J.R.R. Tolkien explains why he spent years building Middle-earth before writing The Lord of the Rings.
In a rare interview, Tolkien is asked why he devoted more than a decade to creating the world behind his stories before writing them.
He rejects the idea that Middle-earth emerged purely from his unconscious, describing himself instead as “a meticulous sort of bloke” who spent years working out timelines, languages, histories, customs, and genealogies until everything fit together.
For Tolkien, the world existed before the story.
He even says The Hobbit began almost by accident, explaining that the larger mythology was already in place and that the novel simply became absorbed into it.
When asked why anyone would build an entire fictional world before telling a story, Tolkien points to what he calls “subcreation.”
As creations of a Creator, he argues, humans naturally desire to create. Since we cannot create something from nothing, we instead reshape existing reality into new forms that are both imaginative and aesthetically satisfying.
Tolkien also rejects the idea that art should be driven solely by moral purpose, insisting that beauty and aesthetics are just as fundamental to human creativity.
Discussing good and evil, he explains that Sauron was not evil from the beginning but fell from grace, much like Lucifer. The One Ring, he says, symbolizes a power so absolute that even someone with good intentions would inevitably be corrupted by wielding it.
He adds that this idea long predates the atomic age, noting that the foundations of his mythology were developed while he was still an undergraduate, not as an allegory for modern events.
At the end of the interview, Tolkien is asked whether he would rather be remembered for what he said or for what he made. He dismisses the distinction, arguing that lasting creations endure precisely because they have something meaningful to say.
Source: The Tolkien Professor interview with J.R.R. Tolkien (BBC, 1968), “J.R.R. Tolkien Interview (1968).
@RobotsWon@Davidstout@BernieSanders Progress never comes from socialism. It only degrades through division of society and rots morals and innovation birthing only communism.
@ImMeme0@itsdeaann So easy to rebottle this is crazy easy layups this kid is giving him, but he isn’t taking him. I guess he’s being an interviewer a proper one, but definitely some pushback could’ve been a little clearer
@chaotichermes He backtracked so hard, never answered her question or backed his claim. The Democrats are more patriotic, pivot, pivot, pivot, wonderful signs of bad argumentation sadly, she wasn’t that good at going for the jugular either though.
@7signxx That’s disgusting, horrible conflicting and somehow making less of the holocaust is supposed to bring better or Claire elect genocide. This is a horrible excuse for an intelligent conversation.
Billie Eilish reported me to ICE and got me deported cause I joked about flying to the US and moving into her mansion
She literally said “no one is illegal on stolen land” but called ICE on me
Honestly amazing performance art, I somehow managed to get Billie Eilish and American liberals to endorse border control and deportations
The pain was worth it for the meme