@yarkimginamarie@bankertobuilder I will rent out a warehouse for 75 of them to stay and get cleaned up. My friend will keep 7 in his driveway in the suburbs. Most of them will be out parked on lots owned by businesses that don't have shoppers at night, earning some parking rent fee money for doing nothing.
Good review. I would point out that range and charge time only matter on long trips and even then your range will outlast your bladder and stomach. 'Having' to stop at a charger means a chance to do something better than just pump gas and use a dirty restroom. But 95% of the time none of this matters. Compare your EVs on the differences on normal drives to do errands around town, and getting kids and stuff in and out. Tesla FSD is wonderful. Maybe Rivian will surprise us with something as good.
@yarkimginamarie@bankertobuilder Probably not the same amount of cars at 5am and 5pm. Some cars can run at 3am for the few people who need them. Usually they don't run trains all night, 95% empty.
Here is a better comparison in a prompt you can use. "Compare moving 25,000 riders each way per day over a 100-mile corridor by (A) a Tesla Cybercab robotaxi fleet vs. (B) a new modern electrified passenger rail line. Use 2026 dollars. Assumptions: - 25,000 riders each way per day (50,000 trips/day), 100 miles each, 365 days/year - Cars carry 1.2 people each; riders come from existing car trips, so no new roads - Cybercab: $25-30k each, ~400 miles/day per car, ~15% empty repositioning miles, ~4-year vehicle life, charging $0.04-0.05/mile - Rail: new double-track, 125-150 mph, $50-100M per mile* (including land, stations, trains, electrification), ~72 trains/day each way, $40-60 per train-mile operating cost - Annualize capital over 40 years at 4% Give me a side-by-side table showing for each option: 1. Upfront cost (with a breakdown) 2. Annual operating cost (energy, maintenance, labor/remote ops, insurance, vehicle replacement) 3. All-in annual cost with capital annualized 4. Cost per one-way trip Show the math for fleet size and train-miles, check that your line items add up to your totals, and end with a short conclusion on which is cheaper and what the numbers leave out (safety, congestion, emissions)."
[*I didn't use the $250β470 million per mile for the California high speed rail line]
Result: The autonomous vehicle costs a little more than half per ride over 40 years.
They *could* both exist. But, I don't think the train offers advantages. Hypothetically, if a new city started 100 miles from an existing city in an unpopulated area, it might make sense to have a rail line between them versus making a highway. I think I would still prefer to ride in my own space private car and get transported directly to the door of where I'm going. When I rode a train, my partner drove me to the train station and picked me up. I occasionally rode my bike, but often it was raining, icy or dark. So, even in the situation where the highway needs to be built, I would rather ride in an autonomous car.
Faster: If you don't count getting to and from the station. But, I give you this one.
Cheaper: The annualized cost of capital to build a train line is huge. It makes a train twice as expensive. I gave an AI prompt in this thread so you can compare the costs yourself.
Accessible to the poor: The unsubsidized cost of a train ticket would be almost double than a robotaxi because of the cost to build train system. You could always subsidize robotaxis for the poor, if that is important.
Disabled: If you can get on a train, you can get into a car? Maybe not. We will need some special vehicles for differently-abled folks.
Frees up highways: If you eliminated human drivers, or a good fraction of them, travel time will go down. Speed could go up very high without sacrificing safety if they were all autonomous.
Pedestrians: Are you counting suicide by train? People being shoved in front of trains?
No. I was talking about autonomous cars with 1-4 people in each. They come to pick you up at your home, and drive on a highway, and drop you off at your work or for shopping. A different car drives you back the other way. We already own the roads so we don't need to build a rail line(s) which adds most of the cost of a train.
In an autonomous car, just like on the train, you can read or watch a movie. But in a car, you can also crank up your music. Nobody is coughing on you or being noisy or smelly or violent.
The cost to go 100 miles would be about $20 for the cybercab vs an unsubsidized cost of about $40 for the rail line (not counting getting to the station and to work from the other station).
I'm hypothesizing that even in a semi-rural area a robotaxi will be 5-15 minutes away. It's not a total loss: If you take a 5-15 minute ride in it, you can do things for those 5-15 minutes, like keep scrolling social media or watch an educational video.
I'm also hypothesizing that a lot of people will want to own one or more of these robotaxi cars AND will want to put them to work (when they aren't using them). That's a different incentive from Uber. Yes, right now I am living in a semi-rural area outside Raleigh, and I take Uber to the airport frequently. I pre-book, but it takes about 30 minutes from when the driver gets into the car until it arrives. Robotaxi has to be 3 times better, so 3 times as many vehicles available, but I think it will be.
I will also point out that in olden times, the idea that I would not go to the store in my own car, right then when I wanted, and buy my own groceries or my own electronics was crazy. Now, I plan ahead and wait a day or three for my stuff and am very happy that someone brings it to my door. The advantages of not shopping in stores far outweigh the disadvantages of waiting for me.
"add to the financial strain of car dependency"
Calculate the total costs. Here is a prompt you can use.
"Compare moving 25,000 riders each way per day over a 100-mile corridor by (A) a Tesla Cybercab robotaxi fleet vs. (B) a new modern electrified passenger rail line. Use 2026 dollars. Assumptions: - 25,000 riders each way per day (50,000 trips/day), 100 miles each, 365 days/year - Cars carry 1.2 people each; riders come from existing car trips, so no new roads - Cybercab: $25-30k each, ~400 miles/day per car, ~15% empty repositioning miles, ~4-year vehicle life, charging $0.04-0.05/mile - Rail: new double-track, 125-150 mph, $50-100M per mile* (including land, stations, trains, electrification), ~72 trains/day each way, $40-60 per train-mile operating cost - Annualize capital over 40 years at 4% Give me a side-by-side table showing for each option: 1. Upfront cost (with a breakdown) 2. Annual operating cost (energy, maintenance, labor/remote ops, insurance, vehicle replacement) 3. All-in annual cost with capital annualized 4. Cost per one-way trip Show the math for fleet size and train-miles, check that your line items add up to your totals, and end with a short conclusion on which is cheaper and what the numbers leave out (safety, congestion, emissions)."
[*I didn't use the $250β470 million per mile for the California high speed rail line]
The autonomous vehicle costs a little more than half per ride over 40 years. And, how to get from your home to the station and then to work?
If you owned your vehicle, when you got to work you could let it be a taxi for other people and make some money for you.
The 'financial strain of car dependency' must be assuming that taxpayers are going to pay for the train, but not for the cars?
Also, since we already own the highways, we don't have to displace farms, homes or businesses to build the rail lines and stations.
@realKyleKeegan It's Marxist opposite world where telling someone to take down speech is not censorship, peaceful protests involves looting, racism is treating people the same, criminals are the victims, and fairness uses confiscation.
@SeanMalarkey@theBocker70@Spikels I think they will sell to businesses that buy cybercabs and run them. The owner (you) will use the cybercab when they want.