IndianProfessor ©

I'm professor

[Ganesh Kulkarni @iambestganesh]

Ever had a perfectly reasonable suggestion get completely twisted into something extreme — and then attacked?
Welcome to the Straw Man fallacy.
Meaning
Misrepresenting or exaggerating someone’s actual position to make it easier to attack, instead of engaging with what they really said.
Corporate Example
In a quarterly planning session, the Product Manager (Rahul) suggests:
“Let’s pilot an AI-assisted triage system for 10% of tier-1 support tickets to free up capacity for high-value work. We’ll measure CSAT and resolution time closely.”
A senior support manager immediately jumps in:
“So you’re saying we should fire half the support team and replace them with chatbots? That’s terrible for customer trust and team morale. We’ve built relationships over years — you can’t just automate everything!”
The actual modest pilot idea never gets discussed. The conversation shifts to defending against mass layoffs.
As a Scrum Master, what I should think
Did I (or the team) allow the original proposal to be distorted?
Is fear of change (or protecting territory) turning the discussion into a fight against a version that was never proposed?
How do I bring the conversation back to facts without escalating conflict?
How high-performing teams deal with it
They practice Steel Manning — restating the other person’s idea in its strongest possible form before critiquing it.
A good facilitator or team member steps in:
“Just to make sure we’re aligned — Rahul suggested a small, measured pilot on 10% of tickets, not replacing the entire team. Can we respond to that actual proposal?”
They separate legitimate concerns (job impact, customer experience) and address them directly, but without letting the discussion get hijacked by the exaggerated version.
When we attack straw men, we don’t just kill good ideas — we kill trust and psychological safety in the team.
Clear thinking starts with intellectual honesty: engage with the real argument, not the convenient distortion.
Have you seen a Straw Man twist happen in your meetings? How did the team handle it?
#ScrumMaster #Leadership #PsychologicalSafety #LogicalFallacies #TeamPerformance #DeliveryOwnership #Agile

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

एका meeting मध्ये सगळ्यांनी "Yes" म्हटलं...
पण बाहेर पडल्यावर प्रत्येकाचं opinion वेगळं होतं.
Corporate मध्ये silence म्हणजे agreement नसतं.
Safe environment असेल... तर honest opinions बाहेर येतात.
Leader म्हणून question विचारणं महत्त्वाचं... Answer देणं नाही.

#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Office मध्ये दोन types चे people भेटतात...
एक problem घेऊन येतात. दुसरे problem सोबत solution पण घेऊन येतात.

Guess करा... Promotion कोणाला आधी मिळत असेल?

Complaint करणारे खूप असतात... Ownership घेणारे कमी.

तुम्ही कोणत्या category मध्ये आहेत? 👇
#CorporateDiary #

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Corporate मध्ये सगळ्यात expensive sentence माहितीय?

"Assume केलं होतं..."
Assume केल्यामुळे deadlines miss होतात... Expectations mismatch होतात... आणि trust कमी होतं.

Better to ask one question today... than give ten explanations tomorrow.

तुम्ही clarify करता... की assume? 🤔

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Corporate मध्ये एक lesson खूप late समजतो...
"Being right" आणि "Getting results" हे नेहमी same नसतं.
कधी ego बाजूला ठेवून consensus बनवणं... तेच खरं leadership असतं.

Question जिंकायचा आहे... की project?
तुम्ही शेवटचं कधी ego पेक्षा outcome निवडलं होतं? 🤝
#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Promotion मिळाल्यावर leader होत नाही.
लोक स्वतःहून follow करायला लागले, तेव्हा leadership सुरू होते.

Designation कंपनी देते. Respect team देते.

आणि respect, daily actions ने earn करावं लागतं.
तुमच्या career मध्ये कोणत्या leader कडून सर्वात मोठा lesson मिळाला? 👇
#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Corporate मध्ये smartest person होण्यापेक्षा Reliable person होणं जास्त powerful आहे.

Deadline दिली? Complete करा.

Follow through करा.

Trust build व्हायला months लागतात... Lose व्हायला एकच दिवस पुरतो.

लोक तुमच्या skills साठी आठवतात... की reliability साठी?

#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Manager चुकीचा असू शकतो...

पण त्याच्याबद्दल pantry मध्ये बोलून
career कधीच improve होत नाही.

Feedback द्यायचं असेल तर right place निवडा...
Frustration काढायची असेल तर wrong audience नको.

तुम्ही problem discuss करता... की solution? ☕
#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Office मध्ये smartest person होणं impressive आहे.

पण easiest person to work with होणं... त्याहून जास्त powerful आहे.

Skills तुम्हाला interview clear करून देतात. Attitude तुम्हाला career grow करून देतं.

तुमच्या मते career मध्ये IQ जास्त महत्त्वाचा की EQ? 😊

#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@sagarcasm #Paidpost

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Promotion फक्त hard work मुळे मिळत नाही...

Right work, Right time, आणि Right people पर्यंत ते दिसलं... तेव्हाच game बदलतो.

Corporate मध्ये perception ही reality बनते.

तुमच्या कामाची value decision makers पर्यंत पोहोचते का? 👇

#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@Core_punekar मतदान कार्ड वर माझ्या वडिलांचे नाव चुकीच्या पद्धतीने लिहिलेले आहे शिवाय बर्थडे पण चुकीचा आहे.. तरीपण SIR व्हेरिफिकेशन झालं. केंद्रावर जाऊन करावे.. सोपं आहे पाच मिनिटात काम होतं.

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

Corporate मध्ये एक truth आहे...
"Busy" दिसणं आणि "Valuable" असणं यात खूप फरक असतो.

Inbox full असणं म्हणजे impact नाही. Calendar packed असणं म्हणजे leadership नाही.

Day संपल्यावर एकच question विचारा...
आज खरंच value create केली का फक्त tasks complete केले? 🤔

#CorporateDiary

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@Core_punekar अन्नदाता आहेत आयकर नको त्यांना.

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@PuneDistrict Where in Kharadi ?

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@GabbbarSingh #paidpost

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@kushanmitra @BROindia Wow what a roads.. Why @PMCPune doesn't get some training from BRO about building good roads.

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@pulse_pune Builder would put on 10 Crore defamation case on people who came forward and speaks on camera.. it happened with few friends 😭

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@mibalajijoshi @MarathiRojgar पर्यावरणा विषयी अत्यंत कमी ज्ञान.

Prove it ??

Latur guys in mys hostel used to take 0.5 bucket during bath while West Maharashtra used to take "shower"

Prove it or delete it.

[IndianProfessor © @Bgnasa]

@MarathiRojgar Why the map is wrong..? are you educated enough.?

It's surprising that highly educated and advanced people can make a such fundamental mistake.

Region is backward because of power politics. Don't insult people living there.