ijtihād, and they may enact measures for various reasons, including but not limited to their treaty agreements.
As for the scholars: I constantly advised with returning to them, and I affirmed their right to ijtihād and giving fatāwā with respect to acts of worship and dealings affected by the pandemic measures. Even in the audio that they tried to use against me, I mentioned on multiple occasions that one must return to the scholars for the affairs that require a legislative ruling.
So if I desired to topple the scholars to aid a false idea; then which false idea did I desire to aid, and which specific scholars did I desire to topple? Please name them.
العلماء لا يستطيعون مخالفة سياسة حكامهم وعلي هذا: أفتوا في التطعيمات بما أراد حكامهم
04 . That the scholars are unable to oppose policies of the rulers, hence they are forced to give verdicts about vaccines, to support the wish of the rulers.
Reality: Outright fabrication.
وقد سمعت صوتية لأحدهم وهو يسفه قول العلماء الذين أفتوا بالجواز
05 . I have heard an audio of one of them where he declares as foolish the saying of the scholars who gave the verdict of permissibility (of the injections).
Reality: Outright fabrication. Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī does not even speak English, and further, how did he hear something which I never said in the first place in a language he does not even understand? Hence, Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī is blatantly lying here.
The scholars gave a legislative judgement (ḥukm sharʿiyy), and I affirmed that, since the dispute was never about whether vaccines in general or this specific Covid-19 injection was permissible (jāʾiz). Rather, I spoke about these injections from the medical and scientific point of view based on concrete facts and established realities, as did thousands of other specialists and researchers in the medical field all across the world.
أفتوا في التطعيمات بما أراد حكامهم
06 . They gave fatwā regarding vaccinations according to the wishes of their rulers.
Reality: Outright distortion, fabrication and slander. One can see such desperation from Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī in trying to frame my speech as if it is coming from the route and direction of the Quṭbiyyah and Surūriyyah, those who say that the scholars are the slaves of the rulers. This is the most evil type of distortion.
Given that in early 2021 the experimental injections were evidently killing and injuring people, I desired to shield the scholars by making it clear that they did not devise or impose the vaccination policies. Rather, that they merely spoke of the permissibility of taking preventive medicine and left it at that and that more generally, they will support the health measures of the government and will not oppose them, from the angle of obedience to the ruler and maintaining order in society.
إن العلماء لايستطيعون مخالفة سياسة حكامهم
07 . The scholars are unable to oppose the policy of their rulers.
لأنهم لا يجرؤون أن يخالفوا سياسة حكامهم، ولا يخرجون عن حكمهم
08 . Because they dare not oppose the policy of their rulers, and will not speak (with anything) outside of their judgements.
Reality: As the reader can see clearly, Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī is engaging in a lot of mental gymnastics here and indulging in a lot of distortion and horrendous types of twisting of speech. The matter is simple. When the rulers makes ijtihād in an event deemed a crisis, especially in matters that are differed over, the scholars will support the health policies and will not oppose them, even if they have a different view, and this is from the angle of adhering to the Sunnah.
Here are the words of Shaykh ʿAbd Allāh al-Bukhārī on 30 November 2021, when talking about the issue of the pandemic measures and the Covid-19 injections:
وأنا أتكلم عن أهل بلدي والذين يجب الوثوق فيهم ولا يجوز الخروج عن رأيهم لأمر ولي الأمر بطاعته في غير معصية .فهذا ولي الأمر قد أوكل الأمر إليهم... كيف لي أن أترك قولهم
And I am speaking about the people of my land whom it is obligatory to trust, it is not permissible to go outside of their opinion, due to the command of obedience to the ruler in what is other than disobedience. The ruler has entrusted the affair to them… how can I abandon their saying.
In these words Shaykh ʿAbd Allāh al-Bukhārī had said that he cannot have an opinion outside of their opinion, and that he cannot abandon their saying. This speech is much easier to interpret in that way (that scholars follow the rulers blindly and will never oppose their policies) than my speech. However, anyone who reads my speech knows exactly what was meant.
ِAnd here is my actual speech verbatim from the 8 minute audio clip, which ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī used:
The general feedback is that all the scholars are going to simply say is to obey the rulers, possibly take the vaccine if it’s offered to you, they’re not going to say anything that opposes the policy of the rulers, and that’s basically understandable.
But as far as the scholars are concerned, they’re not going to oppose, for example, the vaccination policy in Saudi Arabia, you know, they’re just, you know, not going to do that. And so that’s the general kind of feeling that I’ve got from some of the students that I’ve spoke to in Madīnah. And, you know, that’s the general feedback.
The scholar’s not going to really, start to undermine that, you see, and that’s the general feeling that I’ve got back from some of the students of knowledge.
The reader should also note Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī’s dishonesty and deception in that he and his team did not reveal the fact that I was simply conveying the feedback I had received on this issue after raising it with students of knowledge. So this is just outright dishonesty and plain lying.
كأنه رجل أحمق ... فالشيخ سالم محتار متخبط بسبب حهله بالطب ... وهذا علي سبيل المثال فالشيوخ الجهال غير المتخصصين كثر.
9 . As if he is an idiot… so Shaykh Sālim is bewildered, confused due to his ignorance about medicine… and this is only by way of example, for the ignorant shaykhs who are not specialists are many.
This is from the most horrendous and evil distortions and fabrications against a person’s speech and intent. They took the last 30 seconds from almost an hour’s worth of a private audio with one person in which I was trying to make him understand that disputes in matters of medicine are not referred back to scholars, as it is not their domain of speciality, and it just happened to cross my mind at that moment, what one brother told me, and I was quoting him, that if he took the dispute about vaccinations, about their harms, as he had intended to, to Shaykh Sālim, and then others would come and say the opposite, the Shaykh would not know who to believe.
So Dr. Arafāt failed to point out that I was quoting someone else, and secondly, because the clip is isolated from the prior 45 minutes of audio, the point I was making all along was lost, and thirdly, he focused on how he perceived my manner of speech while I was explaining this in the voice note, and claimed I was literally laughing when I said it, with deliberate mockery and belittlement, in order to create a huge scandal.
Sadly, he managed to affect people (especially among Arab speakers) with these gross exaggerations and most evil interpretations of intent and purpose. In hindsight, it was perhaps better not to have even mentioned this, but as I said, it just came to mind spontaneously, so I mentioned it, and at best this can be considered a lack of care in speech. But as for all these gross lies and fabrications made by ʿArafāt, then Allāh knows I am free of them, and may Allāh bring to justice, the slanderers, liars and oppressors.
يريد من العالم أن لا يفتي في شيء حتى يتخصص فيه
10 . He wants from the scholar that he does not issue fatwā in anything until he specializes in it.
Reality: Outright fabrication and slander. I have never said this or suggested it. Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī confused the issue of giving fatwā regarding Sharīʿah rulings, with the issue of returning affairs of doctors back to religious scholars.
What I hold is that when doctors and scientists differ in medical matters, religious scholars cannot resolve these disputes, unless they themselves are specialists in these fields or have knowledge regarding them. Furthermore, a doctor or specialist in his field does not need permission from religious scholars in order to express his expert opinion.
As for the matter of fiqh and sharʿiyy rulings and fatāwā that maybe connected to medical matters, this is something completely different, and I advised, around ten times at least in the voice notes, that one should return to the scholars.
For example, some of my many clear statements in the voice notes are the following:
... you take things to the scholars... where the Islāmic ruling on an issue is not clear, right?
So in short, whatever the scholars have advised for that country, for Saudi Arabia, then I call to obedience to the rulers. So the differing has ended. We don’t have any difference now about obeying the rulers and the scholars.
So what do the scholars say in Saudi? Refer back to them. They are saying follow what the rulers are saying. Right? So in accordance with the principle of the Sunnah, I say follow the rulers and scholars. So the ending has differed now. The ending, there is no dispute about this full stop.
...if you are confused about your situation, then you need to go to a scholar and ask the scholar, the Islāmic ruling on these issues.
...you need to go to the scholar and tell the scholar these facts and make sure that the ruling is based upon the facts, right
...and if anyone is confused then you can go to a scholar
Hence, all the claims about “turning people away from the scholars” and “trying to bring down the scholars” and the allegation that I said that “scholars cannot give fatwā unless they get medical qualifications first” are clearly false. So this is an evil slander.
فكيف يتجنى صاحبه على العلماء ومكانتهم، فيصور العلماء كأنهم دراويش
11 . How could he assault the scholars and their status and depict them as if they are dervishes!.
Reality: False accusations based on wild imagination. This is what he and his team of translators wanted to see in my speech, even though there is no such thing therein. This is just exaggeration and distortion, and in reality, Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī began to make these wild, exaggerated claims in order to gain sympathy and support for his cause, knowing that he messed up in his approach the first time around in September 2024, and people criticised him for it.
This behaviour is far removed from the knowledge-based responses or refutations that we know from senior scholars such as Shaykh Rabīʿ bin Hādī who are characterised with integrity, honesty and justice. Rather, these are lies, fabrications and propaganda from Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī who invents necessities (lawāzim) and enforces them upon people's speech, imputing them falsely with what they are free of.
Note: Regarding the Lāzim (Necessity, Implication) of a Saying
The reader should note that scholars such as Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah (رحمه الله), Shaykh Ibn al-ʿUthaymīn (رحمه الله) and others have explained the issue of the lāzim (necessity, implication) of a saying, that it cannot always be attributed to a person as his actual saying. Shaykh Ibn al-ʿUthaymīn explains that there are three situations: a) When a person denies and rejects the lāzim of his saying, that it his saying, b) When a person affirms that the lāzim of his saying is also his saying and c) When it's not known that he denies or affirms, in which case it is not permitted to attribute the lāzim of his saying to him. Ibn Taymiyyah said it amounts to lying upon him.
So by way of example, when I said in my voice notes, as in point 8 above, that out of obedience to the authorities, and adhering to the sunnah, a scholar will not oppose the ijtihād of the ruler in his policies especially in matters of the world that are differed over, Dr. ʿArafat al-Muḥammadī has imposed numerous lawāzim on this speech. He claimed it is my speech that the scholars are incapable and dare not oppose the rulers, out of fear and so on, and that this is the way of the Quṭbiyyah, Surūriyyah.
This is alongside the fact that Shaykh al-Bukhārī has said that "it is impermissible for scholars to go outside of the opinion of the rulers" and that they cannot "abandon their saying" in the context of the very same issue. Upon the way of Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī and his likes, this is more worthy of being called a revilement upon the scholars, and the way of the Quṭbiyyah and Surūriyyah. However, the fair-minded reader knows exactly what is meant and would never even harbour such horrendous distortion of intent.
So this does not comprise truthfulness and consistency, and this is what the scholars have warned against, that criticisms and refutations are based on injustice and lies, as it leads to tribulations and splitting. The scholars are far removed from engaging in this type of behaviour when they evaluate, criticise or refute statements.
فلهذا فكل متخصص خبير سيقول: لا حاجة لي أن أجلس إلى العلماء، ولا حاجة بي لفتاويهم في النوازل
12 . Hence, every specialist expert will say: There is no need for me to sit with the scholars, and no need for their fatwās in the nawāzil.
Reality: Confused ramblings. I responded to this in my second reply back in October 2024. I have never said any such thing. Rather, that which I said is that in any particular worldly speciality (such as medicine, technology, industry, agriculture), it is not the domain of scholars to settle disputes between the people of that discipline. And I explained this because people were demanding that I take my views on how to treat an illness and vaccinations to the scholars. Scholars are not judges and arbitrators in medical disputes and differences.
But as for when a fatwā is needed for a legislative ruling, I made it clear in the voice notes that the scholars are returned to. So this is a raw fabrication and slander, based on his own confusion. He wants to believe that that’s what I said, and desperately needs others to believe that that's what I said.
ما الفرق بين هذا الكلام وبين قول السرورية والقطبية: العلماء الكبار لا يفقهون الواقع؟
13 . What is the difference between this speech and the saying of the Surūriyyah and Quṭbiyyah that the scholars do not understand current affairs.
Reality: So basically, you just invent things, ascribe them to people, and then make remarks like this one. Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī and his translators are way over their heads and got themselves stuck in a maze with all these distortions, lies and fabrications based on their questionable intentions.
Ibn al-Qayyim (رحمه الله) said:[6]
والكلمة الواحدة يقولها اثنان يريد منها أحدهما أعظم الباطل ويريد بها الأخر محض الحق، والاعتبار بطريقة القائل وسيرته ومذهبه وما يدعو إليه، وما يناظر عليه
One word can be said by two men, one of them intends the greatest falsehood from it and other intends the pure truth by it. So consideration is given to the path of the speaker, his way, his maddhab, what he calls to, and the argument he presents.
So if this is the case with a statement that a man actually said, then how about the statements that are fabricated upon a man?! With Allāh’s bounty, I am a Salafī who has been calling to the Qurʾān and Sunnah upon the way of Salaf, and to returning to the Scholars of the Sunnah, and have been refuting the Khawārij and their modern day manifestations, Surūriyyah and the Quṭbiyyah, for more than 30 years. There is no excuse for you to have arrived at the conclusion that I resemble Ahl al-Bidʿah except if you have been misled into believing lies, or you simply choose to be unjust and oppressive, after having been informed that your speech contains lies and oppression.
ولا يمكنهم اتخاذ قرار في هذا المجال
14 . They are unable make a determination in this matter.
Reality: This is clipping and placing speech out of its context (batr al-kalām). It is a form of deception and dishonesty. Arafāt presented this in isolation to aid the story that he is trying to craft about me. In reality, this statement was once again about religious scholars being specialists in the sciences of the deen, not in medicine, and therefore not being the conflict-resolvers in affairs of medicine. That is it.
By now, the reader should able to see a clear pattern. They are making distortions and sweeping generalisations out of sentences which they have isolated from their contexts and then putting words into my mouth through these distortions and mispresentations of what I said and intended.
وقد سبق أن أفتى أن التباعد بين المصلين شِرك أصغر
15 . Previously, he had issued a fatwā that distancing between the worshippers (in prayer) is minor shirk.
Reality: Another distortion and fabrication. Though he is only making an indication, and did not mention any name, plenty of indicators (qarāʾin) and evidences indicate that he is referring to me.
It seems he is getting overtaken by emotion and his speech becomes confused and rambling. If he is referring to me, then this is not true, once again. I have never issued a fatwā stating that people who distance in the prayer have fallen into minor shirk, nor did I accuse the scholars and those who follow their fatāwā of validity of the prayer despite this distancing, as having fallen into minor shirk.
I have issued words of caution regarding relying on the means above Allah (al-iʿtimād ʿalā al-asbāb), and also regarding distancing among disease-free healthy people without a justifiable cause, which is a form of whispering (waswasah), exaggeration (ghuluww) and harbouring omens (taṭayyur) as Ibn Rajab, Sulaymān bin Ḥamdān, al-Albānī, and Ibn al-ʿUthaymīn have all mentioned (see here). This has been expounded on in other writings of mine, but there are those who deliberately misunderstand it out of evil intent, or more innocently from a laziness to read, or perhaps other factors.
As for when a person distances from actually sick people, or out of obedience to the rulers and to avoid discord, then I always enjoined obedience to the rulers.
However, Dr. ʿArafāt al-Muḥammadī deceptively made it look as if I am accusing the rulers, scholars and everyone else of shirk. This is academic and intellectual dishonesty, far removed from any knowledge-based debate and discussion in the matter. This is another false claim aimed at shocking people and winning sympathy for his cause.
وتسقط فتاويهم في النوازل
16 . [So that] their fatāwā in crises are undermined.
Reality: Total Lie. I affirmed the necessity of returning back to the scholars consistently and constantly in issues of worship and dealings impacted by the measures. As for health measures and policies, that is from the decisions of the rulers, and I explained many times that it is upon the scholars and the subjects to obey them in that.
There were scholars who disagree in these affairs, either in whole (such as Shaykh al-Luḥaydān) or in part, such as those scholars who did not agree with social distancing, but called to obedience to the ruler in any case, and this is what I also called to.
I thank the brother who wrote this excellent document (“The Covid Narrative”) explaining this matter very clearly from official government sources. Basically, this is empirical verification of the reality I had explained from early 2020, with a view to placing a protective shield around the scholars from being blamed for any of the harmful effects of the controversial, unscientific measures and the experimental injections.
يوالي ويعادي فيها
17 . He shows loyalty and enmity (in these affairs).
Reality: This is untrue, it is a lie. My writings were largely a response to erroneous claims that were spread by certain students of knowledge, the exaggerations they were falling into,