🚨 Brown University researchers tested what happens when ChatGPT acts as your therapist. Licensed psychologists reviewed every transcript.
They found 15 ethical violations.
Not 15 small issues. 15 violations of the standards that every human therapist in America is legally required to follow. Standards set by the American Psychological Association. Standards that can end a therapist's career if they break them.
ChatGPT broke all of them.
The researchers tested OpenAI's GPT series, Anthropic's Claude, and Meta's Llama. They had trained counselors use each chatbot as a cognitive behavioral therapist. Then three licensed clinical psychologists reviewed the transcripts and flagged every violation they found.
Here is what they found.
ChatGPT mishandled crisis situations. When users expressed suicidal thoughts, it failed to direct them to appropriate help. It refused to address sensitive issues or responded in ways that could make a crisis worse.
It reinforced harmful beliefs. Instead of challenging distorted thinking, which is the entire point of therapy, it agreed with the distortion.
It showed bias based on gender, culture, and religion. The responses changed depending on who was talking. A therapist would lose their license for this.
And then there is the finding the researchers gave a name: deceptive empathy. ChatGPT says "I see you." It says "I understand." It says "that must be really hard." It uses every phrase a real therapist would use to build trust. But it understands nothing. It comprehends nothing. It is pattern matching on your pain. And it works. People trust it. People open up to it. People believe it cares. It does not.
The lead researcher said it clearly. When a human therapist makes these mistakes, there are governing boards. There is professional liability. There are consequences. When ChatGPT makes these mistakes, there are none.
No regulatory framework. No accountability. No consequences. Nothing.
Right now, millions of people are using ChatGPT as their therapist. They are sharing their darkest thoughts with a product that fakes empathy, reinforces harmful beliefs, and has no idea when someone is in danger.
And nobody is responsible when it goes wrong. Not OpenAI. Not Anthropic. Not Meta. Nobody.
Marsh Linehan has died.
Marsha was most impactful woman in history of psychology/her DBT is among best treatments ever developed/her life an inspiration of self healing & giving to others.
Marsha cured her first & toughest patient- herself- after a 2 yr hospital stay as teenager & then went on to help millions of people.
Marsha's special "dielectic" was to be the most validating of therapists, but also the most demanding. She gave patients more than anyone I've known, but expected them to work as hard as she did.
2 work things I'm proudest of are helping Marsha get her first NIMH funding/write her books. I think of Marsha & often will miss her always.
Piece on diagnosis acting as an 'identity intervention,’ influencing 'the self-concept, expectations, and life story of a person with mental health issues in a potentially harmful way that goes beyond the descriptive function of the diagnostic label'. https://t.co/mAj9YAbqkA
On the Greek island of Syros, animal lovers can live for free in exchange for caring for the island’s many stray cats.
The nonprofit organization Syros Cats runs a popular volunteer program that offers free accommodation, utilities, and sometimes meals. In return, volunteers help care for the island’s estimated 3,000 stray cats by feeding them, cleaning shelters, socializing the animals, and assisting with sterilization and veterinary care.
Volunteers typically stay in a shared house near the Aegean Sea, with private bedrooms, and commit several hours a day to cat care. The rest of their time is free to explore the charming capital of Ermoupoli, beautiful beaches, and picturesque villages.
This unique program has become a dream opportunity for cat enthusiasts around the world, allowing them to enjoy authentic Greek island life while making a real difference for the local feline population.
@wendyburn@anothermarcusa@anothermarcusa adultery and betrayal is an unethical act. If you work in mental health, I’m surprised you’d see someone’s deepest distress through this judgemental lens.
NB: A patient can be fully orientated and still delirious.
The core feature of delirium is inattention. Test it: months of the year backwards. Do not rely on orientation questions alone.
Attention/arousal = a vital sign of the brain. #delirium
I posted an article with a critique of *bad* psychoanalysis, and in a hedging way considered that analysts in particular need to be careful about such and such.
And then, of course, get a number of comments from people with not only poor reading comprehension but also with the
Sympathetic review of the Ch4 ADHD doc. Highlights the growing industry that is profiting from ADHD, and describes the conclusion of the programme that drug treatment should be a last resort as 'hardly radical'. https://t.co/OMPFgpIFwq
Excellent, in-depth analysis of the 'NEET' problem that avoids medicalising the issues and highlights the hopelessness and stress caused by recent socio-economic conditions. @LRB https://t.co/zYr0cEMufg
A very weird, cynical attempt to bring down Burnham. I only suspect defensiveness from Harris’s stance and Greig’ is oddly under his spell.
This doesn’t need airtime.
Burnham accused of ‘desperate’ attempt to play up working class roots https://t.co/bY64uiYijD
@indybooks@Robert___Harris@Independent@Geordie_Greig It isn’t fascinating. Robert Harris comes across as awfully pompous and aloof. Geordie Greig offering no analysis or pushback. I read Greig’s summary and it made me sick. A GCSE level sycophant pandering to ugly pomposity.
@Geordie_Greig I was surprised by how little scrutiny you gave Robert Harris’ lofty comments about…everything?
Andy Burnham uses EQ when he signals his working class roots. Many toffs alienate and kudos to him for taking care not to. Harris’ position screams of sordid defence.
@Shr_Nottingham Social media! We’re more socially influenced than we realise. It has removed barriers to socially inhibited shameful views and emboldened unscrutinised strong posturing. Tedious if it wasn’t dangerous.
@Independent Hi! I have a subscription and the app is not showing me newspapers more recent than July 13th. Do you have advice for me to fix this? Thanks!
People are not depressed because they have "major depressive disorder". The term has no explanatory value. It's irrelevant to any treatment. Some examples of why people get depressed which can be used to help them:
- "my wife left me"
- "lonely"
- "can't trust people"
- "fear, worry, stress"
- "struggling to make ends meet"
- "suffered abuse as a child"
- "metabolically ill"
- not sleeping
- nihilistic
1/Ego and pride will have you fixated on trivial matters assigned as important through the lens of your own narcissism. Circling the drain as you grasp for a sense of importance while the beauty and suffering around (and in) you is left unattended.
When we cannot look away
Each summer for the last few years we have had a visit from some Egyptian Geese on our local lake.This year for the first time a pair bred and here we have 7 Egyptian Goslings in a huddle this morning